HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Criminal Appeal1976

CHAN KEUNG v. THE QUEEN

Related cases with same parties

  • CAAR10/1992THE QUEEN v. WONG MOK DIN
  • CAAR11/1986THE QUEEN v. CHUNG WAI-YIU
  • CAAR12/1986THE QUEEN v. HSU SAI-MAN AND ANOTHER
  • CAAR15/1986THE QUEEN v. WU KAM MING AND OTHERS
  • CAAR15/1987THE QUEEN v. LEUNG WING FAI
  • CAAR16/1987THE QUEEN v. PANG CHEUNG KIM
  • CAAR19/1986THE QUEEN v. CHAN CHI MAN
  • CAAR22/1986THE QUEEN v. WONG TAK-CHI
  • CAAR23/1986THE QUEEN v. MA LAI WU AND OTHERS
  • CAAR4/1986THE QUEEN v. LY XUONG THANH
  • CAAR5/1986THE QUEEN v. YEUNG KAM-WAH (D1) AND ANOTHER
  • CAAR8/1986THE QUEEN v. ALBERT STANLEY MALIA
  • CAAR9/1986THE QUEEN v. CHU TAI WAI AND ANOTHER
  • CAAR9/1989THE QUEEN v. CHAN KOON KWOK ARTHUR
  • CACC1000/1976LAI FAT v. THE QUEEN
  • CACC1000/1983THE QUEEN v. LEE HEI KEUNG
  • CACC1001/1979LAW WAI-MING AND ANOTHER v. THE QUEEN
  • CACC100/1972LIU KAM-MAN v. THE QUEEN
  • CACC100/1973LO WAI KEUNG v. THE QUEEN
  • CACC100/1977TAM YUK-MUI (F) v. THE QUEEN
5362-EN-1976-06-19

CHAN KEUNG v. THE QUEEN

HTML content

CACC000542/1976

  

IN THE SUPREME COURT 
  
 CRIMINAL APPEAL
 1976 No.542

  

BETWEEN:  
 CHAN KeungAppellant
 and 
 THE QUEENRespondent

Coram: Briggs, C.J.

Date of Judgment: 19th June, 1976.

  

-----------------

JUDGMENT

-----------------

  

1. The appellant pleaded guilty to being in possession of a false Hong Kong Certificate of Identity and was sentenced to a fine of $250. He appeals against his sentence.

2. In 1973, the appellant wished to travel to the United Kingdom. He applied for a Certificate of Identity and stated in his declaration that he was born in Toi Shan, China. Accordingly, a Certificate of Identity was issued to him with those particulars.

3. In November, 1975 the appellant applied for naturalization as a British Subject. On this occasion he stated that he was born in Hong Kong, which appears to be the truth. It will be noted that the appellant, when applying for a Certificate of Identity was not trying to get the benefit of the privilege of being born in Hong Kong. His parents came from Toi Shan and his two elder brothers were born there.

4. This can, in a sense, be said to be a stale offence and it is of its kind a trivial offence but one which may well have serious consequences if the appellant wishes to apply again for naturalization.

5. The appellant has an excellent work record. He is employed in the Taikoo Dockyard and has been so employed with the same employers for some thirty years. He also is a man of public spirit and has served the public both in the Auxiliary Police Force and the St. John's Ambulance Brigade.

6. Mr. Sedgwick, who appeared for the appellant, asked the court to allow the appeal to the extent that a conviction be not recorded.

7. In the circumstances of this case, particularly taking note of the excellent character the appellant bears, I think that justice would best be done if the sentence is varied so that the appellant is given an absolute discharge. The fine, if paid, must be returned to the appellant.

  

  

 ...(illegible)
 (Geoffrey Briggs)
 Chief Justice.

  

Representation:

Sedgwick (Tong & Ip) for appellant.

Miss Beeson for crown.