HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Civil Action2000

DR PAUL KI PING KI AND ANOTHER v. SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE

Related cases with same parties

  • CAAR10/1997SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. WONG KWONG FEI and Another
  • CAAR10/1998SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. HUI SIU MAN, RICKY
  • CAAR10/2007SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. CHOI SUI HEY
  • CAAR10/2010SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. AMINA MARIAM BOKHARY
  • CAAR10/2011SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. YAN SHEN
  • CAAR10/2021SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. CHAN KIN PONG BONNY
  • CAAR11/2001SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. CHEUNG CHUN-CHIN & OTHERS
  • CAAR11/2006SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. CHUNG YUI HUNG
  • CAAR11/2007SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. MA KWAI CHUN
  • CAAR11/2010SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. CHAN CHUN FAI
  • CAAR11/2011SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. KAN BRIAN PING CHEE
  • CAAR11/2021SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. PASTANA CARVALHO ANDREZA NARELY
  • CAAR11/2022SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. TAM YING YUEN
  • CAAR1/1999SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. KWAN CHI CHEONG AND OTHERS
  • CAAR1/2002SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. CHAN BOON NING
  • CAAR1/2003SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. TSO TSZ KIN
  • CAAR1/2004SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. WONG KWOK KAU
  • CAAR1/2005SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. LI MAN TAK AND OTHERS
  • CAAR1/2006SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. CHAU WAN FUN
  • CAAR1/2007SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. CHIU CHUN WAI AND ANOTHER
38876-EN-2000-04-11

DR PAUL KI PING KI AND ANOTHER v. SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE

HTML content

HCA000010/2000

HCA 10/2000

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO. 10 OF 2000

____________

BETWEEN
(1) DR PAUL KI PING KIPlaintiffs/
(2) HONG KONG WASHINGTON COMPANYAppellants
AND
SECRETARY FOR JUSTICEDefendant/
Respondent

____________

Coram: Hon Chung J in Chambers

Date of Hearing: 7 April 2000

Date of Handing Down Judgment: 11 April 2000

 

_______________

J U D G M E N T

_______________

 

1. This is the Plaintiffs' appeal against the order of Master Barnes dated 6 March 2000 when she struck out the Statement of Claim herein and dismissed this action.

2. The Writ of Summons therein was issued on 1 January 2000. In essence 2 claims are made against the Defendant:-

(a) defamation by way of a letter dated 9 February, 1993 from the Department of Health which was published in an issue of the "Next" magazine dated 28 May 1993;

(b) despite the drug "Retrogen" (which was invented by the Plaintiffs) having been proven and authorized by the Chinese Government to be a safe drug, the Department of Health (represented in this action by the Defendant) has wrongfully refused to register the drug.

3. In relation to the claim set out in point (a) above, the Defendant supports the learned Master's order and argues that:-

(1) this action is time-barred pursuant to s. 4(1)(a) of the Limitation Ordinance, Cap. 347;

(2) issues identical or similar to those litigated in HCA 12669 of 1995 and HCA 8071 of 1994 are raised herein.

4. The Plaintiffs' answers to those arguments are as follows. First, it took a long time for the earlier actions to come to an end. Secondly, the Judges in the earlier actions were incompetent and did not understand Chinese properly. Thirdly, the Plaintiff was deprived of trials by juries in those actions. Fourthly, the Plaintiff is claiming for financial loss in the present action, and therefore it is different from the earlier actions. Save as aforesaid, the Plaintiffs do not dispute that the claims herein are identical or similar to those raised in the said 2 actions. Having perused the court documents, I do not find this can be disputed.

5. With respect, I do not consider that any of the Plaintiff's answers to be valid. On the contrary, I entirely agree with the Defendant's arguments set out above.

6. In relation to the claim set out in point (b) above, the Defendant also supports the Master's order and argues that:-

(1) it is a claim in public law and should have been brought by way of judicial review;

(2) in any event, the matter was identical or similar to that advanced in HCA 12669 of 1995 and was dealt with in Registrar Betts' Order therein dated 18 July 1996 when he struck out that part of the Plaintiff's claim.

7. The Plaintiffs did not advance other arguments in answer. Similar to the conclusion reached in relation to point (a) above, I also do not consider any of their earlier answers to be valid in relation to point (b) above. I also agree with the Defendant's arguments set out above.

8. For the above reasons, I agree with the Master's order and dismiss this appeal.

9. There will be a costs order nisi pursuant to R.S.C. Ord. 42 r. 5B(6) that the costs of this appeal are to be paid by the Plaintiffs to the Defendant to be taxed if not agreed.

 

 

(Andrew Chung)
Judge of the Court of First Instance

 

Representation:

Appellants: Dr Paul Ki Ping Ki, in person

Ms Jenny Fung, of Secretary for Justice, for the Respondent