HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
2005

NG YAT CHI AND ANOTHER v. CHINA RESOURCES (HOLDINGS) CO LTD AND OTHERS

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV204/2000NG YAT CHI v. MAX SHARE LTD. AND ANOTHER
  • CACV252/1996NG YAT CHI AND ANOTHER v. MAX SHARE LTD AND ANOTHER
  • CACV414/2002NG YAT CHI v. MAX SHARE LTD AND ANOTHER
  • FACV3/1997NG YAT CHI v. MAX SHARE LTD AND ANOTHER
  • FACV5/2004NG YAT CHI v. MAX SHARE LTD AND ANOTHER
  • FAMV1/1997MAX SHARE LTD AND ANOTHER v. NG YAT CHI
  • FAMV19/2001NG YAT CHI v. MAX SHARE LTD. AND ANOTHER
  • HCA2039/2002NG YAT CHI v. MAX SHARE LTD.
  • HCA424/2005NG YAT CHI AND ANOTHER v. CHINA RESOURCES (HOLDINGS) CO LTD AND OTHERS
  • HCA6115/1988CHOY BING WING v. NG YAT CHI
  • HCCW321/1996NG YAT CHI v. MAX SHARE LTD. AND ANOTHER

Files (3)

105063-EN-2016-07-27

NG YAT CHI v. CHINA RESOURCES (HOLDINGS) CO LTD AND OTHERS

HTML content

CACV 2 63/2005

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO 263 OF 2005

(ON APPEAL FROM HCA NO 424 OF 2005)

________________________

BETWEEN

 NG YAT CHI1st Plaintiff
 CHOY BING WING2nd Plaintiff
 and
 CHINA RESOURCES (HOLDINGS) COMPANY LIMITED1st Defendant
 MAX SHARE LIMITED2nd Defendant
 CHINA RESOURCES ENTERPRISES LIMITED3rd Defendant
 SECURITIES AND FUTURES COMMISSION4th Defendant

________________________

Before: Hon Lam VP, Kwan JA and G Lam J in Court
Date of Judgment: 27 July 2016

________________________

J U D G M E N T

________________________

Hon Lam VP (giving the Judgment of the Court):

1. On 20 May 2016, the court (Lam VP and G Lam J) handed down a decision in respect of an appeal by the 2nd Plaintiff from the directions given by Yeung VP on 3 May 2016 regarding the preparation of bundles and the conduct of the appeal in CACV 263/2005.

2. On 26 May 2016, the 2nd Plaintiff issued a Motion seeking an order that the 2nd Plaintiff “do have fundamental rights to the Court of Final Appeal” from the judgment of 20 May 2016.  The 2nd Plaintiff intituled his motion as “Application for motion re-directed to CFA based upon articles 35 and 158 of the Basic Law to procure authentic transcripts for appeal”, CACV 263/2005.

3. In substance, we treat the motion as an application for leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal.  The criteria for the grant of leave to appeal in civil matters are set out in Section 22 of the Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal Ordinance. 

4. Directions were given for the disposal of the application without an oral hearing.  The 2nd Plaintiff queried the court’s jurisdiction to process the application on papers.  The answer lies in Order 59 Rule 14A which gives this court the power to determine interlocutory application without a hearing on the basis of written submissions only.

5. Is the present application an interlocutory one? Applying the application test as prescribed by the Court of Final Appeal in Shell Hong Kong Ltd v Yeung Wai Man Kiu Yip Co Ltd (2003) 6 HKCFAR 503, as the present application would not finally determine the relevant underlying issues in CACV 263 of 2005 if the 2nd Plaintiff were to get leave, the application is classified as an interlocutory application.  Thus, Order 59 Rule 14A is applicable.

6. In respect of the merits of the application, the 2nd Plaintiff has not set out any question of great general or public importance in the motion.  Nor did he explain why leave should exceptionally be granted based on the “otherwise limb” in Section 22.

7. We therefore dismiss the application of 26 May 2016.

(M H Lam)
Vice President
(Susan Kwan)
Justice of Appeal
(Godfrey Lam)
Judge of the
Court of First Instance

 

2nd plaintiff acting in person

No submissions by Clifford Chance, for the 4th defendant

104111-EN-2016-05-20

NG YAT CHI AND ANOTHER v. CHINA RESOURCES (HOLDINGS) CO LTD AND OTHERS

HTML content

CACV 263/2005

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO 263 OF 2005

(ON APPEAL FROM HCA NO 424 OF 2005)

________________________

BETWEEN

 NG YAT CHI1st Plaintiff
 CHOY BING WING2nd Plaintiff
 and
 CHINA RESOURCES (HOLDINGS) COMPANY LIMITED1st Defendant
 MAX SHARE LIMITED2nd Defendant
 CHINA RESOURCES ENTERPRISES LIMITED3rd Defendant
 SECURITIES AND FUTURES COMMISSION4th Defendant

________________________

Before: Hon Lam VP and G Lam J in Court
Date of Hearing: 18 May 2016
Date of Judgment: 20 May 2016

________________________

J U D G M E N T

________________________

Hon Lam VP (giving the Judgment of the Court):

1. This appeal was brought in 2005 in respect of the judgment of A Cheung J (as the Chief Judge then was) of 12 August 2005. The judge struck out the claim in HCA 424 of 2005 on the ground that leave had not been obtained pursuant to a RPO against the 1st Plaintiff and he further made a RPO against the 2nd Plaintiff. The Notice of Appeal was lodged by the Plaintiffs in person on 2 August 2005. The appeal was set down on the same date.

2. On 9 November 2005, Yeung JA (as he then was) made an order for security for costs in favour of the 4th Defendant.  The security was duly paid into court.

3. On 22 December 2005, Yeung JA made another order for security for costs in favour of the 1st to 3rd Defendants.  The security was not paid and the appeal in respect of the 1st to 3rd Defendants was dismissed accordingly.

4. Notwithstanding that the appeal was extant as between the Plaintiffs and the 4th Defendant, it became dormant.

5. On 1 December 2015, the 2nd Plaintiff issued a summons seeking directions “required due to refusal to release tape recordings over 10 years to show the fabrication of judgment/orders/transcripts committed by A Cheung J in HCA 424 of 2005 be given for the further conduct of this appeal arising from the two orders issued by Yeung JA on 9 November 2005 and 22 December 2005 despite Yeung JA then was fully aware of such judicial frauds”.

6. That summons was dismissed by Yeung JA on 4 December 2015 on the grounds that the application is completely groundless and procedurally irregular.

7. From the records, it appeared that preparation was moving ahead in January 2016 and on 23 March 2016, the 2nd Plaintiff filed an application to fix a date for the hearing of the appeal.

8. In a letter of 12 April 2016, a Master gave directions for the preparation of the appeal bundle.  By a letter of 12 April 2016, the 2nd Plaintiff demanded the release of “authentic transcripts” without which he claimed that the appeal bundle could not be prepared.

9. The Master replied by letter on 15 April 2016 reiterating appellants must comply with directions in his letter of 12 April, failing which the matter would be referred to a Justice of Appeal for further directions.

10. By a letter of 15 April 2015, the 2nd Plaintiff maintained his previous position, viz that “authentic transcript” must be available before appeal bundle could be prepared.

11. What actually happened was that A Cheung J had granted leave on 12 August 2005 for the transcript of the hearing of 23 June 2005 to be provided to the 2nd Plaintiff.  He obtained the transcript.  He then made a request for releasing to him the tape recording of the hearing.  That request was refused by A Cheung J on 26 August 2005.

12. Due to the non-compliance with the direction of the Master, the matter was referred to Yeung VP.  On 3 May 2016, Yeung VP made an order that if the direction for preparation of bundle was not complied within 21 days, the appeal shall be dismissed.

13. On 10 May 2016, the 2nd Plaintiff issued a Notice of Motion seeking to set aside the order of Yeung VP of 3 May 2016.

14. The grounds to support the Motion were set out in the Notice of Motion as follows:

“1. The present appeal has been held at bay due to manipulations by the Defendants and the Judiciary including A. Cheung J (now CJHC), Yeung VP and Lam VP.

2. Yeung VP had been involved in the manipulations including dealing with the Defendants’ applications for security for costs.

3. The crucial matter in the appeal is the authenticity of the transcripts released by A. Cheung J of the hearing on 23/6/2005 but the Judiciary insisted to act with falsity.

4. Yeung VP lately made directions that unless I lodge Appeal Bundle containing the falsified materials, the appeal will be dismissed.

5.  The Order made by Yeung VP is contrary to the rule of law and must be set aside, unless the Full Court of Appeal sees fit to the declarations prayed for herein.”

15. The 2nd Plaintiff made an application for the recusal of Lam VP.  He advanced grounds based on the judge’s judgment in a probate case in which none of the party to this appeal has any connection. He also referred to the striking out of his claim in another case HCA 2351 of 2005. Having heard his application, we rejected the application.  The relevant principles are discussed in a judgment in another instance where the 2nd Plaintiff made a similar application in another case, see Choy Bing Wing v President of Hong Kong Institute of Engineers CACV 172 of 2013, 13 June 2014.  Like that occasion, the 2nd Plaintiff again relied on groundless allegation of judicial fraud without any scintilla of evidence. He also said Lam VP was ugly. Needless to say, that can hardly be a ground for recusal. After making his unruly comments, the 2nd Plaintiff stormed out of the court room before the conclusion of the hearing. We therefore indicated on the record that we would adjourn and give our judgment in writing.

16. Turning to his Motion, Grounds 1 and 2 are absolutely unmeritorious.  Lam VP had not been involved in this appeal until he gave direction on 11 May 2016 for the hearing of the motion.  Further, the materials in the 2nd Affirmation of the 2nd Plaintiff do not disclose any evidence of “manipulations” other than the usual judicial directions or decisions on case managing the appeal and directions for release of transcripts and tape recording.  The processing of the applications for security for costs by Yeung JA was the usual conduct of proper applications in judicial proceedings and there is absolutely nothing to suggest that His Lordship had not dealt with the matter judicially.

17. The only particulars we could identify in respect of the 2nd Plaintiff’s challenge to the authenticity of the transcript of 23 June 2005 appear in his letter of 21 December 2005 to the Chief Justice.  The discrepancies identified by him were as follows:

“ The judge omitted his words the right of a shareholder even holding one share to have the legal right to seek remedy for dividend back spoken in court on 23/6/05.

The judge inserted the issue of Court’s own motion in the transcript to strike out which was then detailedly (sic) canvassed in the judgment.”

18. Having read the judgment of 12 August 2005 and bearing in mind the detailed reasons given in that judgment for the decision, we can hardly see the materiality of these so-called discrepancies in this appeal.

19. Be that as it may, in order to allay the 2nd Plaintiff’s concerns, we would grant him leave to obtain the audio recording of the hearing of 12 August 2005.

20. But that should not prevent him from the preparation of the appeal bundle.  We do not see any merits in Grounds 4 and 5.  Actually, the 2nd Plaintiff had already produced an appeal bundle and submitted the same to the master for approval.

21. We shall make an order granting leave to the 2nd Plaintiff to obtain the audio recording of 23 June 2005 upon the payment of prescribed fees. He can contact the clerk of Lam V-P within 5 days from the handing down of this judgment for the arrangement. If he does not do so, the leave will be revoked. We would not disturb the order made by Yeung VP of 3 May 2016.

(M H Lam)
Vice President
(Godfrey Lam)
Judge of the
Court of First Instance

1st plaintiff, absent

2nd plaintiff appearing in person

No attendance by Clifford Chance, for the 4th defendant

51555-EN-2005-11-16

NG YAT CHI AND ANOTHER v. CHINA RESOURCES (HOLDINGS) CO LTD AND OTHERS

HTML content

CACV 263/2005

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 263 OF 2005

(ON APPEAL FROM hca nO. 424 OF 2005)

_______________________

BETWEEN

Ng Yat Chi1st Plaintiff
Choy Bing Wing2nd Plaintiff 
and
China Resources (Holdings) Company Limited1st Defendant
Max Share Limited2nd Defendant
China Resources Enterprises Limited (Stock Code 291)3rd Defendant
 Securities & Futures Commission4th Defendant

______________________ 

 

Before:  Hon Yeung JA in Chambers (Open to Public)

Date of Hearing:  9 November 2005

Date of Judgment: 9 November 2005 

Date of Handing Down Reasons for Judgment: 16 November 2005

 

_________________________

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

_________________________

  

1.  On 9 November 2005, I granted leave to Securities and Futures Commission (‘SFC’) to amend its summons to increase the amount of security for costs sought to $230,000 with no order as to costs on that summons. I then granted SFC’s application for security of costs of the appeal against the plaintiffs – Ng Yat Chi and Choy Bing Wing in their absence as both of them chose not to appear. I indicated that I would hand down my reasons and this I now do.

2.  On 12 August 2005, A Cheung J (the judge) struck out Mr Ng and Mr Choy’s statement of claim against SFC with costs on an indemnity basis.

3.  The judge took the view that their claims were covered by the restricted proceedings order against Mr Ng of the Court of Final Appeal in FACV 5 0f 2004, an appeal from HCCW No 321 of 1996, HCA No 2039 of 2002 and HCSD No 22 of 2002 (‘the proceedings’).

4.  The judge refused to grant Mr Ng permission to continue with his claim and issued a further restricted proceedings order against him to cover any proceeding that Mr Ng might wish to commence whether as the sole plaintiff or as a co-plaintiff in connection with the proceedings.

5.  The judge also made a similar restricted proceedings order against Mr Choy.

6.  On 25 August 2005, Mr Ng and Mr Choy filed their notice of appeal, seeking to set aside the judge’s order.

7.  On 23 September 2005, SFC applied for an order for security of costs of the appeal in the sum of $150,000, which sum was subsequently increased to about $230,000.

8.  SFC had set out the history of the proceedings, in particular the difficulties involved in pursuing previous costs orders against Mr Ng and Mr Choy in other related proceedings, and contended that SFC would incur additional costs and suffer delay in trying to enforce any costs order against them.

9.  SFC further suggested that Mr Ng and Mr Choy’s claims against SFC were unsustainable and their grounds of appeal were not capable of reasoned argument, and therefore constituted an abuse of the process of the court.

10.  Order 59 rule 10(5) of the Rules of the High Court empowers the Court of Appeal to order, in special circumstances, the security for costs of the appeal and one of such recognized special circumstances is “where the respondent will be likely to encounter undue delay or be put to undue expense in enforcing any order for the costs in respect of the appeal”.

11.  The previous conducts of Mr Ng and Mr Choy in other related proceedings clearly indicate that they are likely to resist enforcement of any costs order. There was no indication that they sought to argue otherwise. They had been given chances to file evidence to challenge SFC’s contention and they chose not to.

12.  I find it unnecessary to set out the history of Mr Ng and Mr Choy’s complains as the judgment of the Court of Final Appeal in FACV 5 0f 2004 has spoken loudly and clearly.

13.  Mr Ng and Mr Choy’s claim against SFC is an abuse. It is likely that SFC will encounter undue delay or be put to undue expense in enforcing any costs order against them or either of them.

14.  I considered it proper to exercise my discretion to order Mr Ng and Mr Choy to furnish security for costs of the appeal and the requested amount by SFC of $230,000 is a reasonable sum.

15.  I therefore made the following orders:

(1)     Mr Ng and Mr Choy have to pay into court the sum of $230,000  within 21 days as security for SFC’s costs of the appeal;

(2)     Until the payment into court of the security of costs, their appeal will be stayed;

(3)     If Mr Ng and Mr Choy fail to provide the security of costs , their appeal will be dismissed forthwith with costs to SFC to be taxed on an indemnity basis; and

(4)     If the order for security of costs is complied with, the costs of  this application will in the cause of the appeal.

(W Yeung)
Justice of Appeal

Mr Jose-Antonio Maurellet instructed by Messrs Clifford Chance for the 4th  Defendant

1st Plaintiff: In person, Absent.

2nd Plaintiff: In person, Absent.