HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Civil Action2013

百州年投資管理集團有限公司 v. 銀泰百貨(集團)有限公司 AND ANOTHER

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV107/2011TU ZHIQIANG v. 合生公司(商號) AND ANOTHER
  • CAMP482/2022郭 (前稱郭) v. 孫 (又名孫) AND ANOTHER
  • DCEC40/2010涂志強 v. 合生公司 (商號) AND ANOTHER
  • FCMP3/2019郭(前稱郭) 對 孫(又名孫)及另一人
  • HCAL1758/2019陳祺豐 v. 林鄭月娥女士 (香港特別行政區行政長官) AND ANOTHER
  • HCAL31/2024蔣言勵 v. 上訴委員會 (房屋) AND ANOTHER
  • HCCT96/2024周惠明 v. 挪信新能源科技 (南通) 有限公司 AND ANOTHER
  • HCMP1801/2023深圳澳銀天使創業投資企業 (有限合伙) AND ANOTHER v. LIU XIAOLONG AND ANOTHER

Files (2)

95439-EN-2014-10-15

百州年投資管理集團有限公司 v. 銀泰百貨(集團)有限公司 AND ANOTHER

HTML content

HCA 507/2013

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO 507 OF 2013

______________________

BETWEEN

 百州年投資管理集團有限公司Plaintiff

and

 銀泰百貨(集團)有限公司1st Defendant
 沈國軍2nd Defendant
______________________

Before: Recorder Ambrose Ho SC in Chambers

Date of Hearing: 15 October 2014

Date of Decision: 15 October 2014

________________________

D E C I S I O N

________________________

1.  This is the 1st defendant’s application to strike out the plaintiff’s claim against it. Although it would appear that the 1st defendant is invoking all the grounds under Order 18, rule 19, Mr Paul Lam, SC, counsel for the 1st defendant, informed me at the hearing that he would rely only on grounds (b) to (d) of rule 19(1).

2.  The plaintiff has not filed any evidence to oppose the application.  The plaintiff is absent at the hearing and is not legally represented. 

The plaintiff’s claim against the 1st defendant

3.  In this Action, the plaintiff is claiming substantial damages against both defendants for misrepresentation, as well as for trespass and conversion of personal properties.

4.  The 1st defendant is a company incorporated in the Cayman Islands and is registered as a non‑Hong Kong company under Part 11 of the former Companies Ordinance. 

5.  The 2nd defendant, Shen Guo Jun (沈國軍) (“Shen”), founded the Yintai Group of companies (銀泰集團) in 1998. The Group has substantial retail business in the Mainland, as well as business in various other areas including logistics, finance and investment in the real estate market in the PRC.  The Group also carries on business across a number of the major cities in the country including Beijing, Hangzhou, Xian, Linbo etc.  The headquarters is in Beijing. 

6.  The Yintai Group comprises various corporate entities.  Among them is one called Beijing Yintai Property Co Ltd (北京銀泰置業有限公司) (“Beijing Yintai”).  Shen is the legal representative (法定代表人) of Beijing Yintai. 

7.  The 1st defendant is a member of the Yintai Group.  Shen is the 1st defendant’s Chairman and one of its directors.

8.  Shen, therefore, has the dual capacity as the legal representative of Beijing Yintai, as well as being the chairman and director of the 1st defendant.

9.  It is the plaintiff’s pleaded case that in 2005, Shen claimed to have developed a landmark property belonging to the Yintai Group at the heart of the business district in Beijing, known as the Yintai Centre (銀泰中心). 

10.  The plaintiff alleged that in September 2009, Shen had made a number of misrepresentations in order to induce the plaintiff into investing RMB 30 million to set up a Japanese restaurant at the Yintai Centre.  In reliance on the misrepresentations, the plaintiff had entered into a 10‑year tenancy agreement in April 2010 to rent units 314 – 315 on the 3rd floor of the Yintai Centre, and had in March 2011 further entered into a joint venture with Beijing Yintai to operate the Japanese restaurant. 

11.  Importantly for the present purpose, it is the plaintiff’s case that the alleged misrepresentations were made by Shen as a representative acting on behalf of the 1st defendant.

12.  Allegedly, in late 2011, the plaintiff learned from a number of press reports that there were serious questions concerning Yintai Group’s claim to the title of the land on which the Yintai Centre was built.  The plaintiff further learned subsequently that the parts rented to the plaintiff for the Japanese restaurant were in fact illegal constructions.  The plaintiff had thus discovered the falsity of Shen’s representations, and this forms the basis of the plaintiff’s misrepresentation claim. 

13.  In addition to its misrepresentation claim, the plaintiff also pleaded that on an occasion in March 2013, a group of about 50 people were sent by the Yintai Group to repossess the rented premises by force.  They had removed the safe containing cash of RMB 2 million; taken away expensive wine and spirits; and caused extensive damage to the fittings in the premises. 

The 1st defendant’s defence

14.  The thrust of the 1st defendant’s Defence is that it was never involved in the development of the Yintai Centre nor was it involved in persuading the plaintiff to undertake the investment.  It has no knowledge about the representations allegedly made by Shen, and it has never authorized Shen or anyone else to make the alleged representations at all.

15.  Materially, as is evident from the tenancy agreement, the parties to the tenancy in question were Beijing Yintai on the one hand and the plaintiff on the other. The 1st defendant was not actually a party thereto. 

16.  The same applies to the two subsequent supplemental agreements relating to the rented premises. 

17.  The 1st defendant also denies the plaintiff’s claim in trespass and conversion.

Further and better particulars of the plaintiff’s case

18.  The plaintiff was asked to provide particulars of its plea that the alleged misrepresentations by Shen were made in his capacity as the 1st defendant’s representative. 

19.  In the particulars provided, the plaintiff went into some detail as to what Shen had allegedly said either by himself or through his assistants on various occasions.  However, despite details of the various conversations, it is plain that the plaintiff is really only relying on Shen’s position as chairman and executive director to support its attribution of the alleged misrepresentations to the 1st defendant.  Insofar as reliance is also placed on the Annual Report of the 1st defendant, the Annual Report apparently adds nothing evidentially apart from confirming Shen’s position as the 1st defendant’s Chairman.

20.  As Mr Lam has submitted on behalf of the 1st defendant, when stripped of the details, the plaintiff’s pleaded case is simply that the 1st defendant should be made liable because Shen was its chairman and executive director.

Discussion

21.  As noted earlier, it is the plaintiff’s case that the tenancy agreement and the joint venture for operating the Japanese restaurant were both made with Beijing Yintai.  It was this investment which had eventually resulted in substantial loss to the plaintiff.

22.  Furthermore, there is evidence from the 1st defendant, which is not disputed, that it was the staff of Beijing Yintai who had all along been involved in the negotiations and communications with the plaintiff in respect of the restaurant venture, and that Beijing Yintai was the entity responsible for that transaction.

23.  In the circumstances, in particular in view of Shen’s dual capacity, insofar as the plaintiff is mounting a case that Shen’s representations were made on behalf of the 1st defendant (rather than as representative of Beijing Yintai), it is incumbent on the plaintiff to plead clearly the factual basis upon which his authority so to act is alleged to have arisen. 

24.  As it appears in the further and better particulars, the plaintiff is in essence pleading a case of apparent authority by reason of Shen’s positions in the 1st defendant.

25.  While Mr Lam accepts that a person in the position as chairman and executive director of a company would generally be taken to have wide authority to manage the ordinary business of the company, he submits however that such a person possesses the authority only in relation to the business of the company in which he or she holds such position, but not that of any other company. 

26.  In the present case, the plaintiff is obviously trying to mount a case by conflating the identities of the two separate entities, namely, Beijing Yintai and the 1st defendant. The matters in controversy relating to the restaurant venture concerned the plaintiff’s dealings with Beijing Yintai.  The fact that Shen was also the chairman and executive director of the 1st defendant does not, without more, support the contention that the 1st defendant has conferred any apparent authority on Shen to manage the affairs of a different company, namely, Beijing Yintai.  In this connection, Mr Lam has referred me to the Court of Appeal’s judgment in Re Yung Kee Holdings Ltd [2014] 2 HKLRD 313, at para 55:

“It is pertinent to bear in mind the fundamental principle that each company in a group of companies is a separate legal entity and it is expected that the court would apply the principle of Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] AC 22 in the ordinary way (Adams v Cape Industries Plc [1990] Ch 433 at 532D and 544F). The English Court of Appeal in Adams v Cape Industries Plc analysed a number of cases …. and rejected the argument that the members of a group of companies constituted a single commercial unit ….”

27.  In the present case, there is nothing in the pleadings and the particulars to support a contention that the 1st defendant has done anything to hold out Shen as having the authority to manage the affairs of Beijing Yantai on behalf of the 1st defendant. 

28.  Mr Lam submits that the same analysis also applies to the plaintiff’s claim based on the tortious acts allegedly committed on 18 March 2013.

29.  I agree with Mr Lam’s submissions set out in the preceding paragraphs.

30.  For the foregoing reasons, I am satisfied that the plaintiff’s claim against the 1st defendant is frivolous and vexatious and doomed to fail.  I would accordingly order that the plaintiff’s claim against the 1st defendant be struck out and its Action against the 1st defendant dismissed.

31.  I would also award costs of the Action to the 1st defendant to be taxed on a party‑and‑party basis. 

(Ambrose Ho SC)
Recorder of the Court of First Instance
High Court

Plaintiff, in person, absent

Mr Paul Lam SC, instructed by WK To & Co, for the 1st defendant

95880-EN-2014-09-17

百州年投資管理集團有限公司 v. 銀泰百貨(集團)有限公司 AND ANOTHER

HTML content

HCA 507/2013

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO 507 OF 2013

________________

BETWEEN

 百州年投資管理集團有限公司Plaintiff

and

 銀泰百貨(集團)有限公司1st Defendant
 沈國軍2nd Defendant

________________

Before: Deputy High Court Judge Wilson Chan in Chambers
Date of Hearing: 17 September 2014
Date of Decision: 17 September 2014

________________________

D E C I S I O N

________________________

 

1. This is the 1st defendant’s appeal against the order of Master R Lai dated 25 August 2014. The Notice of Appeal was filed on that same day.

2. On 25 August 2014, Master R Lai made the following order:

(1)   time for the plaintiff to file and serve its affirmation in opposition to the 1st defendant’s striking out application be extended to 15 October 2014;

(2)   the hearing scheduled on 24 September 2014 be vacated and re‑fixed to be heard before a Master with 3 hours reserved; and 

(3)   costs of the plaintiff’s adjournment application be to the 1st defendant payable forthwith and summarily assessed at HK$5,000.

3. On the same day, the 1st defendant lodged this appeal for an order:

(1)   that the 1st defendant’s striking out summons be heard on 24 September 2014 as originally scheduled by consent; and

(2)   in terms of the 1st defendant’s unless order application requiring the plaintiff to file its evidence in opposition within 7 days, failing which the plaintiff be debarred from doing so.

4. Having re‑heard today the applications that were before the Master, I am satisfied that the 1st defendant is entitled to succeed in this appeal.

(1)   First, the plaintiff had ample time to file evidence in opposition.  In total, the plaintiff had 56 days from 7 June 2014 to 1 August 2014 (both days inclusive) to file evidence.  Taking into account the de facto additional time from 1 August 2014 to 25 August 2014 (when Master R Lai made his order), the plaintiff had a total of some 80 days to file evidence.

(2)   Secondly, the original timetable was ordered by consent.  Indeed, the fact that the plaintiff and the 1st defendant had both agreed to that original timetable, including the 24 September2014 hearing date, is crucial in highlighting the unacceptable manner in which the plaintiff has contested the 1st defendant’s striking out application. 

(3)   Thirdly, the explanations given by the plaintiff for its failure to file evidence in opposition and the reasons in support of its adjournment application are inadequate.  It is important to stress that Michael Chin, one of the directors of the plaintiff, was alleged to have eye illness and difficulties in giving instructions to ONC Lawyers on as early as 18 November 2013.  It was not something which took place after the plaintiff had agreed to the timetable or had sought extension of time in early July 2014.  Further, the medical “certificates” produced by the plaintiff are also unhelpful.  Dr Dylan Chan’s letter is irrelevant given he only said that Michael Chin was “not fit to work”, but he was asked only to give instructions to the plaintiff’s lawyers and not to work. Dr George Ng said, without giving meaningful explanations, that Michael Chin was “not suitable for litigation procedures for the next 3-4 months”, but what he had intended “litigation procedures” to mean was decidedly unclear.   Dr George Ng’s letter of 13 August 2014 (produced pursuant to Master K Lo’s order dated 11 August 2014) gave no clarification or further assistance, and he repeated that Michael Chin was “not suitable for involving in any litigation procedures, given his present mental and physical condition”.  The alleged mental condition was only that Michael Chin had developed “depression” due to eye illness, but there is no evidence of how his mental state has affected his abilities.  Dr Alvin Kwok’s letter, like Dr Dylan Chan’s, is unhelpful as he only recommended Michael Chin to “have good rest”. 

(4)   All Michael Chin has to do for the purpose of the plaintiff’s filing evidence in opposition is to listen to what his lawyers tell him and then tell them whatever he has to say; he does not even need to read any document.    In this regard, I note from paragraph 8 of the 2nd Affirmation of Yan, Sherman Chuek‑ning filed herein on 7 August 2014 that ONC Lawyers had already drafted an affidavit in opposition to the 1st defendant’s striking out summons.

5. For the reasons stated above, I am satisfied that the 1st defendant’s appeal should succeed and Master R Lai’s order should be set aside.

6. I order that unless by 5 pm on 3 October 2014 the plaintiff do file and serve an affirmation in reply to the 2nd Affirmation of Jiang Zhi Xiong filed herein on 6 June 2014, the plaintiff be debarred from filing any affirmation in opposition to the 1st defendant’s striking out application under its summons filed herein on 6 June 2014.  I think 14 days instead of 7 days should be the final chance given to the plaintiff. 

7. Given the amount of the plaintiff’s claim, it is clear that whichever side succeeds in the striking out application, the losing party will very likely appeal.  To ensure costs-effectiveness and the most expeditious disposal of the matter, given the delay that has already been caused by the plaintiff, I order that the 1st defendant’s striking out application be heard by a Judge in Chambers, on the earliest possible date to be fixed with an estimated time of 3 hours. 

8. On the question of costs, in making its adjournment application the plaintiff has acted, in my view, most unreasonably and irresponsibly without respect to the process of the court or any sense of what is procedurally just. 

9. In the circumstances, I make the costs orders as follows:

(1)   Costs of the 1st defendant’s unless order application be costs in the cause of its striking out application; and

(2)   Costs of the plaintiff’s adjournment summons and also this appeal be to the 1st defendant, to be paid forthwith and on an indemnity basis.  Such costs to be taxed if not agreed.

(Wilson Chan)
Deputy High Court Judge

 

Mr Yonah Leung, of ONC Lawyers, for the plaintiff

Mr Mike S K Lui, instructed by W K To & Co, for the 1st defendant

2nd defendant was not represented and did not appear