HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Constitutional and Administrative Law Proceedings2018

HUSSAIN ZUBAIR v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV103/2021LUU THI VAN v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD /NON REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
  • CACV30/2019SORIP KHAN v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD /NON REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
  • CACV33/2019GURWINDER SINGH v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD/ NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE AND ANOTHER
  • CACV37/2019BALA BISWAJIT v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD /NON REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
  • CACV71/2021NGUYEN THANH QUANG v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD /NON REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
  • CACV93/2021VU THI THUY HANG v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD /NON REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
  • HCAL1000/2020USMAN SAQIB v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL1000/2022WASINI v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL1001/2020KANORA ANA v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL1001/2021MAHYANI v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL1001/2023MIAH REPON v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL100/2015HUSSAIN QASIM v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL100/2018GALIZA GOMER DADIS v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL1002/2019SALIM MOHAMMED v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL1004/2021RAHMAN MOHAMMAD ARIFUR v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL1006/2020AFZAL KHAWAJA REHAN v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL1006/2021VU TRUONG SON v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
  • HCAL1007/2019SHAHUL HAMEED BEER MOHAMED AND ANOTHER v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL1007/2023CARYINI v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL1008/2019DUAZO WENDELL MONTILLA v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]

Files (2)

[2019] HKCFI 1926-EN-2019-07-31

HUSSAIN ZUBAIR v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD /NON REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE

HTML content

HCAL 40/2018

[2019] HKCFI 1926

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST

NO 40 OF 2018

___________________

BETWEEN
 HUSSAIN ZUBAIRApplicant
and
 TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD /
NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
Putative Respondent
and
 DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATIONPutative Interested Party

___________________

Before: Hon Campbell Moffat J in Chambers

Date of Hearing: 31 July 2019

Date of Decision: 31 July 2019

___________________

D E C I S I O N

___________________


Introduction

1.  This is an application dated 15 May 2019 for appeal from my decision of 30 April 2019, refusing leave to apply for judicial review.  The applicant had 14 days in which to apply to appeal that decision.  He did not do so.  He now requires leave to extend time to appeal against that order.  The applicant attended court with the assistance of an interpreter although he does speak some limited English.

Procedural background

2.  The applicant is a claimant under Article 3 of the Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment.  He entered Hong Kong illegally by boat on 22 April 2014 and was arrested on 21 August 2014.  He submitted a non-refoulement claim form on 2 March 2016 and was interviewed by the Director of Immigration (“the Director”) on 27 May 2016.  The Director dismissed his claim under all heads, by Notice of Decision on 27 July 2016 and by Notice of Further Decision on 14 July 2017.  He appealed those decisions to the Torture Claims Appeal Board (“the TCAB”).  The adjudicator of the TCAB, Mr Wesley Wong (“the Adjudicator”), heard him on 9 November 2017.  The Adjudicator refused his appeal on 15 December 2017.

3.  The applicant filed a notice of application on a Form 86 seeking leave to apply for judicial review on 8 January 2018 and did not request an oral hearing.  The matter was therefore considered on the papers.  His application for leave to apply for judicial review was refused on 30 April 2019.  He had 14 days from that date to appeal that decision which would have expired on 14 May 2019.  By way of summons dated 15 May 2019, he seeks leave to appeal out of time.

4.  An applicant does not require leave to appeal against a CFI judge’s refusal to grant leave to apply for judicial review (Order 59, rule 21(1)(g)).  The applicant may appeal as of right.  However, an applicant who wishes to appeal against a CFI judge’s refusal to grant leave to apply for judicial review, which is an interlocutory order, has to observe the time limits for appeal under Order 53, rule 3(4) of the Rules of the High Court which allows 14 days.  Where the applicant is out of time to appeal against a judge’s refusal to grant leave to apply for judicial review, an extension of time may be granted by a judge of the Court of First Instance under Order 59, rule 15.  The court is required to consider (1) the length of the delay; (2) the reasons for the delay; (3) the prospect of success in the intended appeal; and (4) the prejudice to the respondent if an extension of time were granted.

5.  In order to obtain that leave, an application must be made promptly and it must be supported by an affirmation or affidavit deposing to any facts relied upon by the applicant and giving a full account of and explanation for the whole of the delay since time expired.  Even though he was late by only one day, the applicant nevertheless requires leave and his delay necessarily triggers an assessment of his overall appeal.

6.  Whilst the granting of an extension of time is entirely within the discretion of the court, the applicant is required to explain the reasons for his delay as this forms part (but not all) of the consideration of whether there is good reason to allow an extension of time. He claims he did not receive the Order on time because he was in the process of changing his address.  The court file suggests that it was properly served upon the correct address given at that time.  It is the duty of a litigant to give the court an address to which correspondence or notice can come to his attention in a timely manner[1]. The consequences of any delay arising from failing to do so will fall upon the litigant[2].

7.  The applicant was late by just one day but this application brings into stark relief the complete lack of merit in both his appeal and in the underlying merits of his UNHCR application.  Even if the court does accept the reasons given for the delay, which was minimal, the court is required to examine whether there is any merit in the applicant’s appeal[3].  The applicant was asked but could not provide any reasons for his appeal.

8.  An applicant must understand that the role of the court in judicial review is not to provide a further avenue of appeal from the decisions of the Director and the Adjudicator[4].  It follows that an appeal from this court should not be founded upon any attempt to appeal those same decisions.  It is an appeal from the decision of this court and the applicant should look to draft grounds of appeal on that basis.  This applicant could not do so.

Conclusion

9.  Even though the delay was minimal, the court is required to consider whether the applicant has an arguable appeal, which necessitates a further consideration of the underlying merits of his claim.  It has no merit as explained in the initial refusal of leave.  There were no grounds of review and none could be ascertained from the papers.  There was no complaint before the court as to the decision to refuse leave.  The applicant wishes the Court of Appeal to consider his situation afresh.  Having considered the length of delay, reason for the delay, underlying merits of his application and grounds of appeal, it would not be in the interest of justice to grant an extension of time in all the circumstances of this case.

10.  The applicant’s summons dated 15 May 2019 be dismissed.

 (A P Campbell Moffat)
 Judge of the Court of First Instance
High Court

The applicant appeared in person.



[1]Re Ahmed Zakar CAMP 17/2019, [2019] HKCA 566

[2]Islam Raja Rais v Director of Immigration HCMP 881/2017

[3]Re Mehmood Ikhlas CAMP 28/2019 [2019] HKCA 567

[4]Nupur Mst v Director of Immigration CAMP 54/2018 [2018] HKCA 524; Re Md Shohel Sheak CACV 233/2018 [2018] HKCA 714

[2019] HKCFI 1143-EN-2019-04-30

HUSSAIN ZUBAIR v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]

HTML content

HCAL 40/2018

[2019] HKCFI 1143

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST No. 40 of 2018

BETWEEN

Hussain ZubairApplicant
and
Torture Claims Appeal Board /
Non-refoulement Claims Petition Office
Putative Respondent
and
Director of ImmigrationPutative Interested Party

Application for Leave to Apply for Judicial Review
NOTIFICATION of the Judge’s decision (Ord. 53 r. 3)

Following:

   consideration of the documents only;     or
   consideration of the documents and the Applicant being present/absent in open court

Order by The Honourable Mrs. Justice Campbell-Moffat:

Leave to apply for judicial review be refused.

Observations for the Applicant:

Procedural history

1.  The applicant entered Hong Kong illegally on 22 April 2014 from China and was arrested by the police on 21 August 2014 for illegally remaining.  The applicant submitted a non-refoulement (“NRF”) claim by way of written representation on 26 August 2014.  He was released upon recognisance on 13 September 2014.  His NRF claim form was submitted on 2 March 2016.

2.  The applicant attended a screening interview on 27 May 2016.  The Director of Immigration (“the Director”) dismissed his claim (not including that under BOR 2) by Notice of Decision (“the Decision”) on 27 July 2016 and by Notice of Further Decision (re BOR 2) on 14 July 2017.  He appealed the Decision to the Torture Claims Appeal Board (“the TCAB”).  The adjudicator of the TCAB, Mr Wesley Wong (“the Adjudicator”), heard his appeal on 9 November 2017.  The Adjudicator considered his appeal on all applicable grounds including BOR 2.  The Adjudicator refused his appeal on 15 December 2017.

3.  The applicant filed a notice of application on a Form 86 seeking leave to apply for judicial review on 8 January 2018 and did not request an oral hearing.  The matter was therefore considered on the papers.

Background

4.  The applicant is a Pakistani national.  He was born on 15 October 1984, in the Punjab.  He had 10 years of formal education and worked as a farmer between 2000 and 2006 and thereafter as a Land Officer in the Land Office between 2006 and 2010.  The applicant was a member of the Pakistan Peoples Party (“PPP”) but 90% of the local population were supporters of the Pakistan Muslim League (N) (“PML(N)”).  The applicant also appears to have been a Deobandi Sunni, who had some degree of conflict with Brailvi Sunnis and Shias.  In 2013, a group of Brailvi Sunnis who were PML(N) supporters assaulted the applicant’s local Imam. The applicant went with the Imam to file a report with the police but the police would not accept the complaint as they had been approached by the Brailvi Sunnis beforehand.  Thereafter, the applicant received several telephone calls a week from Shias or Brailvi Sunnis telling him to file no further complaints to the police; not to belong to the PPP and not to vote PPP or he would be killed.  On one occasion unknown men tried to drag him from his home but neighbours intercepted them and he was ultimately unharmed.  The applicant reported this to the police and his assailants were intercepted and detained in order for the applicant to identify them, which he did but the suspects were later released.  The applicant therefore made a report to a senior police officer and attended a number of interviews over several weeks during which the police sought to persuade him to drop his complaint because of the influence of the PML(N) or to reach a compromise in order to avoid further trouble but the applicant wished to proceed.  The applicant continued to receive phone calls telling him not to proceed with his complaint.  He left his home to avoid further trouble and went to Peshawar and then, for fear they could track him down and to avoid being killed, he came to Hong Kong.

The non-refoulement claim

5.  Under the Unified Screening Mechanism (“USM”), the applicant’s claim is to be assessed on all applicable grounds which are:

i.  Risk of torture under Part VIIC of the Immigration Ordinance, Cap 115 (“torture risk”).  Under torture risk, the applicant must establish he has substantial grounds for believing he will be subjected to torture if returned to his home state.  Those grounds cannot be speculative or theoretical and the risk of torture must be real and personal.  The standard of proof is a low one.

ii.  Risk of torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment under Article 3 of section 8 of the Hong Kong Bill of Rights Ordinance (“HKBORO”), Cap 383 and Article 7 of the ICCPR (“BOR 3 risk”).  Under BOR 3, the applicant must establish that he has a genuine and substantial risk of being subject to mental or physical torture; cruel, inhuman or degrading ill treatment; or punishment, if returned to his home state.  The level of such mental or physical torture etc. must reach a minimum level of severity.

iii.  Risk of persecution with reference to the non-refoulement principle under Article 33 of the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees (“persecution risk”).  Under “persecution risk”, the applicant must establish that he has a well-founded fear that there is a real chance that he will face persecution based upon race, religion, nationality or membership of a social group or political opinion if he is expelled and returned to his home state.

iv.  Risk of a violation of the right to life under Article 2 of section 8 of the HKBORO, Cap 383 and Article 6 of the ICCPR (“BOR 2 risk”).  Under BOR 2, the applicant must establish a real risk that he will be arbitrarily deprived of his life, have a death penalty imposed upon him; or be the victim of genocide or otherwise be deprived of his rights under BOR 2.

6.  It is the duty of both the Director and the Adjudicator to weigh all of the available credible, reliable evidence and ascertain whether the applicant had established the factual basis of his claim.  The Director and Adjudicator must then assess the level of harm the applicant says he fears.  Each ground of claim above has a relevant level of risk.  It is for the applicant to establish that he is the subject of such risk.  Under the HKBORO, he must show substantial grounds for believing that the harm which he fears is “foreseeable, real, personal and present”.  The question is whether there is a real riskor real chance of the occurrence or recurrence of the harm which he fears.

Decision of the Adjudicator

7.  The applicant seeks to review the Decision of the Adjudicator.  The Adjudicator analysed the applicant’s claim on all applicable grounds.  He arranged for an oral hearing and treated the appeal as a rehearing.  He explained the purpose of the hearing and the procedure to be adopted.  The applicant stated he wished to produce documents to the Adjudicator but could not say which documents he wished to produce.  Having given the applicant a fair opportunity to add to the facts already before the him, the Adjudicator correctly set out the law and key legal principles including the burden and standard of proof.  He analysed the facts, applied the law to them and explained why he found that the applicant had not established his case to the requisite standard.

Leave to apply for judicial review

8.  Judicial review is not a rehearing of the merits of the applicant’s original application for refugee status.  This is an application to apply for leave to judicially review the Decision of the Adjudicator.  The applicant must show an arguable case that there was either unlawfulness, unreasonableness or unfairness by those bodies or persons when dealing with his application in order to obtain leave to judicially review them.

Grounds of review

9.  There were no grounds of review.  The applicant seeks a re-hearing of his appeal.  He has not complained of any procedural irregularity, unfairness or unreasonableness.  The applicant has a duty to state the grounds of his intended judicial review and show that they are reasonably arguable and enjoy a realistic prospect of success: Po Fun Chan v Winnie Cheung (2007) 10 HKCFAR 676.  I have nevertheless considered whether the papers indicate any such ground for the purposes of considering whether to grant leave.

Conclusion

10.  Despite the fact that the applicant did not submit any grounds of review, I have considered the papers carefully.  I have not found any error of law or procedure.  I see no evidence of procedural unfairness nor a failure to adhere to a high standard of fairness throughout.  Despite the onus being upon the applicant, the Adjudicator engaged in a joint endeavour with the applicant and considered all relevant criteria; gave the applicant a reasonable opportunity to state his case and enquired into that case appropriately.  There is no criticism of his determination, which was open to him on the facts and eminently reasonable.  

11.  In my judgement, there is no reasonably arguable basis upon which the applicant could found a claim for judicial review and, as such, there would be no realistic prospect of success if he were to be granted leave.  I therefore refuse leave for judicial review.

Dated the 30th  day of April 2019.

 (Marcus Wong)
for Registrar, High Court

Where leave to apply has been granted, Applicants and their legal advisers are reminded of their obligation to reconsider the merits of their application in the light of the Respondent’s evidence




Notesfor the Applicant:

If leave has been granted, the Applicant or his solicitors must:

    

a) serve on the respondent and such interested parties as may be directed by the Court the order granting leave and any directions given within 14 days after the leave was granted (Order 53, rule 4A);

b) issue the originating summons within 14 days after the grant of leave and serve it in accordance with Order 53, rule 5; and

c) supply to every other party copies of every affidavit which the Applicant proposes to use at the hearing, including the affidavit in support of the application for leave (Order 53, rule 6(5)).

 

Sent to the Applicant on 30 April 2019

Hussain Zubair

Applicant’s ref. no:
Nil.

 

Sent to the Putative Respondent / the Putative Respondent’s solicitors / such Putative Interested Parties as may be directed by the Court / the Putative Interested Parties’ solicitors on 30 April 2019

Torture Claims Appeal Board /
Non-Refoulement Claims Petition Office
Putative Respondent’s ref. no.:
USM 4347/16/8/66/P1075

Department of Justice for Director of Immigration
Putative Interested Party’s ref. no.:
QA T/C 173/16 (formerly RBCZ/2707/14)
RBCZ/9002548/17




Form CALL-1