HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Constitutional and Administrative Law Proceedings2018

郭卓堅 v. 鄭泳舜

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV158/2018郭卓堅 v. 立法會主席梁君彥AND ANOTHER
  • CACV295/2017郭卓堅 對 法援署副署長莊因東及另一人
  • HCAL1054/2022郭卓堅 v. 政府醫衛局局長盧寵茂先生
  • HCAL1068/2019郭卓堅 v. 差餉物業估價署署長蔡立耀先生
  • HCAL1094/2017郭卓堅 v. 立法會主席及各立法會建制派議員(39人)
  • HCAL1165/2018郭卓堅 v. 香港特首林鄭月娥
  • HCAL130/2018郭卓堅 v. 香港島地方選區選舉主任鄧如欣
  • HCAL1405/2020郭卓堅 訴 香港特別行政區首長林鄭月娥女士
  • HCAL1440/2021郭卓堅 v. 民政事務局局長徐英偉先生及另一人
  • HCAL1513/2022郭卓堅 v. 律政司司長林定國
  • HCAL1532/2018郭卓堅 對 民政局長劉江華 [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL1596/2020郭卓堅 訴 香港特首林鄭月娥女士
  • HCAL1985/2019郭卓堅 對 食物衞生局長陳肇始小姐
  • HCAL2216/2019郭卓堅 v. 元朗區指揮官李偉文先生 AND OTHERS
  • HCAL429/2017郭卓堅 v. 葛佩帆及另一人
  • HCAL453/2017郭卓堅 v. 林鄭月娥特首連同行政會議成員
  • HCAL463/2019郭卓堅 訴 香港行政長官林鄭月娥
  • HCAL511/2017郭卓堅 v. 梁君彥 (立法會主席)及另一人 [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL530/2017郭卓堅 v. 律政司司長袁國強 [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL531/2018郭卓堅 v. 林鄭月娥 香港特別行政區首長
[2018] HKCFI 593-EN-2018-03-19

郭卓堅 v. 鄭泳舜

HTML content

HCAL 415/2018

[2018] HKCFI 593

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST NO 415 OF 2018

____________

BETWEEN  
 郭卓堅Applicant

and

 鄭泳舜Putative Respondent

____________

Before: Hon Chow J in Chambers

Date of Decision: 19 March 2018

Date of Handing Down Decision: 19 March 2018

___________________

D E C I S I O N

___________________

1.  This is an application for leave to apply for judicial review seeking a declaration that the Putative Respondent is disqualified from holding office as a member of the Legislative Council, on the ground that he advocates for the independence of Hong Kong from the Peoples’ Republic of China contrary to Article 104 of the Basic Law.

2.  At the 2018 Legislative Council By-election (“the By‑election”) recently held on 11 March 2018, the Putative Respondent was elected as a member of the Legislative Council for the Kowloon West Geographical Constituency.  On 14 March 2018, the Applicant made the present application.

3.  The basis of the application, it appears, is that the Putative Respondent is a member of “民建聯” (DAB).  The full name of “民建聯” is “民主建港協進聯盟” (Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong).

4.  In his affirmation filed in support of the application for leave, the Applicant alleges that DAB advocates for “香港民主建港和香港民主建國” (the building up of Hong Kong, and the formation of Hong Kong as a state or country, through democracy), which it is said amounts to advocating for (i) the independence of Hong Kong, and (ii) the formation of Hong Kong as a state or country independent from the Peoples’ Republic of China, contrary to the declaration and promissory oath made by the Putative Respondent accompanying his nomination form as a candidate for the By-election for the Kowloon West Geographical Constituency under Section 40 of the Legislative Council Ordinance, Cap 542.

5.  The Applicant also produces a photograph of the Putative Respondent (and other persons), apparently taken during a visit of a delegation of DAB to San Francisco in front of a banner containing the following words “歡迎香港民主建國聯盟代表團訪問舊金山”.  The date of the photograph is not clear from the exhibit produced by the Applicant.

6.  On the evidence before the court, there is, I consider, no proper basis to contend that DAB is a party or organization which advocates for the independence of Hong Kong from the Peoples’ Republic of China.  The words “民主建港” in the full name of DAB in Chinese cannot be taken in isolation to mean that DAB advocates for the formation of Hong Kong as an independent state or country through democracy.  In order to discover the objects, purposes or intentions of a political party, one ought to consider the founding articles and/or manifesto of the party as well as the words and conduct of that party.  The Applicant has singularly failed to adduce any relevant evidence on those matters.  In any event, the words “民主建港”, in their natural and ordinary meaning, mean only the building up or advancement of Hong Kong through democracy.  It also seems to me to be obvious that the banner as shown on the photograph, in so far as it refers to DAB as “民主建國聯盟”, is a mistake.

7.  There is one other matter that I should mention.  The Applicant’s address as stated in the Form 86 is in Cheung Chau Island.  It would appear that he was not an elector entitled to vote at the By-election for the Kowloon West Geographical Constituency.  It is questionable whether he has standing to make the present application.  In the absence of full arguments, I shall leave open the question of whether a person who is neither a candidate (or prospective candidate) nor an elector for the relevant constituency has standing to challenge, by way of judicial review, the qualification of a person to hold office as a member of the Legislative Council for that constituency.  I consider that the present application can be disposed of on the simple basis that the proposed application for judicial review is not reasonably arguable.

8.  Accordingly, the application for leave to apply for judicial review is dismissed, with no order as to costs.

(Anderson Chow)
Judge of the Court of First Instance
High Court

The Applicant acting in person