HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Constitutional and Administrative Law Proceedings2018

RE TRAN VAN THANH

Related cases with same parties

  • HCAL452/2018RE TRAN VAN TUAN
  • HCAL497/2018BUI THI MI v. IMMIGRATION DEPARTMENT AND ANOTHER [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL498/2018LUU VAN HOA v. IMMIGRATION DEPARTMENT AND ANOTHER [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL511/2018RE ALI JAMSHAID
  • HCAL561/2018PHAM THI QUYEN v. IMMIGRATION DEPARTMENT AND ANOTHER [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL591/2018TRAN VAN THANH v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL598/2021TRAN VAN THANH v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL939/2023TRAN VAN THANH v. DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION<br> [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL942/2020CAO THI HAU v. IMMIGRATION DEPARTMENT AND ANOTHER [Decision on Leave Application]
  • HCAL943/2020RE NGUYEN THI THU

Files (3)

[2022] HKCFI 1338-EN-2022-05-18

RE TRAN VAN THANH

HTML content

HCAL 453/2018

[2022] HKCFI 1338

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST

NO 453 OF 2018

_____________

RE:TRAN VAN THANHApplicant

_____________

Before:  Deputy High Court Judge Bruno Chan in Chambers

Date of Hearing:  4 May 2022

Date of Decision:  18 May 2022

______________

D E C I S I O N

______________

1.  On 27 August 2020 I extended time of 14 days for the Applicant to appeal against my earlier refusal to grant leave for him to apply for judicial review of the decisions of the Director of Immigration (“Director”) or of the Torture Claims Appeal Board (“Board”) regarding his non-refoulement claim upon finding that the 14-day period for him to appeal under Order 53 rule 3(4) of the Rules of High Court, Cap 4A happened to be within the months when the High Court Registry was then closed due to the Covid-19 pandemic, and I therefore allowed him a further 14-days up to 10 September 2020 to file his Notice of Appeal.

2.  The Applicant however did not do so, and more than one year later on 30 September 2021 he issued another time summons for extension of time to file his appeal, and in his supporting affirmation he claimed to have never received the order of 27 August 2020 in the mail even though he had never changed his address, and that it was only sometime in September 2021 when he reported on his recognizance that he was told by his immigration officer that his case was finished, and it was then when he came to the Court to make enquiry about his case that he was given a copy of the decision but by then he was way out of time to file his appeal.

3.  In considering whether to extend time for appealing against a decision refusing leave to apply for judicial review, the Court shall have regard to (i) the length of the delay; (ii) the reason for the delay; (iii) the prospect of the intended appeal; and (iv) the prejudice to the respondent if an extension of time were granted: see Re MK HCMP 2609/2016, 10 January 2017; Chu On Fong Winter v The AppealPanel (Housing) HCMP 982/2017, 20 July 2017; Islam Raja Rais v Director ofImmigration HCMP 881/2017, 26 June 2017; Re Gurung Min Bahadur[2018] HKCA 226; and Re Saqlain Muhammad[2018] HKCA 346.

4.  In the Applicant’s case, a delay of more than one year must be considered as extremely substantial or inordinate, and at the hearing of his summons he confirmed what he had stated in his supporting affirmation, but was unable to provide any further details or documentary evidence in support of his statement.

5.  The court record shows that the decision was sent on the same day to the Applicant’s last reported address without being returned through undelivered post, but even if for whatever reason it indeed never reached the Applicant in the mail, given that he had intended to appeal as early as on 7 May 2020 when he issued his first time summons, if he had indeed not heard from the Court since, surely he would and should have made enquires about his summons or application much earlier than until more than one year later in September 2021 when he allegedly only found out from his immigration officer. It simply defies both common sense and his duty to prosecute his case diligently and in a timely manner, especially for applications of this nature. In the circumstances, and in the absence of any details or documentary evidence to corroborate his bare assertions, I am not satisfied that the Applicant has provided any good reason for his such serious delay.

6.  More importantly, the Applicant has failed to put forth any proper or valid draft or proposed grounds of appeal, or any particulars of any error in the decision or why it may reasonably be argued that the decision was unfair or unreasonable either in his summons or his affirmation, nor was he able to do so at the hearing of his summons. As such, and given the fact that the previous extension of time granted to him was due to procedural technical reason rather than on merits or prospect of his intended appeal, and in the absence of any error in the decision being clearly and properly identified by the Applicant, I do not see any prospect of success in his intended appeal.

7.  In the premises, and for the reasons given, it would be futile to extend time for what appears to be a hopeless appeal. I accordingly refuse his application for extension of time to appeal, and dismiss his summons.

  (Bruno Chan)
Deputy High Court Judge

The Applicant appeared in person

[2020] HKCFI 2072-EN-2020-08-27

RE TRAN VAN THANH

HTML content

HCAL 453/2018

[2020] HKCFI 2072

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST

NO 453 OF 2018

_____________

RE: TRAN VAN THANH Applicant

_____________

Before: Deputy High Court Judge Bruno Chan in Chambers

Date of Hearing: 15 July 2020

Date of Decision: 27 August 2020

________________________

D E C I S I O N

________________________

1.  On 15 January 2020 I refused to grant leave to the Applicant to apply for judicial review of the decision of the Director of Immigration (“the Director”) or the Torture Claims Appeal Board (“the Board”) in rejecting/dismissing his non-refoulement claim upon finding none of the grounds put forward by him reasonably arguable for his intended challenge, that there was no error of law or procedural unfairness in the process before the Director or the Board or in their decisions, and that there was no reasonable prospect of success in his intended application.

2.  The Applicant now by a summons issued on 7 May 2020 seeks extension of time to appeal against that decision, as the 14-day period for him to file his appeal under Order 53 rule 3(4) of the Rules of High Court, Cap 4A ended on 29 January 2020, and hence he was late by more than 3 months with his intended appeal. 

3.  In considering whether to extend time for appealing against a decision refusing leave to apply for judicial review, the court shall have regard to (i) the length of the delay; (ii) the reason for the delay; (iii) the prospect of the intended appeal; and (iv) the prejudice to the respondent if an extension of time were granted: see Re MK HCMP 2609/2016, 10 January 2017; Chu On Fong Winter v The AppealPanel (Housing) HCMP 982/2017, 20 July 2017; Islam Raja Rais v Director ofImmigration HCMP 881/2017, 26 June 2017; Re Gurung Min Bahadur[2018] HKCA 226; and Re Saqlain Muhammad[2018] HKCA 346.

4.  In the Applicant’s case, a delay of more than 3 months must be considered as substantial or excessive, for which the Applicant explained in his supporting affirmation that he was prepared to lodge his notice of appeal within the required 14-day period, but the registry was then closed and it was not until 19 February 2020 when it was opened, and when he then tried to file his appeal, he was told to seek leave from the court as by then he was deemed out of time.

5.  Indeed the last day for the Applicant to file his appeal fell on the same day when the General Adjourned Period commenced as announced by the Judiciary due to the Covid-19 pandemic resulting in general closure of the court and tribunal registries from 29 January 2020 to 3 May 2020.     

6.  In the circumstances and given the fact that he was unrepresented and obviously required assistance to prepare his appeal and application, I am prepared to give him the benefit that he might have been prevented by the closure of the registry to file his appeal within the required period, and accordingly grant him extension of time to file his notice of appeal within 14 days of this order.  

(Bruno Chan)
Deputy High Court Judge

The applicant was not represented and did not appear

[2020] HKCFI 76-EN-2020-01-15

TRAN VAN THANH v. IMMIGRATION DEPARTMENT AND ANOTHER [Decision on Leave Application]

HTML content

HCAL 453/2018

[2020] HKCFI 76

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST No. 453 of 2018

BETWEEN

Tran Van ThanhApplicant
and
Immigration Department1st Putative Respondent
Torture Claims Appeal Board2nd Putative Respondent

 Application for Leave to Apply for Judicial Review

NOTIFICATION of the Judge’s decision (Ord. 53 r. 3)

Following:

   consideration of the documents only; or
   consideration of the documents and oral submissions by the Applicant in open court;

Order by Deputy High Court Judge Bruno Chan:

Leave to apply for judicial review refused.

Observations for the Applicant:

1.  The Applicant is a 49-year-old national of Vietnam who entered Hong Kong illegally on 1 January 2014 and was arrested by police on 29 July 2014 for possession of a forged identity card for which he was subsequently convicted and sentenced to 15 months in prison.  Upon his discharge from prison on 29 May 2015, he was referred to the Immigration Department when he raised a non-refoulement claim on the basis that if he returned to Vietnam he would be harmed or killed by his creditor for failing to repay his loan.  He was subsequently released on recognizance pending the determination of his claim.

2.  The Applicant was born and raised in Thủy Nguyên Huyện, Hải Phòng, Vietnam. He received no formal education but had worked as a fisherman, got married with two children and later raised a poultry farm together with his wife.

3.  In 2000, in order to expand his poultry business, the Applicant borrowed a loan from a local money-lender repayable with monthly interest payments.

4.  However, in 2002 there was an outbreak of infectious disease in his home region that killed all his poultry that he had to close down his business.  As a result he was having difficulty making his loan repayment in time, and had had to resort to borrowing from his friends to make part payments to the money-lender.

5.  From 2002 to 2013 the Applicant had made only two small repayments to his creditor, and so one day in mid-2013 his creditor came with several men to the Applicant’s home to demand for repayment with threats to kill him and his family if he failed to do so. As a result the Applicant handed over the title deeds of his house to his creditor who then warned him that unless the loan was paid soon, he would forfeit his house.

6.  After his creditor left with his men, the Applicant did not report their threats to the police, and as they continued to threaten and harass him and his family, in August 2013 his wife left their home and Vietnam, and in late 2013 the Applicant also left Vietnam for Hong Kong but was refused entry and was returned to Vietnam.

7.  About one week later, the Applicant again departed Vietnam but this time for China, and from there he later sneaked into Hong Kong, and upon his subsequent arrest for possessing a forged identity card and his release from prison on 29 May 2015 after serving 15 months in prison, he raised a non-refoulement claim for protection, for which he completed a Non-refoulement Claim Form on 6 July 2018 and attended screening interview before the Immigration Department with legal representation from the Duty Lawyer Service (“DLS”).

8.  By a Notice of Decision dated 30 July 2018 the Director of Immigration (“the Director”) rejected the Applicant’s claim on all the applicable grounds including risk of torture under Part VIIC of the Immigration Ordinance, Cap 115 (“torture risk”), risk of his absolute or non-derogable rights under the Hong Kong Bill of Rights (“HKBOR”) being violated including right to life under Article 2 (“BOR 2 risk”), risk of torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment under Article 3 of HKBOR (“BOR 3 risk”),and risk of persecution with reference to the non-refoulement principle under Article 33 of the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees (“persecution risk”).

9.  In his decision the Director took into account all the relevant circumstances of the Applicant’s claim and assessed the level of risk of harm from his creditor upon his return to Vietnam as low due to the low intensity and frequency of past ill-treatment from him,that it is unlikely the creditor had any real intention to harm or kill the Applicant when he had had ample opportunities to do so between 2002 and 2013, that in any event his creditor was already given the title deed of his house and that it was a private monetary dispute between them without any official involvement that state or police protection would be available to the Applicant if resorted to, and that reliable and objective Country of Origin Information (“COI”) show that reasonable internal relocation alternatives are available in Vietnam with a large population of 96 million people spread across a vast territory of more than 331,000 square kilometers that it would not be unduly harsh for the Applicant as an able-bodied adult with work experience to move to other part of Vietnam away from his home district in large cities such as Ho Chi Minh City where it would be difficult if not impossible for his creditor to locate him.

10.  On 10 August 2018 the Applicant lodged an appeal to the Torture Claims Appeal Board (“the Board”) against the Director’s decision, and for which he attended an oral hearing on 24 May 2019 before the Board with his lawyer from DLS during which he gave evidence and answered questions put to him by the adjudicator for the Board and with submissions made by his lawyer on his behalf.  On 22 July 2019 his appeal was dismissed by the Board which also confirmed the decision of the Director.

11.  In its decision the Board found that even on the Applicant’s own case that his problem with his creditor was a private loan dispute between two private citizens without any state or official involvement that state protection as well as reasonable internal relocation options would be available for the Applicant to move safely to other places of Vietnam away from his home district in large cities such as Ho Chi Minh City where it would be difficult if not impossible for his creditor to locate him that his claim for non‑refoulement protection failed on all applicable grounds.

12.  On 20 March 2018 the Applicant filed his Form 86 for leave to apply for judicial review of both the decisions of the Director and the Board, but no ground for seeking relief was given in his Form, and in his supporting affirmation of the same date he merely repeated his claim of fear of being killed by his creditor and that he cannot return to Vietnam.  As such and in the absence of any error of law or procedural unfairness in his process before the Director or the Board or in their decisions being clearly and properly identified by the Applicant, I am unable to find any reasonably arguable basis to challenge the findings of the Director or the Board.

13.  As has been repeatedly emphasized by the Court of Appeal, judicial review does not operate as a rehearing of a non-refoulement claim when the proper occasion for an applicant to present and articulate his claim is in the screening process and interview before the Immigration Department and in the process before the Board where the evaluation of the risk of harm is primarily a matter for the Director and the Board as they are entitled to make such evaluation based on the evidence available to them that the court will not usurp their role as primary decision makers in the absence of any legal error or procedural unfairness or irrationality being identified by the applicant, as judicial review is not an avenue for revisiting the assessment by them in the hope that the court may consider the matter afresh: Re Lakhwinder Singh[2018] HKCA 246; Re Daljit Singh[2018] HKCA 328;ReMudannayakalage Chaminda Pushpa Kumara[2018] HKCA 400; and Nupur Mst v Director of Immigration[2018] HKCA 537.

14.  The fact is that it has been established by both the Director and the Board in their respective decision that the risk of harm in the Applicant’s claim is a localized one and that it is not unreasonable or unsafe for him to relocate to other part of Vietnam, there is simply no justification to afford him with non-refoulement protection in Hong Kong: see TK v Jenkins & anor [2013] 1 HKC 526.

15.  In the premises and having proceeded to consider the decisions of both the Director and the Board with rigorous examination and anxious scrutiny, I do not find any error of law or procedural unfairness in either of them, nor any failure on their part to apply high standards of fairness in their consideration and assessment of the Applicant’s claim.

16.  For these reasons I am not satisfied that there is any prospect of success in the Applicant’s intended application for judicial review, and I accordingly refuse his leave application.

Dated the 15th day of January 2020.

(NG Hang-yin)
for Registrar, High Court

Where leave to apply has been granted, Applicants and their legal advisers are reminded of their obligation to reconsider the merits of their application in the light of the Respondent’s evidence




Notesfor the Applicant:

If leave has been granted, the Applicant or his solicitors must: 
    
a) serve on the respondent and such interested parties as may be directed by the Court the order granting leave and any directions given within 14 days after the leave was granted (Order 53, rule 4A);

b) issue the originating summons within 14 days after the grant of leave and serve it in accordance with Order 53, rule 5; and

c) supply to every other party copies of every affidavit which the Applicant proposes to use at the hearing, including the affidavit in support of the application for leave (Order 53, rule 6(5)). 
 
 Sent to the Applicant on 15th January 2020

Tran Van Thanh

Applicant’s ref. no.:
Nil. 
 Sent to the Putative Respondent / the Putative Respondent’s solicitors / such Putative Interested Parties as may be directed by the Court / the Putative Interested Parties’ solicitors on 15th January 2020

Immigration Department
1st Putative Respondent’s ref. no.:
QA T/C 2396/18 (Formerly RBCZ 56/18) [T6I4]

Torture Claims Appeal Board

2nd Putative Respondent’s ref. no.:
USM 12944/18/8/214/V2166

Department of Justice,
Senior Assistant Law Office
(Civil Law)
(Civil Litigation Unit 2) 



Form CALL-1