HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Bankruptcy Proceedings1984

STANDARD CHARTERED BANK HONG KONG TRUSTEE LTD v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV125/1985FEDERAL ENTERPRISES CO LTD v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • CACV126/1989STANDARD CHARTERED BANK AND ANOTHER v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • CACV202/2011THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. CHAN KIN HANG DANVIL
  • CACV222/2007THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. CHAN HING TO
  • CACV269/1998THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. POA KWOK HO ALEXANDER
  • CACV271/2006LEUNG YAT TUNG v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • CACV367/2005THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. WILLIAM NICHOLAS GILES AND ANOTHER
  • CACV541/2018THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. BROWN COLVIN MORTON
  • CACV59/2017KWOK HIU CHUN DAMIEN v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • CACV80/1989STANDARD CHARTERED BANK AND ANOTHER v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • CACV84/2006THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. CHAN HING TO
  • CAMP138/2020THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. CHOW TUNG SHAN
  • HCA2731/2015CHUNG SUN KWAN v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCAL63/2002PHILIP LEIGH TOSE v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCAL64/2002WONG WING CHEONG, PETER v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCAL67/2003COSIMO BORRELLI AND ANOTHER v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCB1/1977EDWARD WONG & CO LTD v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCB251/1983MARIA PUN SIU FUN v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCB941/1990THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. MAK PUI YUK AND OTHERS
  • HCCW20/2014DAVID MOY v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER

Files (2)

36045-EN-1989-04-28

STANDARD CHARTERED BANK HONG KONG TRUSTEE LTD v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER

HTML content

HCB000297A/1984

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF HONG KONG KONG

IN BANKRUPTCY

No. 297 OF 1984

---------------------

Ex parteSTANDARD CHARTERED BANK HONG KONG TRUSTEE LIMITED, Administrator of the estate of Madam Lau Sui Ling, deceasedApplicant

and

THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER, The trustee of the property of Sabrina Au-yang Lam Lai Ming, a BankruptRespondent

------------------

Coram: Hon. Jones J. in Chambers

Date of hearing: 21st April 1989

Date of handing down judgment: 28th April 1989

-------------------------

J U D G M E N T

-------------------------

 

1. On the 26th July 1988, I dismissed an appeal by the Standard Chartered Bank Hong Kong Trustee Limited (the appellant), the adminstrator of the estate of Madam Lau Sui Ling, deceased (the deceased) against a decision of the Official Receiver rejecting a proof of debt for HK$6,000,000. The present appeal by the appellant is against a rejection by the Official Receiver of a further proof of debt for the same sum based upon virtually identical facts.

2. It is therefore necessary to recapitulate some of the facts that I set out in my previous judgment.

3. The deceased died on the 8th October 1985. By her will she appointed four of her children, including Stephen Lam and Sabrina Lam (Sabrina), to be the executors and trustees of her will. One of the other two executors predeceased the deceased. The residuary estate has been bequeathed to eight of the deceased's children in equal shares, two of the beneficiaries being Stephen Lam and Sabrina. A receiving order was made against Sabrina on the 26th September 1984 and she was adjudicated bankrupt on the 1st November 1984. Sabrina who is believed to be living in the United States did not give evidence in the first appeal nor in these proceedings.

4. The appellant on the instructions of the surviving executors obtained Letters of Administration with the will annexed to the estate of the deceased on the 9th February 1987.

5. The debt relates to a loan that is alleged to have been made to Sabrina on the 26th November 1982. On that date Stephen Lam and Sabrina acting as attorneys for the deceased, wrote to Cititrust (Cayman) Limited Trustee, with instructions to transfer $6,000,000 from a time deposit that matured on that date to be credited to an account with Bylamson & Associates International Limited, Bermuda (Bylamson Bermuda) with Bylamson & Associates (Hong Kong) Limited (Bylamson (H.K.)) with the Hang Seng Bank Limited, Hong Kong. A cheque for this sum was drawn on the same day by Citibank N.A. payable to the Hang Seng Bank for the account of Bylamson (H.K.). The account for Bylamson (H.K.) revealed that $6,000,000 was credited on that date and withdrawn on the same, day by means of a cheque in favour of Sabrina. A receipt also dated the 26th November 1982 was signed by Sabrina acknowledging receipt of $6,000,000 as a sum advanced and that it would be repaid on demand.

6. On the 26th May 1983 Bylamson Bermuda wrote to Sabrina claiming interest on the loan of $6,000,000 from the date of its commencement in a sum of $322,273.97. Stephen Lam was one of the signatories to this letter.

7. When the appellant sought directions from the court under 0.85, r.2 of the Rules of the Supreme Court, Liu, J. said that there was prima facie evidence that Sabrina was indebted to the deceased's e state. Although as I have said Sabrina did not give evidence in either appeal, reference was made to evidence that she gave in her bankruptcy proceedings in the United States that she had received a sum of $6,000,000 from Bylamson.

8. In the first appeal I rejected the argument presented by the appellant that a loan had been made by the deceased but that if a loan had been made, it was from Bylamson Bermuda. On the 29th October 1988 Bylamson Bermuda under seal, assigned the debt of $6,000,000 to the appellant. Following the assignment, the appellant submitted the second proof of debt to the Official Receiver the subject of this appeal, on the grounds that there was sufficient evidence of a loan by Bylamson Bermuda to Sabrina. That argument, which was rejected by the Official Receiver, has been rehearsed before me. A letter from Bylamson (H.K.) to the appellant dated the 20th April 1989 confirms that the sum of $6,000,000 was deposited in the account to be held for Bylamson Bermuda and that upon their instructions a cheque for this amount was paid to Sabrina. However, both Rogerio Lam and Stephen Lam, directors of the Bylamaon companies, have testified in previous proceedings that the loan was made by the deceased and was not a debt due to the company. Yet, Stephen Lam, as one of the signatories to the assignment, now purports to say that Sabrina was so indebted. Stephen Lam did not give evidence upon the present appeal, but did so on the first appeal when I found him to be an unimpressive witness.

9. Miss Yuen, counsel for the appellant, submitted that there could only be one of two possible scenarios to determine the true facts with regard to the loan. As the first scenario that the loan was made direct by the deceased to Sabrina has been rejected, she submitted that it necessarily follows that the loan must have been made by the deceased to Sabrina through Bylamson Bermuda. However, the evidence is, not only conflicting, but confusing. Originally the appellant's evidence was based upon the contention that there was a direct loan from the deceased to Sabrina with Bylamson Bermuda, acting as agent whereas it is now contended that the money was owed to Bylamson Bermuda. However, there is no evidence that the money was ever received by Bylamson Bermuda. The bank statement of Bylamson (H.K.) and the cheque made payable to Sabrina merely show that the money was received by Bylamson (H.K.) and then paid out to Sabrina. Stephen Lam described in his evidence in the first appeal that money was credited to Bylamson (H.K.), then transferred by way of internal accounting to Bylamson Bermuda, after which it returned to Hong Kong and was then paid to Sabrina, but there was no documentary evidence to support his testimony. Further the only evidence that Stephen Lam had that the loan was from the deceased to Sabrina was what he was told by Sabrina.

10. In order to accept a proof of debt, the Official Receiver is required to satisfy himself that there is a real debt due, see In re VAN LATIN Ex parte CHATTERTON [1907] 2 K.B. 23. In this case there is a complete lack of evidence that Bylamson Bermuda, ever received the money or lent it to Sabrina. The money only passed through Bylamson (H.K.). Despite the purported assignment of the debt to the appellant, both Stephen Lam and Rogerio Lam had previously asserted that Bylamson Bermuda never received the money. There is therefore a complete conflict of evidence.

11. Two different versions have been put forward but it cannot be said that because the first argument was rejected that the second is necessarily correct. I accept the submission made by Mr Lewis, counsel for the Official Receiver, that upon the present state of the evidence, the real nature of the transaction is not known. The Official Receiver was entirely right to reject the proof of debt for the evidence is wholly unsatisfactory and cannot be relied upon to justify the appellant's claim that there is a real debt due. As a result the appeal is dismissed and there will be an order nisi for costs to the Official Receiver on the common fund basis.

(B.L. Jones)

Judge of the High Court

Representation:

Miss Maria Yuen, instructed by Philip K.H. Wong & Co. for Appellant.

Mr Kevin Lewis for Official Receiver/Respondent.

28916-EN-1988-07-26

RE AU-YANG LAM LAI MING, SABRINA

HTML content

HCB000297/1984

1984, No. B297

 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE

HONG KONG

(IN BANKRUPTCY)

 

----------------

 

Re: Au-Yang Lam Lai Ming, Sabrina

Ex parte:

STANDARD CHARTERED BANK HONG KONG TRUSTEE LIMITED, administrator of the estate of Madam Lau Sui Ling, deceasedAppellant
and
THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER, the trustee of the property of Sabrina Au-Yang Lam Lai Ling, a BankruptRespondent

--------------

 

Coram: Hon. Jones J. in Chambers

Date of hearing: 13th July 1988

Date of handing down judgment: 26th July 1988

 

------------------

JUDGMENT

-------------------

 

1. This is an appeal by the Standard Chartered Bank Hong Kong Trustee Limited, the administrator of the estate of Madam Lau Sui Ling (the deceased) who died on the 8th October 1985 to reverse a decision of the Official Receiver rejecting a proof of debt for the sum of $6,000,000 together with interest. I shall refer to the appellant in this judgment as the administrator.

2. By her will executed on the 29th August 1966, the deceased appointed four of her children including Stephen Lam and Sabrina Lam (Sabrina) to be the executors and trustees of her will. Under her will, she bequeathed the residue of her estate in eight equal shares to her children. Two of the shares were bequeathed to Sabrina and one to Stephen Lam. One of the executors pre-deceased the deceased.

3. On the 23rd September 1974, the deceased appointed Stephen Lam and Sabrina to be her attorneys. On the 19th May 1982, a Declaration of Trust was executed in favour of the deceased by Cititrust (Cayman) Limited (Cititrust) by which the beneficiary of the income from the trust was to be the deceased during her life time and upon her death the trust was to terminate with the capital and income of the trust to be paid to her estate.

4. A receiving order was made against Sabrina on the 26th September 1984 and she was adjudicated bankrupt on the 1st November 1984. Sabrina also filed a voluntary petition in bankruptcy in the United States where she now lives on the 11th September 1984 but it appears that she has not been formally adjudicated bankrupt in that jurisdiction.

5. After the death of the deceased, the three remaining executors instructed the administrator to carry out the administration of the deceased's estate the provisional net value of which for estate duty purposes has been assessed at about $38,000,000. The administrator obtained Letters of Administration with the Will annexed on the 9th February 1987.

6. The circumstances surrounding the present appeal relate to an alleged loan by the deceased to Sabrina of $6,000,000 made in November 1982. The loan was effected by a withdrawal made on the instructions of Stephen Lam and Sabrina from a deposit with Cititrust that matured on the 26th November 1982. However, instead of the sum being paid direct to Sabrina, it was paid into the account of Bylamson & Associates International Ltd., Burmuda, with Bylamson & Associates (HK) Ltd. with the Hang Seng Rank Ltd. in Hong Kong. The Bylamson companies were private companies run by the Lam family. A receipt, signed by Sabrina, which is also dated the 26th November 1982, acknowledged receipt of this sum from Bylamson & Associates International Ltd., Burmuda as a sum advanced to her and stating that it would be repayable upon demand. On the 26th May 1983, Bylamson & Associates International Ltd., Burmuda wrote to Sabrina claiming interest payments on the loan of $6,000,000 as from the commencement of the loan in the sum of $322,273.97 based upon rates of interest varying from 10.5% per annum to 13.5%, per annum for that period. One of the signatories to this letter was Stephen Lam.

7. Having regard to the bankruptcy of Sabrina, the administrator sought directions from the court in its administrative capacity under O.85, r.2 of the Rules of the Supreme Court as to whether the first interim distribution from the estate could be retained as against the Official Receiver. Liu, J. held in a ruling delivered on the 26th

8. April 1988 that it could not be retained and should be paid to the Official Receiver. However, he also held that it had been established that there was prima facie evidence that Sabrina was indebted to the deceased's estate.

9. After the directions sought from Liu J. had been given, the administrator submitted a proof of debt with the Official Receiver against the estate of Sabrina in which iv was claimed that the money was advanced by Bylamson as agent for the deceased to Sabrina and was repayable upon demand. The claim was supported by the letter from Stephen Lam and Sabrina to Cititrust dated the 26th November 1982, the receipt signed by Sabrina of the same date described as a promissory note, and the letter from Bylamson to Sabrina dated the 26th May 1983 claiming interest. The Official Receiver rejected the proof of debt on the grounds that the agency between the deceased and Bylamson & Associates International Limited had not been proved, that the promissory note dated the 26th November 1982 was invalid and the debt was not proved.

10. In this appeal, no evidence was given by Sabrina but reference was made to testimony that she had given in the bankruptcy proceedings in the United' States where, in answer to a question as to whether she had received a loan from the deceased, she pleaded the Fifth Amendment, thereby refusing to give evidence which may tend to incriminate her. However, she went on to say that she had received a sum of $6,000,000 from Bylamson but again claimed the Fifth Amendment as to when this sum was received.

11. Stephen Lam gave evidence that Sabrina had informed him that the deceased had made a loan to her of $6,000,000. He claimed that the loan had been made to her by means of the Bylamson companies so that all the beneficiaries would be aware of this fact. He explained that the absence of documents to support the loan was because it was done by way of an internal transfer so that the monies never, in fact, left Hong Kong. With regard to the latter claiming interest, he said that such interest would have been paid to the deceased, but in fact, no payments were ever made. He was not aware of the identity of the person who had decided upon the quantum of interest to be paid. Mr Lam agreed that he did not verify the loan with the deceased despite the fact that he was one of her attorneys. Until quite recently Mr Lam had not even mentioned to the administrator the existence of a loan from the deceased to Sabrina.

12. Another son of the deceased Mr Rogerio Lam did not give evidence, but Mr godson in his affidavit made on behalf of the administrator, states that Mr Lam had asserted that the advance of $6,000,000 from the deceased to Sabrina by means of the company's account was a mere conduit and had been dealt with in this manner for tax purposes. Mr Rogerio Lam gave evidence in the proceedings before Liu J. that there was a risk of death duty being imposed on the amount of the loan if it was not repaid in time. Mr Rogerio Lam wrote to the solicitors for the administrator on the 24th March 1987, to the effect that according to Stephen Lam, who was in charge of the matter for Bylamson, the arrangement was carried out under the specific direction of the deceased and that the Burmdda company acted in the capacity of agent so it would not upset the previous overseas deposit arrangement with Cititrust. As the company had acted as the agent for the deceased, no loan agreement was prepared for the deceased did not have an account with the company. Mr R. Lam regarded the loan as a one-off transaction. He confirmed that the company was willing to assign all the rights with regard to the loan to the estate of the deceased.

13. When the receipt was submitted to the Official Receiver by the administrator, it was described as a promissory note but it is clear, having regard to the provisions of section 89(1) of the Bills of Exchange Ordinance that there is no reference to the money being repayable on a fixed or determinable date in the future to or to the order of a specified person or to bearer. Indeed Miss Yuen did not seriously pursue this aspect but relied upon the fact that it amounted to a receipt for the money.

14. Apart from the evidence given by Stephen Lam that Sabrina had been granted a loan by the deceased, there was no evidence to support the administrator's contention that such a loan had been made. Sabrina did not testify in these proceedings whilst she refused to inform the United States Bankruptcy Court as to whether a loan had been made to her by the deceased. All the documentary evidence shows that if a loan was made it was made by Bylamson, Burmuda to Sabrina. That evidence was wholly inconsistent with the administrator's argument that loan had been made by the deceased. Even if there had been any merit in this argument, there could be no conceivable reason for the interest to be paid as claimed by Bylamson. Stephen Lam could provide no plausible reason for the demand and agreed that the matter of interest had never been mentioned by Sabrina. The explanation for the circuitous route from the deceased to Sabrina on the grounds that it eras for tax purposes or would, in some way, affect the overseas deposit arrangements with Cititrust was neither credible nor had it any evidential basis upon the facts.

15. Stephen Lam who was the only witness who gave viva voce evidence was most unimpressive. His mere acceptance that a loan had been made by the deceased to Sabrina without verification was unconvincing, particularly, as be was a joint attorney. Again, it is most unlikely that he would have delayed until recently to inform the administrator of the facts of the loan if he had been a witness of truth. The reason that he gave for the loan being made by means of the Bylamson companies was to acquaint the beneficiaries with knowledge of the loan was apart from being purely speculative, quite ludicrous. I have no hesitation in rejecting his evidence and find as a fact that Sabrina never informed him that a loan had been made to her by the deceased.

16. There was no evidence that Bylamson acted as agent for the deceased nor from Sabrina as I have said, that she borrowed the money from her mother. I am therefore satisfied that the Official Receiver was wholly justified in rejecting the proof of debt.

17. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed. There will be an order nisi for costs to the Official Receiver.

(B.L. Jones)

Judge of the High Court

Representation:

Miss Maria Yuen (Philip K.H. Wong & Co.) for Appellant.

Mr Kevin Lewis for the Respondent.