HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
2017

KWOK HIU CHUN DAMIEN v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV125/1985FEDERAL ENTERPRISES CO LTD v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • CACV126/1989STANDARD CHARTERED BANK AND ANOTHER v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • CACV202/2011THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. CHAN KIN HANG DANVIL
  • CACV222/2007THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. CHAN HING TO
  • CACV269/1998THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. POA KWOK HO ALEXANDER
  • CACV271/2006LEUNG YAT TUNG v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • CACV367/2005THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. WILLIAM NICHOLAS GILES AND ANOTHER
  • CACV541/2018THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. BROWN COLVIN MORTON
  • CACV80/1989STANDARD CHARTERED BANK AND ANOTHER v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • CACV84/2006THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. CHAN HING TO
  • CAMP138/2020THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. CHOW TUNG SHAN
  • HCA2731/2015CHUNG SUN KWAN v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCAL63/2002PHILIP LEIGH TOSE v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCAL64/2002WONG WING CHEONG, PETER v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCAL67/2003COSIMO BORRELLI AND ANOTHER v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCB1/1977EDWARD WONG & CO LTD v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCB251/1983MARIA PUN SIU FUN v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCB297/1984STANDARD CHARTERED BANK HONG KONG TRUSTEE LTD v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER
  • HCB941/1990THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER v. MAK PUI YUK AND OTHERS
  • HCCW20/2014DAVID MOY v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER

Files (2)

112737-EN-2017-12-14

KWOK HIU CHUN DAMIEN v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER

HTML content

CACV 59/2017

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 59 OF 2017

(ON APPEAL FROM HCB NO. 5440 OF 2012)

________________________

Between 
 RE: Kwok Hiu Chun Damien
(郭曉駿) (the ‘Bankrupt’)

________________________

 Kwok Hiu Chun Damien (郭曉駿)Appellant
 and
 The Official ReceiverRespondent

________________________

Before: Hon Cheung, Kwan and Poon JJA in Court

Dates of Appellant’s written submissions: 19 October 2017 and 9 November 2017

Date of Respondent’s written submissions: 3 November 2017

Date of Decision: 14 December 2017

________________________

D E C I S I O N

________________________


Hon Cheung JA (giving Decision of the Court) :

1.  This is the appellant’s application for leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal against our judgment of 3 August 2017 with reasons for judgment given on 8 August 2017.

2.  The appellant contends that the appeal involves issues of great, general or public importance.  The grounds that are set out in the amended notice of motion are as follows :

‘ 1. the appeal involves great general or public importance concerning the protection of the accrued or vested benefits under laws of the Mandatory Provident Schemes Funds (Cap. 485 Laws of Hong Kong) (“MPFSO”), the Occupational Retirement Schemes Ordinance (Cap. 426 Laws of Hong Kong) (“ORSO”) against the operation of the Bankruptcy Ordinance (Cap. 6 Laws of Hong Kong) (“BO”) for such disposition made, if justified, for the purposes of provisions of the Employment Ordinance (Cap. 57 Laws of Hong Kong) (“EO”) more specifically:-

(a) Whether section 58 of the BO attaches all the benefits of an ORSO scheme at the time a bankruptcy order is being made;      

(b) Whether section 16 of the MPFSO or any other provision under the MPFSO and/or ORSO or any other law would provide protection of the benefits in the schemes or disposition of any such benefits (for purpose of enjoyment by the scheme member or the preservation as minimum MPF benefits pursuant to Schedule 2 of the Mandatory Provident Fund Schemes (Exemption) Regulation (Cap. 486 sub leg B”) (“the Exemption Regulation”); and

(c) Whether in the circumstances when a bankruptcy order is in force prior in time the employer to an ORSO scheme can still set off any benefits pursuant to section 70A of the ORSO for the purpose of meeting its LSP obligations under the EO and being relieved from making payment from the employer’s own resources.’

3.  We will not grant leave.  As stated in our reasons for judgment, the exclusion application by the appellant was based solely on section 16 of MPFSO.  As section 16 is not applicable by virtue of section 6 of the MandatoryProvident Fund Schemes (Exemption) Regulation (Cap. 485 sub leg B) (‘the Exemption Regulation’), the appellant has no basis to lodge his exclusion application.  As such, the three questions are not engaged and are academic.  The appellant submits that our interpretation of section 6 is wrong.  However, it is not said that the interpretation of section 6 is one of great, general or public importance.  What the appellant really wants is to have a second appeal on the interpretation of section 6 when this point is plainly unarguable and it is not shown that this is an issue which may affect a wide sector of employees in Hong Kong.

4.  Accordingly the application is dismissed with costs to the respondent which we summarily assess at $60,000. The appellant’s own costs are to be taxed in accordance with the Legal Aid Regulations.

(Peter Cheung)(Susan Kwan)(Jeremy Poon)
Justice of Appeal
Justice of Appeal
Justice of Appeal

Mr Wong Chao Wai Brian, instructed by Wong, Fung & Co, for the Appellant (Bankrupt)

Mr Anthony HK Chan, for the Official Receiver

110714-EN-2017-08-08

KWOK HIU CHUN DAMIEN v. THE OFFICIAL RECEIVER

HTML content

CACV 59/2017

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 59 OF 2017

(ON APPEAL FROM HCB NO. 5440 OF 2012)

________________________

 RE: Kwok Hiu Chun Damien (郭曉駿) (the ‘Bankrupt’)

________________________

BETWEEN

Kwok Hiu Chun Damien (郭曉駿) Appellant
and
The Official Receiver Respondent

________________________

Before : Hon Cheung, Kwan and Poon JJA in Court
Date of Hearing : 3 August 2017
Date of Judgment : 3 August 2017
Date of Reasons for Judgment : 8 August 2017

________________________

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

________________________

Hon Cheung JA :

I.The appeal

1.1   A bankruptcy order was made on 25 September 2012 against the bankrupt based on his own petition for bankruptcy.  The bankrupt applied under section 43D of the Bankruptcy Ordinance (Cap 6) (‘BO’) to exclude the amount of $85,625.94 paid out by his employer, the MTR Corporation Limited (‘MTRC’), to him as long service award from his estate for the purpose of the BO (‘the exclusion application’).  The exclusion application was refused by Master Simon Lo.  Pursuant to extension of time granted by Anthony Chan J, the bankrupt appealed against the decision of Master Lo. 

1.2   The Master’s jurisdiction to hear the application is under Practice Direction 3.1 on Bankruptcy and Winding-Up Proceedings.  Para 3.1(j) confers jurisdiction to hear the exclusion application. Section 98(2) of the BO provides for the Court of Appeal to hear appeals from the exclusion application.  This Court heard the appeal without the benefit of a reasoned decision by the Master as he did not provide such a decision and the parties did not request one.  This is unsatisfactory. On appeal to this Court, a reasoned decision from below should always be provided.

1.3    We dismissed the appeal at the conclusion of the hearing.  We ordered the bankrupt to pay the OR the costs of the appeal and the application for extension of time.  Such costs (together with the costs of HCMP 2074/2016) are to be taxed by the taxing master.

1.4   I now give reasons for our decision.

II. Background

2.1   The bankrupt was an employee of MTRC between 15 November 2005 and 18 February 2014.  On 1 July 2009, he elected to change from the Mandatory Provident Fund Scheme (‘MPF Scheme’) under the Mandatory Provident Fund Schemes Ordinance (Cap 485) (‘MPFSO’) to the MTRC Provident Fund Scheme (‘P Fund Scheme’) under the Occupational Retirement Schemes Ordinance (Cap 426) (‘ORSO’).  The bankrupt applied for early retirement from MTRC and his last day of employment was 18 February 2014.

2.2   The bankrupt later received a payment advice concerning the P Fund Scheme which showed that he had an accrued benefit of $159,405.76.  This sum is apportioned into two parts, a sum of $85,625.94 (‘the Sum’) was payable to him as long service payment and a sum of $73,779.82 which was stated to be benefit to be preserved under the Minimum MPF Benefits Rules.

2.3   On 25 February 2014, the bankrupt signed a receipt acknowledging receipt of the Sum as full payment from MTRC of the long service payment in accordance with the Employment Ordinance (Cap 57) (‘EO’).

2.4   The receipt also stated that:

‘ I understand that in accordance with the relevant statutory provisions and the governing rules of the [P Fund Scheme], my vested benefit in the [P Fund Scheme] that is attributable to the Employer’s contributions will be used to offset the amount of Long Service Payment paid by the Employer (the maximum amount of the vested benefits which can be used for offset is the amount of Long Service Payment paid).’

2.5   The Official Receiver (‘OR’) gave notice to claim, among other things, the Sum for the bankrupt’s estate on the basis that it was property acquired by him after the commencement of his bankruptcy.  On 6 March 2014, the bankrupt paid the Sum to the OR.

2.6   On 4 February 2016, Master Lo dismissed the bankrupt’s application to exclude the Sum from his estate.

Statutory retirement benefit schemes

3.1  There are two statutory schemes on employee retirement benefit.  One is under the MPFSO. The other is under ORSO.  Under section 5 of the MPFSO, the Mandatory Provident Fund Schemes Authority may issue a certificate of exemption exempting the members of an occupational retirement scheme and their employer from the provisions of the MPFSO.

3.2   Provisions relating to the exemption are found in the Mandatory Provident Fund Schemes (Exemption) Regulation (Cap 485 sub leg B) (‘the Exemption Regulation’).

3.3   Where a scheme under the ORSO is exempted from the MPFSO, it is subject to Schedule 2 of the Exemption Regulation which contained mandatory conditions applicable to the exempted ORSO scheme (section 17 of the Exemption Regulation).

3.4   Section 4 of Schedule 2 of the Exemption Regulation requires the preservation of ‘minimum MPF benefits’, the calculation of which is set out in section 1 of Schedule 2.  Under section 5 of Schedule 2, the trustee of the scheme shall transfer the ‘minimum MPF benefits’:

‘ (a) to a registered scheme in which the member’s new employer is a participating employer; or

(b) to a master trust scheme or an industry scheme, nominated by the member, that accepts transfers of minimum MPF benefits.’

3.5   Under section 6 of Schedule 2, among other things, the employee who has attained retirement age ‘shall be entitled as of right to have paid to him by the trustee of the scheme the entirety of his minimum MPF benefits in the scheme in a lump sum.’

3.6   Under section 15 of the Exemption Regulation, an employee may elect to change his retirement benefit scheme from the MPFSO to ORSO.

3.7   Under both the MPFSO (section 12A) and ORSO (section 70A), there are provisions which allowed the employer to set off from the accrued benefits, long service award/severance payment payable by the employer to the employee upon the termination of the employer’s employment under the EO.  In other words, the employee will not receive on retirement both his statutory benefit accrued on the one hand and long service award/‌severance payment on the other hand.

Section 16 of MPFSO and its application

4.1   This appeal was determined on a short point.  The exclusion application was based solely on section 16 under Part 3 of the MPFSO.  It provides that:

‘16. Protection of accrued benefits

(1) No part of any accrued benefits in a registered scheme in respect of a scheme member shall be taken in execution of a judgment debt or be the subject of any charge, pledge, lien, mortgage, transfer, assignment or alienation by or on behalf of the scheme member and any purported disposition to the contrary is void.

(1A) To avoid doubt, if a scheme member is adjudicated bankrupt, the right or entitlement of the scheme member to any accrued benefits in a registered scheme is excluded from the property of the scheme member for the purposes of the Bankruptcy Ordinance (Cap 6).’

4.2   Had the bankrupt received the accrued benefits under the MPFSO then this section will exclude them as his property for the purpose of the BO.  However, the bankrupt did not receive his accrued benefit under the MPFSO because he had elected to join the P Fund Scheme which is governed by the ORSO and not the MPFSO. Specifically, section 6 of the Exemption Regulation excludes the operation of section 16 of the MPFSO.  It provides that :

‘ 6. Effect of exemption certificate

 Without prejudice to the operation of section 3, the effect of an exemption certificate is that the existing members and new members of the ORSO exempted scheme to which the certificate relates, and the relevant employer of the scheme, are each exempt from Part 3 of the Ordinance.’

4.3   The exclusion provision of section 16 is within Part 3 of MPFSO.  As a result, section 16 is plainly not applicable and the bankrupt has no basis to lodge his exclusion application. This provides a complete answer to the bankrupt’s exclusion application and to this appeal.  This point cannot be overcome by Mr Wong’s submission that section 6 of the Exemption Regulation is not applicable to the OR. In my view, this is irrelevant because of the wording of section 6 : it affects the bankrupt directly because he is exempted from the exclusion provisions.

4.4   The minimum MPF benefits, however, are excluded from the bankrupt’s estate by virtue of section 16 of MPFSO because of its nature as an MPF benefit. 

Other matters

5.  It is not necessary for the purpose of this appeal to consider the other points by Mr Wong concerning the interpretation of section 16 and the calculation of the minimum MPF benefits.  The latter point was not even raised in the exclusion application.

Hon Kwan JA :

6.  I agree with the Reasons for Judgment of Cheung JA.

Hon Poon JA :

7.  I agree.

(Peter Cheung)(Susan Kwan)(Jeremy Poon)
Justice of AppealJustice of AppealJustice of Appeal

Mr Wong Chao Wai Brian, instructed by Wong, Fung & Co, for the Bankrupt

Mr Anthony HK Chan, for the Official Receiver