HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Civil Action1994

ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. AND OTHERS v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV1006/2000ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • CACV175/2000DR PAUL KI PING KI AND ANOTHER v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • CACV261/1998ORIENTAL DAILY PUBLISHER LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • CACV371/2000ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • CACV726/2001ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. AND OTHERS v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • FACV19/1999NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS v. ORIENTAL DAILY PUBLISHER LTD.
  • FAMV26/2001ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. AND ANOTHER v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • FAMV32/2000DR PAUL KI PING KI v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCA12443/1999IP WING KIN v. NEXT MAGAZING PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCA13058/1995ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. AND ANOTHER v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCA3831/1997ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCA4471/2000MORINDA INTERNATIONAL HONG KONG LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCA4902/1993MAK HAU SHING v. ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. and Others
  • HCA5217/1995ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. AND OTHERS v. TED THOMAS
  • HCA6206/1994CHINA YOUTH DEVELOPMENT LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS

Files (2)

38082-EN-2001-04-12

ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. AND OTHERS v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS

HTML content

HCA012525A/1994

HCA12525/1994

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO.12525 OF 1994

-------------------

BETWEEN
ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LIMITED1st Plaintiff
EASTERN EXPRESS PUBLISHER LIMITED2nd Plaintiff
MA CHING KWAN3rd Plaintiff
AND
NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LIMITED1st Defendant
CHEUNG KIM HUNG2nd Defendant
TOPPAN PRINTING COMPANY (H.K.) LIMITED3rd Defendant

---------------------

Coram: Hon Yam J in Court

Dates of Hearing: 15, 20 February, 7 and 10 March 2001

Dates of Written Submissions: 26, 27, 29 March, 4 and 10 April 2001

Date of Ruling: 12 April 2001

 

------------------------------

RULING NO. 5

------------------------------

 

1. This ruling concerned with five matters arising in the course of the trial in respect of which costs were expressly reserved. They are as follows :-

(1) 15 February 2001 : the plaintiffs' application to admit the statements of Mr Jenkins and Mr C.K. Ma under hearsay notices.

(2) 20 February 2001 : the defendants' application or submission of no case to answer in respect of the action of the 1st and 2nd plaintiffs.

(3) 7 March 2001 : the defendants' application to put the statement of Mr Vines made in the 1994 Action before the jury.

(4) 7 March 2001 : whether or not the defendants were obliged to call Mr Wilson as a witness to give evidence.

(5) 10 March 2001 : the defendants' application to withdraw the issue of malice in connection with the fair comment defence from the jury.

The submissions of the parties were made through their solicitors' letters after their respective counsel were consulted. Both parties did not require a hearing.

The agreed items

2. In respect of Item (1), the plaintiffs accepted that the defendants should be entitled to costs. The admission of Mr Jenkins' statement was not strenuously opposed and in fact the defendants accepted that Mr Jenkins had already died. Mr Ma's statement was not admitted after argument.

3. In respect of Item (5), the plaintiffs also agreed that the defendants should be entitled to costs since their application to withdraw the issue of malice from the jury in respect of the defence of fair comment was successful.

4. In respect of Item (3), the defendants on the other hand agreed that their application to put in the statement of Mr Vines was unsuccessful and the plaintiffs are entitled to the costs therefor.

The disputed items

5. Under Item (2), the defendants' submission of no case to answer in respect of the 1st plaintiff was already dismissed with costs to the 1st plaintiff against the defendants. Thus no further order is required in respect of the 1st plaintiff.

6. In respect of the 2nd plaintiff, the defendants were put to their election as to whether or not to proceed with their application without calling any further evidence or to postpone making the application until a later time. The defendants decided to call their evidence. Mr Vines was called by the defendants but in my view, he did not assist the defendants in any material way in respect of the issue whether the 2nd plaintiff was the publisher of Eastern Express. The evidence adduced by the plaintiffs clearly indicated that not a single item of expenditure was ever paid by the 2nd plaintiff. It cannot therefore be said that the defendants must have considered there was at least a case to leave to the jury by reason of the additional evidence from Mr Vines concerning the 2nd plaintiff's role as the publisher. Further, the jury's verdict clearly indicated that they were unanimous in deciding that from the evidence available, the 2nd plaintiff was not the publisher. Otherwise the verdict should also be six to one in respect of the 2nd plaintiff. If the defendants have elected not to adduce any further evidence in respect of whether the 2nd plaintiff was the publisher, the court would have granted the application by reason of the state of evidence as aforesaid. In the end, I consider that the defendants should be entitled to the costs order of "the defendants' costs in the cause". Eventually the defendants succeeded in the action of the 2nd plaintiff. The defendants in effect are entitled to the costs of this application in respect of the 2nd plaintiff.

7. In respect of Item (4), the defendants indicated that Mr Wilson would not be called after Mr Vines had finished his evidence. Lengthy submissions were made. The court indicated that it is not an application from the defendants for a ruling that the defendants were not obliged to call Mr Wilson, since the court has no power to force the defendants to call a witness. However, the court agreed with the plaintiffs' counsel that it would be entirely unfair to the plaintiffs when they were given to understand all along that the defence would call Mr Wilson. Thus, they allowed Mr Vines to comment on Mr Wilson's notes in the course of Mr Vines' evidence. The plaintiffs also indicated that should such a course be adopted by the defendants, they would probably take a more drastic application. Having warned of such a situation, the defendants eventually decided to call Mr Wilson when the court expressed its misgivings of such a course to be taken by the defendants. I cannot see why the defendants should not bear the costs of the plaintiffs for the time spent in arguing over this matter, i.e. whether or not Mr Wilson should be called as a witness.

Conclusion

8. Accordingly, I make the following orders of costs in respect of the aforesaid five matters, namely :-

(1) The defendants are entitled to costs for the plaintiffs' application to admit the statements of Mr Jenkins and Mr Ma.

(2) In respect of the defendants' application of no case to answer in the action of the 2nd plaintiff, the defendants are entitled to a costs order of "the defendants' costs in the cause".

(3) The plaintiffs are entitled to the costs of the defendants' application to put the statement of Mr Vines before the jury which was dismissed.

(4) The plaintiffs are entitled to the costs of the argument as to whether or not the defendants should call Mr Wilson.

(5) The defendants are entitled to the costs in respect of their application to withdraw the issue of malice under the defence of fair comment.

9. There shall be certificate for two counsel for the aforesaid orders of costs in case anyone of them was heard in chambers.

 

 

(D. Yam)
Judge of the Court of First Instance,
High Court

 

Representation:

Mr Cheng Huan, SC, and Mr Jason W.N. Pow, instructed by Messrs Iu, Lai & Li, for the Plaintiffs

Mr Benjamin Yu, SC, and Mr Anderson Chow, instructed by Messrs Deacons, for the Defendants

 

Please refer to CACV726/2001 for the relevant appeal(s) to the Court of Appeal.

38194-EN-1998-01-27

ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. and Others v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. and Others

HTML content

HCA012525/1994

1994, No. A12525

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

BETWEENORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LIMITEDFirst Plaintiff
EASTERN EXPRESS PUBLISHER LIMITEDSecond Plaintiff
MA CHING KWANThird Plaintiff
AND
NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LIMITEDFirst Defendant
CHEUNG KIM HUNGSecond Defendant
TOPPAN PRINTING COMPANY (HK) LIMITEDThird Defendant

Coram: the Hon Mr Justice Findlay, in Chambers

Date of hearing: 23 January 1998

Date of handing down of judgment: 27 January 1998

 

______________

JUDGMENT

______________

 

1. I have before me a summons issued by the defendants by which they seek an order against the plaintiffs for specific discovery of documents under Order 24, rule 7. The documents are described in a schedule. The schedule reads -

"The documents above referred to are the following, that is:

1. All the pleadings, all the affidavits/affirmations (if any) and all the statements of witnesses filed by the parties with the Court in High Court Action No.A2091 of 1995 (Oriental Press Group Limited v. Stephen Vines) including, but not limited to, the witnesses statements of Stephen Vines, Jonathan Marsh, Tan Thean Peng, Caron Fan, Karl Wilson, Stephen Porctor and Jonathan Mirsky;

2. All the pleadings, all the affidavits/affirmations (if any) and all the statements of witnesses filed by the parties with the Court in High Court Action No.A9415 of 1994 (Pan Britain Limited v. OPG Human Resources Limited)."

2. This action against the defendants is based on an alleged libel contained in Next Magazine published on 16 September 1994. The defence admits the publication, but pleads meanings that are true, and fair comment.

3. In an affidavit in support of the summons, it is said that action A2091 is an action by the first plaintiff in this action against Mr Vines in which it is alleged that Mr Vines "made defamatory remarks against Oriental Press Group on matters same, or substantially the same, as the issues in the present Action". Action A9415 is an action by a company wholly owned by Mr Vines claiming damages for wrongful termination of a contract "which again is an issue leading to the complaints of the Plaintiffs in the present Action". The only evidence of the relevance of these documents is the statement that "the said documents are directly relevant to the issues in the present action." The rule requires that that a supporting affidavit states that a document, or class of document, "relates to one or more of the matters in question in the cause or matter." It is not possible to ascertain from the affidavit which document, or class of document, relates to which matter in question.

4. Because the evidence before me did not explain this, or why these documents were relevant to the action in any general sense at all, I sought this information from Mr Wong. He said the issues to which the documents were relevant in this action were justification and fair comment. These are not, of course, issues. They are defences pleaded by the defendants. It is difficult to see what facts pleaded to support these defences will be, at trial, seriously in issue; very few, I suspect. Certainly, I have not been told which facts are in issue. It looks to me as if most of the trial will be about inferences to be drawn from the undoubted facts, and arguments of law. After some badgering by me, Mr Wong said that the relevance of the documents was to enable the defendants to see if there was something said in them that was inconsistent with what was said in this action, or something said in them that the defendants did not know about. This is what Mr Wong said before Mr Whitehead addressed the court. In his reply, however, Mr Wong conceded that, if the relevance of the documents went only to a question of credibility, discovery should not be ordered. Apart from the question of credibility, Mr Wong did not, as I understood him, clearly identify any other "matter in question" to which any document, or class of documents, related.

5. In this application, the defendants seek discovery of some specific documents - the statements of the persons named - but generally seeks discovery of classes of documents. Where discovery is sought of a class of documents, the class, as defined, must not include documents that are not relevant; all the documents must relate to a matter in question, not just some of them.

6. The case of Dolling-Baker v. Merrett 1990 1 WLR 1205 is similar to the case before me. In Dolling-Baker, the plaintiff was claiming under a policy of re-insurance against the insurer and the placing broker. The plaintiff sought discovery of documents in an arbitration in which a similar policy featured and for which the defendants were also insurer and placing broker.

7. In that case, the documents sought were described in terms remarkably similar to the description in the case before me -

"All pleadings, documents, witness statements, experts reports and any other relevant documents produced and/or disclosed in the arbitrations . . ."

8. Parker, LJ, with whose judgment Ralph Gibson, LJ and Fox, LJ agreed, described the application as "of a somewhat unusual width, to say the least".

9. At the stage of discovery, it is for the applicants to satisfy me on the matter of relevance. If they do that, it is for the plaintiffs to show that discovery is unnecessary.

10. Starting at the beginning of the documents sought, is there any reason to suppose that the pleadings filed in action A2091 contain information which might enable the defendants to advance their own case, damage that of the plaintiffs, or lead to a train of inquiry that would? Certainly, the defendants have given me no reason to think so. The most that Mr Wong is able to say is that they might be inconsistent with the plaintiffs' allegations in this matter, and thus provide ammunition to fire at the plaintiffs at the trial. Well, I suppose they might, but I have been given no basis to think that it would be reasonable to suppose so. In any event, the "pleadings" cover those of Mr Vines as well. On what basis can it be said that it would be reasonable to suppose that the pleadings by Mr Vines would help the defendants in defending the suit by the plaintiffs; that they are, in any way, relevant? I can ascertain none. And this applies also to the other documents, or classes of documents, about which discovery is sought.

11. In Dolling-Baker, Parker, LJ said this -

"I accept that there is good reason to suppose that some parts of the above are, or might be, relevant within the meaning of the Peruvian Guano case, 11 QBD 55 and that, other considerations apart, some form of limited order for discovery might be made. But the plaintiff has not in my view made out a case sufficient to enable me to frame any acceptable order. I would therefore allow the appeal on that ground."

12. I find myself in a similar position, except that I see the defendants' case before me as weaker. The position in this case is that there might possibly be some reason to suppose that some document sought might be relevant in the sense that the document might be used as a weapon in attacking the credibility of witnesses, but the defendants have not made out a case beyond that, and the defendants have given me no basis on which I could identify such a document. That, in my view, is not sufficient.

13. In any event, it seems to me that the use of this Order should not be encouraged where the sole purpose of the exercise is to undertake a fishing expedition in the hope that something may surface to provide the applicant with some arrows to fire at the other side at the trial. So, on this ground, I would decline to exercise my discretion in favour of the defendants.

14. Accordingly, I dismiss the application with costs to the plaintiffs.

JK FINDLAY
Judge of the High Court
Court of First Instance

Representation:

Mr Robert Whitehead, instructed by Messrs Lovell White Durrant, for the plaintiffs.

Mr Wong Hin-Lee, instructed by Messrs TS Tong & Co, for the defendants.