HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Miscellaneous Proceedings (Civil)2000

DR PAUL KI PING KI v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV1006/2000ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • CACV175/2000DR PAUL KI PING KI AND ANOTHER v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • CACV261/1998ORIENTAL DAILY PUBLISHER LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • CACV33/2004DR PAUL KI PING KI v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD AND OTHERS
  • CACV371/2000ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • CACV726/2001ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. AND OTHERS v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • FACV19/1999NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS v. ORIENTAL DAILY PUBLISHER LTD.
  • FAMV26/2001ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. AND ANOTHER v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCA12443/1999IP WING KIN v. NEXT MAGAZING PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCA12525/1994ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. AND OTHERS v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCA13058/1995ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. AND ANOTHER v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCA3831/1997ORIENTAL PRESS GROUP LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCA4173/2001DR PAUL KI PING KI v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD AND OTHERS
  • HCA4471/2000MORINDA INTERNATIONAL HONG KONG LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCA6206/1994CHINA YOUTH DEVELOPMENT LTD. v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS
  • HCAL92/2012DR PAUL KI PING KI v. REGISTRATION AND ELECTORAL OFFICE
21378-EN-2000-12-08

DR PAUL KI PING KI v. NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD. AND OTHERS

HTML content

FAMV000032/2000

FAMV No. 32 of 2000

IN THE COURT OF FINAL APPEAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

MISCELLANEOUS PROCEEDINGS NO. 32 OF 2000 (CIVIL)

(ON APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL
FROM CACV NO. 175 OF 2000)

_____________________

Between:
DR PAUL KI PING-KI1st Applicant
HONG KONG WASHINGTON COMPANY2nd Applicant
AND
NEXT MAGAZINE PUBLISHING LTD1st Respondent
CHEUNG KIM HUNG2nd Respondent
TOPPAN PRINTING CO. (HK) LTD3rd Respondent
YEUNG WAI HONG4th Respondent
LEE KWONG FUNG5th Respondent

_____________________

Appeal Committee: Mr Justice Bokhary PJ, Mr Justice Chan PJ and Mr Justice Ribeiro PJ

Date of Hearing: 8 December 2000

Date of Determination: 8 December 2000

 

______________________________

DETERMINATION

______________________________

 

Mr Justice Chan PJ :

1. The applicant applies for leave to appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision. That decision confirmed the order of Madam Justice Yuen who refused to grant him leave to appeal against a Master's order out of time.

2. The issue in the courts below was this: whether the 1st respondent could set off its liability to pay the applicant's damages in the second defamation action against its entitlement to costs from the applicant in the first defamation action under s.35 of the Bankruptcy Ordinance. The Master held that the 1st respondent could. Ten months later, the applicant applied to the judge for leave to appeal out of time. The judge held that even putting aside the delay, the appeal was not arguable. The Court of Appeal agreed.

3. We do not think leave to appeal further should be granted for the following reasons. The decision of the Court of Appeal was not a final order and the amount in dispute was not in excess of $1 million. The applicant has also failed to show that there is any point of law of great general or public importance. Six grounds of appeal are relied on. The first four grounds arise from a misunderstanding on the part of the applicant of the procedure and are totally unfounded. The last two grounds relate to the application of s.35 of the Bankruptcy Ordinance which governs a set off in the case of a bankruptcy. The Registrar, the judge and the Court of Appeal relying on good authorities were clearly right in their decisions. These grounds are not reasonably arguable.

4. For these reasons, we would refuse the application for leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal. We see no reason why the applicant should not pay the respondent the costs of this application.

 

 

(Kemal Bokhary)(Patrick Chan)(R.A.V. Ribeiro)
Permanent JudgePermanent JudgePermanent Judge

 

Representation:

1st applicant in person

2nd applicant represented by the 1st applicant

Mr Richard Khaw (instructed by Messrs T.S. Tong & Co.) for the respondents