HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Civil Action2010

HASHIMI HABIB HALIM v. DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION AND OTHERS

Related cases with same parties

  • CACC526/2001HKSAR v.HASHIMI HABIB HALIM
  • HCAL139/2007HASHIMI HABIB HALIM v. DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION
  • HCAL1540/2022GURUNG SANTA BAHADUR v. DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION AND OTHERS
  • HCAL1573/2023ZIA, UR REHMAN MUGHAL alias MUGHAL ZIA, UR REHMAN v. DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION AND OTHERS
  • HCAL1788/2023WALLACE SHAUN MARK v. DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION AND OTHERS
  • HCAL2/2016SINGH GILL JATINDER v. DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION AND OTHERS
  • HCAL251/2015HASHIMI HABIB HALIM v. DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION
  • HCAL269/2017HASHIMI HABIB HALIM v. SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE
  • HCAL436/2024ALI NAZAKAT v. DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION AND OTHERS
  • HCAL466/2021AM v. DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION AND OTHERS
  • HCMA286/2002HKSAR v. HASHIMI HABIB HALIM
  • HCMA847/2010HKSAR v. HASHIMI HABIB HALIM
  • HCMP995/2015HKSAR v. HASHIMI HABIB HALIM
[2023] HKCFI 1641-EN-2023-06-16

HASHIMI HABIB HALIM v. DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION AND OTHERS

HTML content

HCA 377/2010

[2023] HKCFI 1641

IN THE COMPETITION TRIBUNAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO 377 OF 2010

________________

BETWEEN

 HASHIMI HABIB HALIMPlaintiff
 and 
 DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION1st Defendant
 SECRETARY FOR SECURITY2nd Defendant
 COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES3rd Defendant

________________

Before: Hon Harris J in Chambers
Date of Hearing: 16 June 2023
Date of Decision: 16 June 2023

________________

D E C I S I O N

________________

1.  I have before me applications arising on the pre-trial review of this action which is currently fixed to commence on 11 September 2023 with six days reserved. The Defendants have issued a summons seeking leave to amend the defence, to file a supplemental witness statement of Chan Fong and seven witness statements of new witnesses. This is not very satisfactory. I have, however, allowed the applications.

2.  The Plaintiff is acting in person and his claims arise from a period of detention in Correctional Services Department facilities. In short, he complains of mistreatment. The new witness statements are staff employed at those facilities, who it is contended by the Defendants have knowledge of the matters of which the Plaintiff complains.

3.  The Plaintiff’s position is that he is not particularly concerned at the introduction of this late evidence as long as he has the opportunity to cross examine the witnesses, which he would obviously have. He has expressed some doubts as to whether or not the Defendants have fully complied with their obligation to disclose certain data including CCTV video footage.

4.  I have suggested to him that he writes a letter to the Department of Justice setting out what he believes should be available to him, but which he has not received.

5.  I have made fairly conventional directions for the preparation for the trial. In the light of the new witnesses I have extended the trial dates by three days. The Plaintiff will be conducting the trial in English. It would appear likely that most if not all the Defendants’ witnesses will give evidence in Cantonese.

6.  I have directed that a Cantonese/English interpreter be available at the trial. The Defendants have agreed to prepare hearing bundles and to add document references to the witness statements to enable of the witness statements to be easily navigated.

7.  As the Plaintiff is representing himself and he is not familiar with legal proceedings the trial is, unfortunately, likely to proceed in a rather disjointed and cumbersome manner it would be helpful if the Defendants try and ensure so far as possible that documentation and administrative matters are dealt with efficiently.

  (Jonathan Harris)
Judge of the Court of First Instance
High Court

The plaintiff is acting in person

Mr Herbert Leung, instructed by Department of Justice, for the 1st to 3rd defendants