HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Bankruptcy Proceedings2015

LEE CHICK CHOI v. WONG KA SEK and WONG KA LAM KING,<br>the Joint and Several Trustees of the Property of<br>LEE CHICK CHOI, a bankrupt

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV138/2015LEE CHICK CHOI v. BEST SPIRITS CO LTD
  • CACV25/2015LEE CHICK CHOI v. BEST SPIRITS CO LTD
  • CACV276/2018LEE CHICK CHOI v. THE DIRECTOR OF LEGAL AID
  • CACV28/2013NG YIN NEI v. LEE CHICK CHOI
  • CACV29/2013NG YIN NEI v. LEE CHICK CHOI
  • CAMP313/2022LEE CHICK CHOI v. THE HONG KONG GOLF CLUB
  • CAMP79/2018LEE CHICK CHOI v. BEST SPIRITS CO LTD
  • DCEO11/2019LEE CHICK CHOI v. THE HONG KONG GOLF CLUB
  • HCA2045/2012LEE CHICK CHOI v. BEST SPIRITS CO LTD
  • HCAL417/2018LEE CHICK CHOI v. THE DIRECTOR OF LEGAL AID
  • HCLA19/2013LEE CHICK CHOI v. BEST SPIRITS CO LTD
  • HCLA29/2011LEE CHICK CHOI v. BEST SPIRITS CO LTD
  • HCMP371/2015LEE CHICK CHOI v. BEST SPIRITS CO LTD
  • HCMP401/2015LEE CHICK CHOI v. BEST SPIRITS CO LTD

Files (2)

[2019] HKCFI 1432-EN-2019-05-30

LEE CHICK CHOI v. WONG KA SEK and WONG KA LAM KING,<br>the Joint and Several Trustees of the Property of<br>LEE CHICK CHOI, a bankrupt

HTML content

HCB 1128/2015

[2019] HKCFI 1432

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

BANKRUPTCY PROCEEDINGS NO 1128 OF 2015

________________

RE:LEE CHICK CHOI, a bankrupt 
BETWEEN  
 LEE CHICK CHOIApplicant

and

 WONG KA SEK and WONG KA LAM KING,
the Joint and Several Trustees of the Property of
LEE CHICK CHOI, a bankrupt
Respondents

________________

Before:Deputy High Court Judge William Wong SC in Chambers
Date of Hearing:30 May 2019
Date of Decision:30 May 2019

________________

DECISION

________________

1.  I have before me two applications taken out by Mr Lee Chick Choi (“the Applicant”). The first is a summon taken out on 22 May 2019 (“the Summons”) under which the Applicant sought the following order from this court:

“ The Trustees to issue a letter of No Objection for my automatice [sic]

discharge which was due on 18th May 2019 under Section 30A of the Bankruptcy Ordinance (Cap.6) when I am having a pending application for leave to appeal in FAMV51/2018 in the Court of Final Appeal closely related with the Trustees’ consent in question for my claim of HK$14,475,849.00 under Section 66 of PDPO which is a precedent case in HKSAR, and/or issue a certificate of discharge by a Judge.”

2.  What happened was that on 21 May 2019, the Applicant’s wife went to the office of the Trustees in Bankruptcy to obtain a No Objection Letter for the Applicant so that the Applicant would be able to apply to court for a certificate of discharge.

3.  Mr Chong, the person in charge of the matter, was taking sick leave on 21 May 2019.  Accordingly, a member of staff of the Trustees in Bankruptcy, advised the Applicant’s wife to make a call to Mr Chong the next day to make further arrangement.

4.  The Applicant and/or his wife did not make a call to Mr Chong the next day. Instead, he took out the Summons.  Mr Yung who appears for the Trustees in Bankruptcy today submits that the Trustees in Bankruptcy did not even know that the woman who appeared in their office is the Applicant’s wife.

5.  On 27 May 2019, Mr Chong called the Applicant and asked him whether he would like to come to their office to collect the No Objection Letter.  The Applicant said that he has already issued a summons and did not go to the office of the Trustees in Bankruptcy to collect the No Objection Letter.

6.  Accordingly, the No Objection Letter was posted to the Applicant which he duly received on 29 May 2019, one day before today’s hearing.

7.  First, as the Applicant has already received the No Objection Letter, there is no need for this court to make an order in terms of the Summons and the Applicant did not press for the same.  Basically, the Summons has been rendered academic.

8.  Secondly, the Trustees in Bankruptcy ask for dismissal of the application with costs.  I agree.  The Summons is now formally dismissed.  As far as costs is concerned, it is obvious to this court when the Applicant was informed that the No Objection Letter was ready for his collection on 27 May 2019, he should not have insisted to proceed with the present hearing.  Court’s time and resources are limited.  The Applicant should either go to the office of the Trustees in Bankruptcy to collect the No Objection Letter or wait for the arrival of the same by post.  Today’s hearing can be avoided if the Applicant adopts a sensible and reasonable approach.  To insist that as a summons has been issued and therefore it has to be heard is incorrect.  The Applicant should have agreed with the Trustees in Bankruptcy to vacate the present hearing instead of incurring further costs.  A consent summons would have saved both costs and time.

9.  Accordingly, I make an order that the Applicant is to pay the costs of the Trustees in Bankruptcy to be taxed, if not agreed, on a party to party basis.

10.  Today, the Applicant also takes out a new application seeking acertificate of discharge pursuant to rule 92 of the Bankruptcy Rules, Cap 6A. 

11.  The Trustees in Bankruptcy have no objection to a certificate of discharge under rule 92 of the Bankruptcy Rules being issued to the Applicant.  There are no other circumstances which indicate that a certificate of discharge should not be issued.

12.  In the circumstances, the application for a certificate of discharge under rule 92 is granted.

 (William Wong SC)
 Deputy High Court Judge

  

The applicant appeared in person

Mr Isaac Yung, instructed by Jimmie K S Wong & Partners, for the respondents

Attendance of the Official Receiver was excused

 

98651-EN-2015-05-18

RE LEE CHICK CHOI

HTML content

HCB 1128/2015

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

BANKRUPTCY PROCEEDINGS NO. 1128 OF 2015

____________

Re: LEE CHICK CHOI (李積才), the Debtor

Ex Parte: BEST SPIRITS COMPANY LIMITED, the petitioner

____________

Before: Hon L Chan J in Court
Date of Hearing: 18 May 2015
Date of Judgment: 18 May 2015

______________

J U D G M E N T

______________

1.  This petition is brought on the basis of a debt owed by the debtor at HK$130,353.

2.  The ground of opposition is that the debtor is proceeding against the petitioner for a sum of HK$143,548 in DCCJ 4962/2014. The debtor says in that claim that it is a claim for service fee, but in fact it is a claim for salary as the claim is calculated on the basis of his salary for a period which was after the termination of his employment with the petitioner, but during which his name was still on an import/export licence issued by the Customs and Excise Department to the petitioner. 

3.  This claim has been dismissed in Labour Tribunal claim LBTC 588/2011, which was with a caveat that the presiding officer did not consider that she had the jurisdiction to deal with it.  The dismissal was way of an alternative finding. 

4.  The debtor applied for leave to appeal against the decision of the tribunal, but the application was dismissed in HCLA 29/2011 by Mimmie Chan J on 6 June 2013.

5.  The debtor made the same claim in HCA 2045/2012 in the last paragraph at the bottom of page 2 of the Statement of Claim in that action.  It was struck out by DHCJ Kent Yee on 1 December 2014. 

6.  The petitioner then issued a statutory demand against the debtor and the debtor applied to set it aside in HCSD 38/2011.  The application to set aside was determined by Anthony Chan J in HCSD 38/2011.  The learned judge said in paras 16 and 17 of his decision as follows:

“16. On 22 December 2014 the applicant served another writ of summons under DCCJ 496/2014 on the respondent claiming against it for service fee in the sum of HK$143,548.

17. It appears from the decision that the service fee claim was ventilated before the tribunal. Despite the tribunal’s ruling that it fell outside its jurisdiction, the tribunal did consider the same in the event that it was wrong on a question of jurisdiction. The tribunal concluded that there was no merit in a service fee claim and dismissed it.”

7.  In the light of the dismissal and also the dismissal of the application for leave to appeal, Anthony Chan J also dismissed the application to set aside a statutory declaration. 

8.  This morning, the debtor repeats the same argument which I also find unmeritorious. 

9.  Mr Yu, counsel for the creditor further referred me to page 77 of the hearing bundle where there is a copy of an order of the Court of Appeal dated 10 April 2015 ordering the debtor to pay the petitioner another sum of legal costs fixed at HK$50,000 by way of a costs order nisi.  The time for an application to vary this order nisi was seven days from the date of the order.  That period has expired and the debtor has not applied to vary it. 

10.  Mr Yu submits that despite the claim in DCCJ 4962, the sum in the petition and also this HK$50,000 legal costs put together far exceeds the claim in DCCJ 4962/2014, hence there is no reason not to adjudge the debtor a bankrupt.  I agree with Mr Yu and I make the usual bankruptcy order with the usual order of costs. 

Addendum

11.  After I have given my verbal decision, Mr Yu has very rightly informed me that, in fact, there has been an application to vary the costs order nisi.  In the light of that, I revise my decision that my decision is not based on that costs order of the Court of Appeal, but bearing in mind the dismissal in the claim of the Labour Tribunal, the dismissal of the application for leave, the dismissal by DHCJ Kent Yee in the High Court Action and the dismissal of the application to set aside the statutory demand by Anthony Chan J, bearing in mind all these, I also dismiss the opposition by the debtor to this petition. 

12.  I therefore make the bankruptcy order with the usual order of costs. 

(Louis Chan)
Judge of the Court of First Instance
High Court

Mr Jason Yu, instructed by Hobson & Ma, for the petitioner

The debtor appeared in person

Miss Tin Shuk-yi, for the Official Receiver