HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
2021

NGUYEN VAN TUOI v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMNT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV148/2022HAFIZ ALI RAZA v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMNT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
  • CACV167/2022RE JAGJEET SINGH
  • CACV179/2022ILUMUENI NZUZI ILOUS v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMNT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
  • CACV193/2022RE DHILLON MANJIT SINGH
  • CACV48/2022BUI THI HA v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMNT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
  • CACV57/2022SUTRISNOWATI BINTI ALI v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMNT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
  • CACV75/2021RE PANKAJ KUMAR
  • CACV85/2021NGUYEN VAN TUOI 對 酷刑聲請上訴委員會 /免遣返聲請呈請辦事處
  • HCAL466/2019NGUYEN VAN TUOI v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD/ NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE [Decision on Leave Application]

Files (2)

[2023] HKCA 242-EN-2023-03-02

RE NGUYEN VAN TUOI

HTML content

CACV 52/2021

[2023] HKCA 242

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO 52 OF 2021

(ON APPEAL FROM HCAL NO 466 OF 2019)

______________________

RE: NGUYEN VAN TUOIApplicant

______________________

Before: Hon Yuen and Au JJA in Court
Date of Judgment:2 March 2023

___________________

J U D G M E N T

___________________

Hon Yuen JA (giving the Judgment of the Court):

1.  This court handed down judgment on 25 February 2022 ([2022] HKCA 265) dismissing the applicant’s appeal against an order of DHCJ C P Pang (“the Judge”) given on 28 January 2021 refusing to grant leave to the applicant to apply for judicial review in respect of his non‑refoulement claim.

2.  The facts and issues in the appeal before this court, as well as the court’s reasons for dismissing it, are set out in our judgment and will not be repeated here.

3.  On 4 July 2022, the applicant filed a Notice of Motion for leave to appeal this court’s judgment to the Court of Final Appeal.  However, it was out of time, as section 24(2) of the Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal Ordinance (“HKCFAO”) (Cap. 484) stipulates that the deadline for filing an appeal from a judgment of the Court of Appeal is 28 days from the date of the judgment to be appealed from.  The last day for filing the Notice of Motion expired on 25 March 2022.  That fell during the High Court pandemic general adjournment period, which terminated on 11 April 2022.  He should therefore have filed the Notice of Motion the following day, 12 April 2022.   

4.  However, under sections 24(5) and 24(6) of the HKCFAO, the Court of Appeal has a discretion to extend the appeal period even though the application for extension is not made until after the expiration of that period.  In the exercise of our discretion whether or not to extend the appeal period, we should consider the length of the delay, the applicant’s reasons for the delay, the merits of the intended appeal, and whether any prejudice would be suffered by the other party. 

5.  In the present case, the applicant was late by almost 3 months, which is substantial.  No reasons for the delay were given in the Notice of Motion or in his supporting affirmation. 

6.  Moreover, the applicant has not shown any merits in this intended application for leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal.  The applicant did not provide any discernible ground for his intended appeal in the Notice of Motion and merely complained that this court dismissed his appeal against the Judge’s decision and that he would be harmed by his creditor and gangsters upon his return to his home country.  He considered the Director of Immigration had disregarded his human rights and he urged this Court to give him a chance to seek justice and to grant leave to him to go to the Court of Final Appeal.

7.  Pursuant to the directions of the Registrar of Civil Appeals given on 4 July 2022, the applicant should lodge his written submissions on or before 18 July 2022.  He failed to do so.  The Registrar further directed that in the event the applicant fails to lodge his written submissions, he will be deemed to have abandoned his right to rely on written submissions and the matter will be considered by the Court of Appeal based on the available materials.  This Notice of Motion is therefore determined on paper without an oral hearing, which we consider appropriate.   

8.  Section 22(1)(b) of the HKCFAO provides that leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal may be granted if the question involved in the appeal is one which, by reason of its great general or public importance, or otherwise, ought to be submitted to the Court of Final Appeal for decision.

9.  Having regard to this court’s judgment, the applicant’s intended appeal has no merit at all.  No question of great general or public importance has been identified as required by section 22(1)(b) of the HKCFAO.    

10.  Nor do we see any basis for granting leave under the “or otherwise” limb under section 22(1)(b).

11.  By reason of the above, the Notice of Motion filed on 4 July 2022 is dismissed.

 

 

(Maria Yuen)
Justice of Appeal
(Thomas Au)   
Justice of Appeal

The applicant, unrepresented, acting in person

  

[2022] HKCA 265-EN-2022-02-25

NGUYEN VAN TUOI v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMNT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE

HTML content

CACV 52/2021

[2022] HKCA 265

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO 52 OF 2021

(ON APPEAL FROM HCAL NO 466 OF 2019)

________________________

BETWEEN

NGUYEN VAN TUOIApplicant
and
TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD/
NON-REFOULEMNT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
Putative Respondent
and
DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATIONPutative
Interest Party

________________________

Before:  Hon Yuen and Au JJA in Court

Date of Judgment:  25 February 2022

________________________

J U D G M E N T

________________________


Hon Yuen JA (giving the Judgment of the Court):

Introduction

1.  On 28 January 2021, DHCJ C P Pang (“the Judge”)  refused to grant leave to the applicant to apply for judicial review against the decision of the Torture Claims Appeal Board/adjudicator of the Non-refoulement Claims Petition Office (“the Board”)  dated 11 February 2019.  In that decision, the Board upheld the decision of the Director of Immigration (“the Director”)  dated 13 January 2017 rejecting the applicant’s non-refoulement claim on all applicable grounds.

2.  On 8 February 2021, the applicant filed a Notice of Appeal to this Court against the Judge’s decision. On the same day, he lodged a letter with the Court indicating his consent to have this appeal disposed of on paper without an oral hearing. 

3.  Pursuant to the directions of Registrar of Civil Appeals made on 13 April 2021, the applicant should lodge his written submissions on or before 28 April 2021.  He failed to do so.  The Registrar further directed that in the event the applicant failed to lodge his written submissions by the deadline, he will be deemed to have abandoned his right to rely on written submissions. 

4.  As it is appropriate to do so, we proceeded to consider the appeal on paper based on the available documents and materials without an oral hearing.

Background

5.  The Applicant is a national of Vietnam. He entered Hong Kong illegally on 9 June 2015.  He surrendered to the Immigration Department on the following day and on 10 June 2015, he lodged a non-refoulement claim on the basis that if refouled, he would be harmed or even killed by his creditor as he defaulted on his loan.  The factual background of this case was succinctly summarized by the Judge in [3] of the Form CALL-1 ([2021] HKCFI 175).

6.  By a Notice of Decision dated 13 January 2017, the Director assessed the applicant’s claim on all applicable grounds i.e. BOR 2 risk[1], BOR 3 risk[2], torture risk[3] and persecution risk[4], and determined it against him.

7.  The applicant appealed the Director’s decision to the Board.  He attended an oral hearing on 17 December 2018 and by its decision dated 11 February 2019, the Board dismissed the appeal.  For the reasons stated at [49] – [54] of its decision, the Board found that the dispute on loan repayment was private in nature without any state acquiescence or involvement.  It was further found that the applicant had not sustained any serious injury during the 3 incidents of assault and that the creditor had no intention to cause any grievous bodily harm or to kill him. The Board therefore concluded that there is no real risk of harm upon his return to Vietnam.  Further, relevant Country of origin information (“COI”)  suggested that there should be reasonable state protection [55] – [63] and internal relocation is a viable option [65] – [69].  For the aforesaid reasons, the applicant’s non-refoulement claim failed on all applicable grounds.

Decision of the court below

8.  On 19 February 2019, the applicant filed his Form 86 for leave to apply for judicial review of the Board’s decision.  He did not provide any grounds of review in his Form 86 and in his supporting affirmation, he merely said that he had not repaid his debt and his life was insecure.  He requested the court to help him.

9.  The applicant did not request for an oral hearing and the Judge disposed of the application on paper.  By his decision made on 28 January 2021, the Judge refused to grant him leave to apply for judicial review and the reasons for the refusal were set out at [11] – [17] of the Form CALL-1 as follows:

“11. The relevant principles regarding appeals on non-refoulement cases have been set out comprehensively in Nupur Mst v Director of Immigration[2018] HKCA 524 at paragraph 14. In particular, the role of the court in a judicial review is not to provide a further avenue of appeal. The primary decision makers are the Director and the Board. While the court in non-refoulement cases will adopt an enhanced standard in scrutinizing the decision of the Board due to the seriousness of the issue at hand, it should not usurp the role of the Board. Assessment of evidence and COI materials, risk of harm, state protection and viability of internal relocation are primarily within the province of the Board and the Director. The court will not intervene by way of judicial review unless there are errors of law, procedural unfairness or irrationality in the decision of the Board.

12. When the applicant pursued his appeal to the Board, the Director’s decision was superseded by the Board’s decision and is no longer susceptible to judicial review: Re Moshsin Ali[2018] HKCA 549. Therefore, while the court examines the decisions of the Director and the Board, it is unnecessary to delve into the decision of the Director. This Observations for the Applicant will only focus on the latter’s decision.

13. In the present case, the Board did not take issue with the applicant’s claimed primary events. It rejected the applicant’s appeal/ petition based on its assessment of risk he would face, if refouled. Further and in any event, the Board found that state protection would be available to him and internal relocation is a viable and reasonable option for him.

14. As mentioned above assessment of evidence, risk of harm, availability of state protection and internal relocation are primarily within the province of the Board and the Director. This court will not interfere with the decisions unless there is a public law ground for the court to do so.

15. The application form and affirmation of the applicant did not demonstrate any procedural irregularity, unfairness or unreasonableness of the Board. It was only a request for rehearing of the appeal. There is no reasonably arguable basis to challenge the findings of the Board.

16. Even on the applicant’s own account, the past ill treatment was of low intensity. It did not reach the level of severity required to constitute torture or CIDTP. He did not report the incidents of assault and threatening to the local police or authorities. He had lived in a city uneventfully for 2 years before he left Vietnam. There cannot be any substantial grounds for believing that he would be at real risk of any type of proscribed harm, if refouled. The decision of the Board is eminently reasonable.

17.  Having considered the decisions of both the Director and the Board with rigorous examination and anxious scrutiny, I do not find any error of law, irrational findings, or procedural unfairness in either of them.  Nor do I see any failure on their part to apply high standards of fairness.”

Appeal to this Court

10.  On 8 February 2021, the applicant filed his Notice of Appeal against the Judge’s decision on the following grounds:

“the grounds of this appeal are that the gravity of my circumstances have noted been weighed or realized by both Putative Respondents while considering my non-refoulement claim. I should be given an opportunity to plead my case properly.”

Legal principles

11.  In assessing the merits of the appeal, we have considered the legal principles set out by this Court in Nupur Mst v Director of Immigration[2018] HKCA 524 at [14]; Re Md Shohel Sheak[2018] HKCA 714 at [13]; and Re Limbu Birkhaman[2019] HKCA 50 at [11].  For the purposes of this appeal, the salient principles are as follows:

(1)  The role of the Court in a judicial review is not to provide a further avenue of appeal.  The primary decision makers are the Director and on appeal, which operates as a re-hearing, the Board.  Though in non-refoulement cases, the Court will adopt an enhanced standard in scrutinizing the decision of the Board due to the seriousness of issue at hand, the Court should not usurp the role of the Board.  Assessment of evidence and COI materials and risk of harm, state protection and viability of internal relocation are primarily within the province of the Board.  The Court will not intervene by way of judicial review unless there are errors of law or procedural unfairness or irrationality in the decision of the Board.

(2)  An appeal against the refusal of leave by a judge in the Court of First Instance is not the occasion for regurgitating arguments advanced and rejected by the judge, or for running arguments which could and should have been raised but not raised before the judge.  In the determination of an appeal, the Court of Appeal focuses on the decision of the judge and we would only reverse that decision if an appellant can demonstrate that the judge made errors of law, or failed to take account of relevant matters already placed before the court, or was otherwise plainly wrong.

(3)  In an appeal against refusal of leave to apply for judicial review in non-refoulement cases, the Court of Appeal would only examine the decision of the judge in light of the grounds advanced by the applicant.  If no viable ground is put forward to reverse the judge, the appeal should be dismissed.  An appellate court should not examine the decision of the Board afresh as if it were a fresh application for judicial review. 

Discussion

12.  The applicant did not in his Notice of Appeal provide any ground of appeal against the Judge’s decision or identify any specific errors, or any other specific potential grounds for reversing the Judge’s decision.  

13.  The applicant’s complaint that the Director and the Board had not weighed his claim properly was a vague and general accusation without particulars and elaboration and cannot be a valid ground of appeal.  We are satisfied that the Judge was right to find that the Board had properly assessed and considered the applicant’s claim and there were no errors of law or any procedural unfairness or irregularities that would warrant the court’s intervention.

14.  Regarding the applicant’s complaint that he was not provided with an opportunity to plead his case properly, it was baseless and ill-conceived.  The applicant was provided with ample opportunities at the two-tiered screening process before the Director and the Board to provide all the relevant information and supporting evidence for his non-refoulement claim.[5] When he came to the stage of seeking leave to apply for judicial review, he had every opportunity to advance grounds of review in his Form 86 but he failed to do so.  In this appeal, he was directed to lodge his written submissions in support of his appeal but he abandoned his right to do so.  In the circumstances, the applicant’s complaint simply cannot stand.

15.  Having considered the materials before us, we are of the view that the Judge’s observations are fully justified.  We are satisfied that the Judge had reviewed the Board’s decision with vigorous examination and anxious scrutiny, and the Judge was plainly right to refuse leave to apply for judicial review.

Order

16.  For the above reasons, this appeal is dismissed.

(Maria Yuen)(Thomas Au)
Justice of AppealJustice of Appeal

The applicant, unrepresented, acting in person



[1]    This refers to the risk of violation of the right of life under Article 2 of section 8 of the Hong Kong Bill of Rights Ordinance (Cap 383).

[2]    This refers to the risk of torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment under Article 3 of section 8 of the Hong Kong Bill of Rights Ordinance (Cap 383).

[3] This refers to risk of torture as defined in Part VIIC of the Immigration Ordinance (Cap.115); the definition being the same as that found in Article 1 of the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment.

[4]    This refers to the risk of persecution with reference to the non-refoulement principle under Article 33 of the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees and its 1967 Protocol.

[5]    [3] – [4] of the Director’s decision; [26] – [30] of the Board’s decision.