HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Civil Action2005

HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD v. TELEVISION BROADCASTS LTD AND ANOTHER

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV113/2007SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD
  • CACV130/2015SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD
  • DCPI1648/2007LAI MEI LING v. HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD
  • FAMV44/2016HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD v. SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE
  • HCA1256/2005HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD v. TELEVISION BROADCASTS LTD AND ANOTHER
  • HCA1398/2005SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD
  • HCA2055/2004TELEVISION BROADCASTS LTD v. HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD
  • HCA2561/2009SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE v. HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD
  • HCA3965/1986CBS/SONY HONG KONG LTD AND OTHERS v. TELEVISION BROADCASTS LTD AND ANOTHER
  • HCA9172/2000HONG KONG BROADBAND NETWORK LTD v. HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD
  • HCAL62/2003HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD v. THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS AUTHORITY
  • HCSA24/2009HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD 訴 鍾俊輝

Files (3)

51674-EN-2006-02-13

HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD v. TELEVISION BROADCASTS LTD AND ANOTHER

HTML content

HCA1171/2005

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO.1171 OF 2005

------------------------------

BETWEEN

 HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LIMITEDPlaintiff
 and 
 TELEVISION BROADCASTS LIMITED1st Defendant
  GALAXY SATELLITE
BROADCASTING LIMITED
2nd Defendant

------------------------------

AND

HCA1256/2005

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO.1256 OF 2005

------------------------------

BETWEEN

 HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LIMITEDPlaintiff
 and 
 TELEVISION BROADCASTS LIMITED1st Defendant
  GALAXY SATELLITE
BROADCASTING LIMITED
2nd Defendant

------------------------------

(HEARD TOGETHER)

Before : Deputy High Court Judge Poon in Chambers

Date of Hearing : 13 February 2006

Date of Decision : 13 February 2006

----------------------

D E C I S I O N

----------------------

1. This is an application by the defendants to amend their defence.  The parts which are being objected to fall into two categories : (1) those dealing with the effect of the BA ruling; (2) those dealing with the right to bring an action under section 15(2) of the Broadcasting Ordinance.

2. It is opposed on the primary ground that my rulings in the July Decision and the December Decision constitute an issue estoppel preventing the defendants from raising them again in their defence for the purpose of the trial.  It is also opposed on the grounds that prejudice will be caused to the plaintiff which cannot be properly compensated by costs. 

3. I first look at the first set of proposed amendments.  They can be found in paragraph 6(3)(a) to (c) of the proposed amended defence in the first action, and paragraphs 6(3), 7(3) and 16(4) of the proposed amended defence in the second action.  In brief, the defendants try to raise a plea of res judicata and/or an abuse of process on the part of the plaintiff to run a case contrary to the findings made by the Broadcasting Authority in the BA ruling.

4. In the July Decision I dealt with the court’s jurisdiction to hear and determine a claim for breach of the firewall provisions under section 15 of the Broadcasting Ordinance.  It was a ruling on the court’s jurisdiction and did not touch upon the effect of a ruling by the Authority on the question of breach of those provisions.  It therefore follows that the plaintiff cannot rely on the July Decision to oppose this set of proposed amendments. 

5. In the December hearing, the defendants sought to adduce as evidence the BA ruling to prove that there was no breach of the relevant licensing condition on the part of TVB.  They argued that it constituted a material change of circumstances that would justify the discharge of the interim injunction.  And my ruling is that the BA ruling, being no more than opinion evidence, is not admissible to prove that there was no breach, but it was admissible to prove that the Authority did make such a ruling.

6. I made no ruling whatsoever whether or not the BA ruling, if admitted, would constitute any issue estoppelor res judicata for the simple reason that no argument had been advanced by the defendants to support such a proposition. 

7. Res judicata in the wider sense means that the court requires the parties to the litigation to bring forward the whole case and will not, except under special circumstances, permit the same parties to open the same subject matter of litigation in respect of matters which might have been brought forward as part of the subject in context, but which was not brought forward only because they have from negligence, inadvertence or even accident omitted as part of their case : See Ray Chen v. Anita Wan Ching Lam & Johnson, Stokes & Master, HCA4582/2001, 9 May 2002.

8. I accept the submission that the contention that BA ruling would constitute an issue estoppel or res judicata ought to have been raised in the December hearing.  Prima facie, the res judicata principle in the wider sense applies.  But that principle is always subject to special circumstances.  As I have demonstrated in the July Decision, under the Broadcasting Ordinance, there may be an overlap of the Authority exercising its statutory duties in monitoring the performance of the licence by the licensee on the one hand, and the court exercising its judicial function in hearing and determining whether or not a licensee has acted in breach of its licence on the other.

9. It is reasonably foreseeable, as in the present case, that the Authority and the court may have to deal with the same parties in connection with the same subject matter at the same time.  How a ruling by the Authority would impact the pending proceedings where the court is asked to determine the same subject matter is no doubt an important question.  It is important to the parties then appearing before the court.  I would also venture to suggest that it is important to the general public in that how the Ordinance is to operate in this particular area, where both the Authority and the court have a role to play, should be clarified.

10. My ruling in the December Decision only dealt with one aspect of the legal effect of the BA ruling in the pending court proceedings.  I ruled that it is inadmissible to prove that there was no breach but admissible only to prove that the Authority had come to that conclusion.  I did not go on to deal with the question of issue estoppel or res judicata.  For my part, I think a determination by the court on that question made after fuller submissions and mature consideration is plainly desirable.  So I will rule that there are special circumstances that would justify a departure of the strict application of the res judicata principle in the wider sense. 

11. Further, I do not think the plaintiff will suffer any prejudice as alleged.  In the absence of any ruling by me on the question that the BA ruling will constitute an estoppel or res judicata, no inconsistent ruling will arise at trial.  I will therefore allow the first set of proposed amendments.

12. I then turn to the second set of the proposed amendments.  They can be found in paragraph 13(5)(b) of the proposed amended defence in the first action, and paragraph 18(3)(b) of the proposed defence in the second action. 

13. The proposed plea is to raise an allegation that no cause of action would accrue under section 15(2) of the Broadcasting Ordinance in the absence of the determination by the Authority on section 13(1) and section 14(1).  The plea does not deal with jurisdiction of the court in hearing and determining a claim brought under section 15(2).  It deals with the question whether a cause of action is established in the absence of such a finding by the Authority.  In other words, my ruling on the court’s jurisdiction in the July Decision is not relevant.  I can see no prejudice that the plaintiff may suffer if the amendment is allowed.

14. I therefore come to the conclusion that without prejudice to the interim injunction that I have granted, both sets of the proposed amendments ought to be allowed.  Unless the parties would have anything to say on the terms of the orders to be made, I would make an order in terms of the two summonses.

(Submission on costs and terms of order)

15. Today’s hearing is necessitated by the plaintiff’s opposition of the proposed amendments.  Since the plaintiff has lost they should bear the costs in any event.  As to the general costs of the proposed amendments the normal rule would apply.  So the costs order that I propose to make is that costs of the application, including the costs of an occasion by the proposed amendment will be to the plaintiff in any event, save and except the costs of the hearing today will be to the defendants in any event.  That will apply to both summonses.  There will be an order in terms of the summonses as amended.

 

 (J. Poon)
Deputy High Court Judge

 

Mr Lewis Ho of Messrs Lovells, for the Plaintiff

Mr Kevin Yam of Messrs Herbert Smith, for the 1st and 2nd Defendants

51009-EN-2005-12-19

HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD v. TELEVISION BROADCASTS LTD AND ANOTHER

HTML content

HCA1171/2005
HCA1256/2005

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NOS.1171 AND 1256 OF 2005

----------------------------------

BETWEEN

HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LIMITEDPlaintiff
and
 TELEVISION BROADCASTS LIMITED1st Defendant
 GALAXY SATELLITE BROADCASTING LIMITED2nd Defendant

--------------------------

(HEARD TOGETHER)

Before : Deputy High Court Judge Poon in Chambers

Dates of Hearing :12 and 13 December 2005

Date of Decision : 19 December 2005

----------------------

D E C I S I O N

----------------------

 

The Injunction

1. This Decision should be read together with the Decision that I delivered on 9 July 2005 (“the July Decision”).  For present purposes, I will adopt the abbreviations used in the July Decision.

2. In the July Decision, I allowed the Program Application taken out by Hong Kong Cable in the 1st Action and granted an interim injunction (“the Injunction”) restraining Galaxy, until trial or further order, from including the Program as part of the Service as defined in the Galaxy Licence within 12 months of the last date on which TVB included the Program as part of its domestic free television programme service, unless otherwise approved by the Broadcasting Authority pursuant to Condition 36.5 of the Galaxy Licence (“Condition 36.5”).  And I refused the Channels Application.

Development since the grant of the Injunction

3. At the time when I heard the Applications, the Broadcasting Authority was considering the various complaints lodged by Hong Kong Cable relating to the Program and the 4 TV Channels.  It had not come to a determination yet.

4. Eventually on 20 August 2005, the Broadcasting Authority made a ruling on the complaints (“the BA’s Ruling”), which was published in a press release.  The parties were formally notified of the BA’s Ruling by letter dated 22 August 2005.

5. On the Program, the Broadcasting Authority ruled that TVB and Galaxy had not breached the relevant firewall provisions in that it was not substantially produced by TVB.  On TVB’s exclusive supply of the 4 TV Channels to Galaxy without going through an open bidding process, the Broadcasting Authority ruled that it constituted a breach of the relevant firewall provisions.  On TVB’s non-exclusive supply of the 4 TV Channels to Galaxy, the Broadcasting Authority ruled that it was in breach of the firewall provisions which required TVB to make available the Channels to other licensees on no less than favourable terms than Galaxy’s in that it had given Galaxy an unfair head start over other licensees.  The Broadcasting Authority further ruled that no case had been made out that there was undue preference between TVB and Galaxy with respect to licence fee payable as the same fee structure was offered to all licensees.

6. On 20 August 2005, TVB responded to the BA’s Ruling by issuing a press release (“the Press Release”) in these terms :

“[TVB] accepts the ruling of the Broadcasting Authority (BA) on the supply of six channels by TVB to [Galaxy].

TVB has acted in good faith with the interest of the public in mind and the belief that its acts, which are the subject of the present complaints, were in compliance with its licence conditions.  The findings of the BA in these cases have provided guidance to TVB on how it should handle future transactions between TVB and Galaxy groups.  With the BA findings, we now have a clearer directive on how to ensure compliance with the firewall provisions.

Regarding [the Program], we are glad to know that BA finds the complaint not substantiated.  We shall provide a copy of the BA findings to the court for the judge’s consideration on whether [the Injunction] should be lifted.  Once [the Injunction] is lifted, we shall arrange [the Program] exhibited on our channel as soon as possible.”

7. Dissatisfied with the BA’s Ruling relating to the Program, Hong Kong Cable has since lodged an appeal to the Chief Executive in Council pursuant to section 34 of the Ordinance, which is still pending.

Applications

8. The above development prompted the parties to make the following applications :

(1) An application by TVB and Galaxy by summons dated 24 August 2005 to discharge the Injunction (“the Discharge Application”).

(2) Applications by Hong Kong Cable by two summonses, one for each of the 1st and 2nd action, dated 29 August 2005 seeking partial interlocutory judgment in each action against TVB pursuant to Order 27, rule 3, Rules of the High Court (“the O27 Applications”).

(3) Two summonses, one for each of the 1st and 2nd action, dated 13 September 2005, seeking partial interlocutory judgment in each action against TVB pursuant to Order 14, rule 1, Rules of the High Court (“the O14 Applications”).

I will first look at the Discharge Application.

The Discharge Application

(1)     Basis upon which the Injunction was granted

9. It is, I believe, convenient to reiterate briefly the reasons why I granted the Injunction.

10. In the July Decision, I first dealt with the statutory regime under the Ordinance and noted that one of the primary aims of the Ordinance which is pertinent to these actions is to ensure a fair competition and a level playing field in the television programme service market : sections 13, 14 and 15 of the Ordinance.  Section 15(2), in particular, confers a statutory cause of action upon persons who claim to have suffered loss and damage as a result of a licensee’s breach of section 13(1) or 14(1) or a licence condition relating to that section.  I then summarized the effect of the relevant firewall provisions in the TVB Licence and the Galaxy Licence.  On the Program Application, I was satisfied that there was a serious question to be tried as to whether the Program was substantially produced by TVB within the meaning of Condition 36.5.  I was further satisfied that on a balance of convenience it was just to grant the Injunction.

11. One of the factors that I took into account when considering balance of convenience is the mischief that Condition 36.5 seeks to address.  In paragraph 40 of the July Decision, I said this :

“…If an injunction is not granted, Galaxy will have a head start over other competitors, including Hong Kong Cable.  Such an unfair head start, I believe, is the mischief that Condition 36.5 aims to tackle.”

12. On reflection, I do not think what I have said about the mischief is entirely correct, although it does not affect my conclusion that the Injunction should be granted.  I was then influenced by senior counsel’s submissions on the effect of the firewall provisions pertaining to the Channels Application.  Those provisions plainly seek to tackle unfair head start by Galaxy.   Condition 36.5 seeks to deal with another form of mischief, namely unfair competition and possible abuse of dominant market position.  It is thus related to sections 13(1) and 14(1) of the Ordinance.  To tackle the mischief, Condition 36.5 imposes a 12 months’ window period within which Galaxy may not include as part of its service any television programme wholly or substantially produced by the TVB group, unless otherwise approved by the Broadcasting Authority in the public interest.  The 12 months’ window period starts from the last date on which TVB included such television programme as part of its domestic free television programme service.

(2)     The court’s jurisdiction

13. I next look at the court’s jurisdiction to discharge the Injunction.

14. In principle, the court has jurisdiction to entertain and, if satisfied, to allow an application to discharge an injunction even following upon a full inter partes hearing.  The court will exercise this jurisdiction :

(1) when the sole, or at least the main, basis for seeking the discharge is that there has been a material change of circumstance since the injunction was first granted, i.e. a crucial new factual development; or

(2) when after the injunction is granted it become apparent that it was founded on an erroneous view of the law.

See London Underground Ltd v. National Union of Railwaymen (No.2) [1989] IRLR 343 at p.344.

(3)     Admissibility of the BA’s Ruling

15. Here, TVB and Galaxy invoke the court’s jurisdiction by asserting that the BA’s Ruling, which confirmed that there was no breach of Condition 36.5 pertaining to the Program, constitutes a material change of circumstance that justifies the discharge of the Injunction.  Mr Smith, SC, appearing for TVB and Galaxy, contends that the BA’s Ruling is admissible in these proceedings to prove that there was no breach of Condition 36.5.  The BA’s Ruling is indeed binding on the parties in this regard.

16. Mr Yuen, SC, appearing for Hong Kong Cable, argues that the BA’s Ruling is inadmissible to show that there was no breach of Condition 36.5.  He relies on the well-established principle that the judgment, verdict or award of another tribunal is not admissible evidence to prove a fact in issue or a fact relevant to the issue in other proceedings between different parties : Hollington v. Hewthorn & Co. Ltd [1943] 2 All ER 35.  For a chronological survey of the cases that applies Hollington, see Secretary of State for Trade and Industry v. Bairstow [2004] Ch. 1, see paras.15–27 at pp.7–11.

17. Mr Smith submits that the above principle does not apply because the parties here were the same parties involved in the BA’s Ruling.  Alternatively, he relies on the exception to the Hollington principle as propounded in Symphony Group plc v. Hodgson [1993] 4 All ER 143.  There, Balcombe LJ held that in the summary procedure for the determination of the liability of a non-party to the proceedings to pay costs, the judge’s findings of fact in the proceedings are admissible.  This departure was justified on the basis that the non-party with the original proceedings was so close that he would not suffer any injustice by allowing this exception to the general rule : at p.153f–g.

18. For my part, I will first look at the nature of the BA’s Ruling and then consider the extent of its admissibility, if at all, by reference to the Ordinance and the general principles relating to admissibility of evidence.

19. In the BA’s Ruling, the Broadcasting Authority first referred to the submissions and representations made by the parties on each of the complaints, then set out its reasoning and finally came to its decisions.  And it is the Broadcasting Authority’s decision that there was no breach of Condition 36.5 that is chiefly relied on by TVB and Galaxy for present purposes.  In my view, the Broadcasting Authority’s said decision on Condition 36.5 is an opinion that it arrived at after considering the parties’ submissions and representations.

20. The general principle is that opinion is inadmissible in proof of facts.  Thus in principle, the BA’s Ruling, as no more than the Broadcasting Authority’s opinion, will not be admissible in these proceedings to prove that there was in fact no breach of Condition 36.5.  This objection to admissibility on principle, in my view, can be overcome only if the BA’s Ruing is admissible for such purpose by (a) the operation of the Ordinance; or (b) the doctrine of issue estoppel. 

21. I first look at the Ordinance.  Under section 15(2) of the Ordinance, a person sustaining loss or damage from :

(1) a breach of section 13(1); or

(2) a breach of section 14(1); or

(3) a breach of a licence condition, determination or direction relating to that section,

may bring an action against the licensee who is in breach.

22. The first two scenarios concern a breach of the relevant statutory provisions.  The 3rd concerns not a breach of the statutory provisions but a breach of, among other things, a licence condition relating to those provisions.

23. Where the case concerns a breach of section 13(1) or 14(1), section 15(4) of the Ordinance provides :

“(4)     For the avoidance of doubt, it is hereby declared that a breach of section 13(1) or 14(1) occurs when the Broadcasting Authority forms the opinion referred to in section 13(1) or 14(4) respectively.”

The Broadcasting’s opinion is plainly admissible to prove that not only did it form such opinion but also that in fact there is a breach of the relevant statutory provision.

24. Where, however, the case concerns a breach of the relevant licence condition, as is the present case, nothing in section 15 or indeed in the Ordinance provides for the admission of the Broadcasting Authority’s opinion (if there is one) as evidence in the court proceedings to show that there is in fact a breach of the licence condition or not.  Absent such specific provision, the Broadcasting Authority’s opinion will not, by operation of the Ordinance, be rendered admissible in the court proceedings for such purpose.  It follows that the BA’s Ruling will not be admissible by virtue of the Ordinance in these proceedings to prove that there was no breach of Condition 36.5.

25. As to issue estoppel, Mr Smith has advanced no argument that the BA’s Ruling constituted an issue estoppel and has thus become admissible and binding on the parties in these proceedings.

26. In my view, the BA’s Ruling is inadmissible for present purposes to prove that there was no breach of Condition 36.5.  It is only admissible to prove that the Broadcasting Authority ruled that there was no breach of Condition 36.5.  Whether in these proceedings there was a breach of Condition 36.5 is a matter for the court to decide after considering all the relevant evidence and submissions.

27. For completeness, I wish to briefly deal with the cases relied on by counsel.  The Hollington line of cases cited by Mr Yuen is arguably not applicable because the parties involved in the present proceedings are the same as those in the complaint procedure before the Broadcasting Authority.  Mr Smith’s submissions and his reliance on the Symphony Group case do not alter the fact that the BA’s Ruling remains merely an opinion of the Broadcasting Authority which, as I have ruled, is inadmissible for the purpose that he contends for.

(4)     Any material change of circumstances

28. I now turn to consider if the BA’s Ruling constitutes a material change of circumstances.

29. Mr Smith argues that it does by taking four points.  He first submits that in light of the BA’s Ruling, there is no serious question to be tried on the breach of Condition 36.5.  I have already ruled that the BA’s Ruling is inadmissible to prove that there was no breach of Condition 36.5.  This argument is plainly untenable.  On the materials before me, the evidence on the question of breach of Condition 36.5 remains very much the same as at the time when I granted the Injunction.  This has not been changed by the BA’s Ruling.

30. Mr Smith next argues that the 12 months’ window period imposed by Condition 36.5 will soon expire in a few months time.  If the Injunction is not lifted, Hong Kong Cable will effectively get what it wants and it will be meaningless for TVB and Galaxy to bring the matter to trial.  He thus asks me to consider Hong Kong Cable’s likelihood of success, bearing in mind the fact that the Broadcasting Authority has ruled that there was no breach of Condition 36.5.  This argument is plainly based on the admissibility of the BA’s Ruling to prove that there was no breach of Condition 36.5.  (The mere fact that the 12 months’ window period will soon expire is not sufficient.)  The basis is now gone.  This contention must fail.

31. Mr Smith then submits that the BA’s Ruling tilts the balance of convenience in favour of not continuing the Injunction.  The wording of the Injunction specifically provides that Galaxy may, with the Broadcasting Authority’s approval, broadcast the Program within the 12 months’ window period.  The BA’s Ruling constitutes de facto approval by the Broadcasting Authority to broadcast the Program.  For having ruled that there was no breach of Condition 36.5, the Broadcasting Authority would most likely give such approval had an application been made on the assumption that there was a breach of Condition 36.5.  I am unable to accept this submission.  Under Condition 36.5, the Broadcasting Authority may give approval in the public interest.  On the evidence before me, it does not follow from its ruling that there was no breach of Condition 36.5 that the Broadcasting Authority will most likely give approval in the public interest.  Making the ruling and giving approval in the public interest are simply two different matters.  The BA’s Ruling in no way constitutes any de facto approval.

32. Mr Smith then advances an alternative argument.  If the Injunction is maintained, then Galaxy would be prevented from broadcasting the Program because it could not obtain approval from the Broadcasting Authority where, from its perspective, no issue of approval even arises.  This would effectively put Galaxy in an even worse position than if the Broadcasting Authority found that the Progamme was substantially produced by TVB, where Galaxy could at least the apply for approval to broadcast the Program and would most likely get it.  In my view, this argument does not take the matter any further for the simple reason that it is purely speculative to suggest that the Broadcasting Authority would give the approval in the public interest even if an application were made on the assumption that the Program was substantially produced by TVB within the meaning of Condition 36.5.

33. For the above reasons, I do not find that the BA’s Ruling constitutes a material change of circumstances that would justify the discharge of the Injunction.  The Discharge Application is dismissed accordingly.

O27 Applications and O14 Applications

34. I now turn to the O27 and O14 Applications, which can be conveniently dealt with together.  For it is Mr Yuen’s submission that they stand or fall together.

35. Mr Yuen submits that the TVB Press Release constitutes a clear and unambiguous admission on the part of TVB that it had breached the firewall provisions pertaining to the 4 TV Channels.  Partial judgment by such admission under Order 27 should be entered : Chung Wong Kit (a bankrupt) [1999] 1 HKC 684, at pp.686E–687A.  Alternatively, by making the admission, TVB can no longer maintain any meaningful defence contrary to it.  Summary judgment under Order 14 should be entered.

36. The Press Release must be understood in its context.  It was couched in careful terms.  TVB did not admit that it had breached the relevant licence conditions.  It reiterated that it had acted in good faith and with the belief that the acts complained of were in compliance with its licence conditions.  It then went on to state that the BA’s Ruling provided guidance on how it should handle future transactions with Galaxy.  Accepting the BA’s Ruling without appealing in the circumstances does not amount to any clear and unambiguous admission as contended by counsel.  I will therefore dismiss the O27 and O14 Applications.

Costs

37. Costs should follow the events.  I will therefore make an order nisi that Hong Kong Cable shall have the costs of the Discharge Application in any event, to be taxed if not agreed; and that TVB shall have the costs of the O27 and O14 Applications in any event, to be taxed if not agreed.

 (J. Poon)
Deputy High Court Judge

Mr Rimsky Yuen, SC, instructed by  Messrs Lovells, for the Plaintiff

Mr Clifford Smith, SC, instructed by Messrs Herbert Smith, for the 1st and 2nd Defendants

45928-EN-2005-07-09

HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LTD v. TELEVISION BROADCASTS LTD AND ANOTHER

HTML content

HCA1171/2005

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO. 1171 OF 2005

---------------------

BETWEEN

 HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LIMITEDPlaintiff
 and 
 TELEVISION BROADCASTS LIMITED1st Defendant
 GALAXY SATELLITE BROADCASTING LIMITED2nd Defendant

 

AND

HCA1256/2005

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO. 1256 OF 2005

---------------------

BETWEEN

 HONG KONG CABLE TELEVISION LIMITEDPlaintiff
 and 
 TELEVISION BROADCASTS LIMITED1st Defendant
 GALAXY SATELLITE BROADCASTING LIMITED2nd Defendant

(Heard-together)

 

Before : Deputy High Court Judge Poon in Chambers

Dates of Hearing : 30 June and 9 July 2005

Date of Decision : 9 July 2005

 

---------------------------------------------

DECISION

---------------------------------------------

 

Introduction

1. There are two actions before me between Hong Kong Cable Television Limited (“Hong Kong Cable”) as plaintiff on the one hand, and Television Broadcasts Limited (“TVB”) and Galaxy Satellite Broadcasting Limited (“Galaxy”) as the defendants on the other hand.  The first action is HCA1171/2005, begun on 21 June 2005 (“the 1st action”).  The second action, commenced on 30 June 2005, is HCA 1256/2005 (“the 2nd action”). 

2.  What calls for my determination today is the applications by Hong Kong Cable for an interim injunction against TVB and Galaxy by way of two summonses respectively taken out in the 1st action on 21 June 2005 (“the 1st summons”) and in the 2nd action on 30 June 2005 (“the 2nd summons”).  In the 1st summons, Hong Kong Cable seeks an interim injunction in respect of the broadcasting of :

(1)the Korean television series known as “The Jewel in the Palace” with Cantonese dubbing and Cantonese subtitles produced by TVB (“the Program”); and
  
(2)the four television channels known as TVB Health Channel, TVB Theatre Channel, TVB Music Channel and Premiere TV Series Channel (“collectively the 4 TV Channels”) in Galaxy’s paid TV platform marketed under the brand name “SuperSUN”.

3. The 1st summons first came before me on 24 June 2005, when I adjourned the matter to 30 June 2005.  On 29 June 2005, TVB and Galaxy signed an amended channel supply agreement whereby the 4 TV Channels are to be supplied on a non-exclusive basis.  This removal of exclusivity naturally impacts on the 1st summons.

4. At the adjourned hearing on 30 June 2005, TVB offered an undertaking in lieu of injunction not to supply to Galaxy the 4 TV Channels or any part thereof on an exclusive basis.  Galaxy offered a corresponding undertaking in lieu of injunction not to acquire or obtain from TVB on an exclusive basis the 4 TV Channels or any part thereof.  I will call them “the Undertakings”.

5. Having heard leading counsel appearing for the parties, I took the view that the Undertakings are sufficient, having regard to Hong Kong Cable’s complaints in the 1st action.  I therefore accepted them and granted leave to withdraw those parts of the 1st summons that related to the 4 TV Channels.  I then adjourned the balance of the 1st summons, which relates solely to the Program, to today for argument.  I will call this application “the Program Application”.

6. The 2nd summons, and indeed the 2nd action, is, in a way, necessitated by the Undertakings.  For Hong Kong Cable complains that supplying and obtaining the 4 TV Channels on a non-exclusive basis still constitutes a breach of TVB’s and Galaxy’s respective licences issued by the Broadcasting Authority (“the TVB Licence” and “the Galaxy Licence” respectively).

7. In the 2nd summons as amended, Hong Kong Cable seeks an interim injunction restraining TVB from supplying to Galaxy the Program and the 4 TV Channels and Galaxy from broadcasting the Program and the 4 TV Channels unless TVB offers or makes available the Program and the 4 TV Channels to all pay TV licensees, including Hong Kong Cable, at the same time an offer to supply the Program and the 4 TV Channels is made by TVB to Galaxy on no less favourable terms than those offered to Galaxy pursuant to and in compliance of the relevant conditions of their respective licences.  I will call this the “Channels Application”. 

The parties

8. The parties are all well-known players in the local television market.  Hong Kong Cable has been a paid television series provider since 1993.  It is one of the top five media companies in Hong Kong.  It is its case that, throughout the years, it has successfully established a leading position in news, movies and sports television programming.  It is, at the moment, particularly engaged in the development of entertainment television programming. 

9. TVB is a wireless commercial television station.  It operates under a domestic free television programme service licence in Hong Kong first granted in the mid-1960s.  It engaged in television broadcasting, programme production and other broadcasting-related activities.  It has been enjoying a dominant position in the free television service market all along.

10. Galaxy is a wholly-owned subsidiary of TVB.  TVB has contracted to sell 51% of its shareholding to a third party on 21 April 2005.  Completion is due to take place on 5 August 2005.  Galaxy is a provider of pay television service and hence a direct competitor of Hong Kong Cable.  It obtained a domestic pay-television programme service licence in 2000.  It commenced its pay TV service in Hong Kong under the name of “ex-TV” in December 2003.  The name has been changed to SuperSUN since May 2005.

The Broadcasting Ordinance

11. In 2000, a new Broadcasting Ordinance, Cap. 562 (“the Ordinance”), was enacted.  The Ordinance, other than sections 13, 14, 16 and 17, came into force on 7 July 2000.  Those provisions came into force later, on 16 February 2001.

12. One of the prime aims of the Ordinance is to ensure a fair competition and a level playing field in the television programme service market.  In this connection, the Ordinance stipulates that : 

(a)A licensee shall not engage in conduct which, in the opinion of the Broadcasting Authority, has the purpose or effect of preventing, distorting or substantially restricting competition in the television programme service market (section 13(1)).
  
(b)A licensee in a dominant position in the television programme service market shall not abuse its position (section 14(1)).
  
(c)A licensee who is in a dominant position is deemed to have abused its position if, in the opinion of the Broadcasting Authority, the licensee has engaged in conduct which has the purpose or effect of preventing, distorting or substantially restricting competition in the television programme service market (section 14(4)).

13. Under section 15(2) of the Ordinance, a person sustaining loss or damage from breach of the above provisions for a breach of licence conditions, may bring an action for damages, an injunction, or other appropriate remedy, order or relief against the licensee who is in breach.

14. Section 15(4) further provides that a breach of section 13(1) or section 14(1) occurs when the Broadcasting Authority so determines.  Absent any such determination, as is the case here, the aggrieved party cannot invoke section 13(1) or section 14(1), even if it has already lodged a complaint to the Broadcasting Authority.

15. Hong Kong Cable’s complaints are therefore not based on any breach of the Ordinance.  It seeks to rely on the so-called “firewall provisions”.

The firewall provisions

16. When the Government gave approval in principle to Galaxy’s application for a television broadcasting licence in July 2000, it was fully aware of the concern about possible unfair competition and market dominance by the TVB group.  To address such concern, the Government considered that Galaxy’s application should only be approved if additional and effective safeguards were put in place to prevent anti-competitive practices between TVB and Galaxy.  The safeguards, commonly known as the “firewall provisions”, were to ensure that there would be no cross-subsidiary or preferential treatment between them and to ensure a level playing field for the television market.

17. They were subsequently incorporated into the TVB Licence (the 3rd Schedule) and the Galaxy Licence (conditions 34 to 38).  For present purposes, these conditions are pertinent.

18. The first category of conditions deals with the exclusive supply of television programmes and television programme services by TVB to Galaxy.  They are condition 3.3(b) in the 3rd Schedule of the TVB Licence, and condition 36.3(b) of the Galaxy Licence.  In short, TVB may not supply exclusively to Galaxy without conducting an open bidding as approved by the Broadcasting Authority.

19. The second category of conditions deals with non-exclusive supply.  They are condition 3.2(b) of the 3rd schedule of the TVB Licence and condition 36.2(b) of the Galaxy Licence.  In short, TVB may supply to Galaxy and Galaxy may obtain from TVB a television programme or television programme service on a non-exclusive basis, only if such programme or service is offered or made available to all other licensees on no less favourable terms.

20. Condition 36.5 of the Galaxy Licence provides that :

“...unless the Broadcasting Authority otherwise approves in the public interest, the licensee shall not, within 12 months of the relevant date, include as part of the service any television programme wholly or substantially produced by the TVB group and which has been included as part of the domestic free television programme service of TVB.  For the purpose of this condition, ‘relevant date’ means the last date on which TVB included such television programme as part of the domestic pre-paid television programme service of TVB.”

21. In other words, absent any approval by the Broadcasting Authority, Galaxy may not broadcast any television programme wholly or substantially produced by TVB within 12 months of its last broadcast by TVB.

Hong Kong Cable’s complaints

22. Hong Kong Cable initially complained about the exclusive supply of the 4 TV Channels by TVB to Galaxy before an open bidding, which contravenes the relevant conditions in their respective licences.  This exclusive supply of the 4 TV Channels by TVB to Galaxy forms the subject matter of the application for an interim injunction relating to these channels in the 1st summons.  But as noted above, for present purposes, this has been disposed of by the Undertakings and does not concern the court any more.

23. Hong Kong Cable now complains that the non-exclusive supply of the 4 TV Channels and the Program by TVB to Galaxy is a breach of condition 3.2(b) of the 3rd Schedule of the TVB Licence and condition 36.2(b) of the Galaxy Licence in that TVB, before supplying the 4 TV channels and the Program to Galaxy, has not offered or made the same available to all other pay TV licensees.  They were offered only on 4 July 2005 as a package of 6 TV channels after the commencement of these proceedings.

24. Hong Kong Cable takes the view that undue preference has been given to Galaxy and therefore finds the offer unacceptable.  The offer will lapse on 1 August 2005.  This forms the subject matter of the Channels Application.

25. In the course of submissions, Mr Yuen, SC, appearing for Hong Kong Cable, prepares to accept an injunction to the effect of restraining the broadcasting of the 4 TV Channels until 1 August 2005.  I will return to this in a moment.

26. The Program, on its own, forms the subject matter of the Program Application.  The plaintiff’s complaint is this.  The Program was broadcast by TVB between 24 January and 1 May 2005.  It was a phenomenal success and enjoyed huge popularity.  The final episode which attracted 3 million viewers turned the Program into the most popular programme in Hong Kong’s television history.

27. On or about 17 May 2005, Galaxy announced that it would broadcast the Program from late June 2005.  Hong Kong Cable complains that no open bidding process for the supply of the Program has been conducted and TVB and Galaxy are therefore in breach of condition 3.3(b) of the 3rd Schedule and condition 36.3(a) of their respective licence.  (This complaint does not concern the court anymore in light of the Undertakings.)  Hong Kong Cable further complains that Galaxy is in breach of condition 36.5 of its own licence in that it included the Program as a part of its service within 12 months, of the last day on which TVB included the Program as its free TV service.

Preliminary points

28. Before proceeding any further, I will deal with three preliminary points raised by counsel in the course of their submissions.

29. The first point is raised by Mr Smith, SC, counsel appearing for TVB and Galaxy, which relates to the court’s jurisdiction.  He submits that Hong Kong Cable’s present complaints are in fact complaints against anti-competition behaviour and abuse of dominant position.  They fall exclusively within the province of the Broadcasting Authority.

30. I am unable to accept this submission.  Under the Ordinance, the Broadcasting Authority no doubt plays a very significant part in combating anti-competition conduct.  It may, as is in the present case, impose necessary licence conditions.  It may, upon complaint, make a determination under section 15(4) on any anti-competition behaviour or abuse of dominant position.                     But if, as is in the present case, the anti-competition measures are incorporated as part of the licence conditions and an aggrieved party complains that there is a breach of those conditions, the court can certainly intervene under section 15(2).

31. The second point raised by Mr Smith is that the injunctions prayed for are mandatory injunctions.  I do not agree.  A mandatory injunction requires a defendant to act in accordance with the injunction.  The Program Application does not require Galaxy to act.  It seeks to prohibit Galaxy from broadcasting a programme within the enjoined period.  The Channels Application, similarly, does not require TVB or Galaxy to act.  With the latest development as noted above, it will, if allowed, restrain the broadcasting of the 4 TV Channels until 1 August 2005.

32. The third preliminary point is raised by Mr Yuen.  He relies on two authorities, the Allman case and the Diomedous case and submits that the breach of the licence conditions on the part of TVB and Galaxy is so clear that the injunctions should be granted without considering the balance of convenience.

33. For my part, I do not think it is appropriate at this interlocutory stage to make a definite and final determination on the interpretation of the relevant licence conditions or on the alleged breaches.  I prefer to go along the conventional approach as propounded in the American Cyanamid case.  That approach has been usefully summarised in Hong Kong Civil Procedure, 2004 Edition, Vol. 1, at paragraph 21/1/11, at pages 498 to 499.  I do not propose to repeat the principles here.

The Program Application

34. I will first consider the Program Application.  I will see if there is a serious question to be tried.  TVB and Galaxy raised in their evidence the point that the Program to be broadcast by Galaxy is the full version of the television series as opposed to the edited version played previously by TVB.  They seem to have suggested that the Program is therefore not a programme which TVB had included as a part of its domestic free-pay television service.

35. Mr Smith, in his oral submissions, does not take this point any further.  I think the short answer is that when the evidence is looked in the round, arguably, the difference in versions does not take the Program outside condition 36.5 of the Galaxy Licence.

36. The next and real objection raised by TVB and Galaxy is that the Program is not a programme substantially produced by TVB.  The Program is of Korean origin.  The central question is whether the Chinese dubbing and subtitles prepared by TVB would render it to be a substantial production of TVB that falls within condition 36.5 of the Galaxy Licence.

37. On the evidence before me, TVB has spent resources in providing the Chinese dubbing and subtitles.  The dubbing and subtitles have enhanced the quality of the Program and contributed to not an insignificant extent its success and popularity in Hong Kong.  In fact, this point was underscored in the various advertisements promoting the Program.

38. Taking these matters into account, I am of the view that there is a serious question to be tried as to whether the Program is substantially produced by TVB within the meaning of condition 36.5.

39. I next turn to the question of adequacy of damages.  I do not wish to labour on this point.  On the evidence before me, it is clear that damages will not be sufficient for both Hong Kong Cable on the one hand and TVB and Galaxy on the other.

40. This brings me to the balance of convenience.  I wish to mention three points.  The first one is this.  If an injunction is not granted, Galaxy will have a head start over other competitors, including Hong Kong Cable.  Such an unfair head start, I believe, is the mischief that condition 36.5 aims to tackle.

41. The second point is on the availability of the television series on VCD and DVD.  I think only little weight can be attached to this.  It seems that, on the evidence, the Chinese dubbing of the television series on the VCD and DVD is different from that produced by TVB.  The Program, irrespective of its availability on VCD and DVD, is central to Galaxy’s promotion of its channels.  To use a very crude description, the Program is the bait.  And one can see that in the advertisement issued by Galaxy on 7 July 2005.

42. The third point is about the status quo.  The Program has not been broadcast.  The status quo should remain so.

43. I would, therefore, in principle, allow the Program Application, and I would invite submissions later on the precise terms of the injunction to be granted.

The Channels Application

44. I now turn to the Channels Application.  Having regard to counsel’s submissions on the interpretation of the relevant conditions, I am of the view that there is a serious question to be tried on the interpretation as advanced by Mr Yuen, and also on the question of breach on the part of TVB and Galaxy.

45. Mr Smith’s primary submission, as I understand him, is that in its original language (after amendment), the injunction, if granted, is imprecise and hence difficult to police.  It is a potential recipe for further litigation.  There is considerable force in this submission.  Had the Channels Application remained in its original form (after amendment), I would have refused to allow it.

46. In order to meet Mr Smith’s submissions, Mr Yuen, on a without prejudice basis, accepts an injunction to prohibit the broadcasting of the channels until 1 August 2005.  He submits that Hong Kong Cable wants to be placed on a level playing field.  The proposed injunction would put all the parties on a clean start and to enable Hong Kong Cable to consider whether or not to accept the offer made by TVB on 4 July 2005 (which will expire on 1 August 2005).

47. However, as rightly pointed out by Mr Smith, on the evidence before me, Hong Kong Cable complains about not only the head start but also other terms of the offer which, it says, give Galaxy undue preference.  I therefore agree with Mr Smith’s submissions that Hong Kong Cable, on the evidence before me, will, most likely than not, reject the offer anyway.  The proposed injunction will not have any useful purpose other than halting the broadcasting of the channels for about three weeks.  It is not justifiable in the circumstances to grant the injunction.

[Submissions on the terms of the injunction]

48. Subject to the usual undertaking as to damages, there will be an order in terms of the draft order as amended.

[Submissions on costs]

49. On the 1st summons, the appropriate costs order is they are the plaintiff’s costs in the cause, and that would include any costs reserved so far.

50. On the 2nd summons, the plaintiff will have to pay the defendants’ costs in any event, to be taxed if not agreed.

 

 

 ( J. Poon )
Deputy High Court Judge

 

Mr Rimsky Yuen, SC, instructed by Messrs Lovells, for the Plaintiff

Mr Clifford Smith, SC, instructed by Messrs Herbert Smith, for the 1st and 2nd Defendants