HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Part IV Possession Application2012

NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER v. LEE SYN YUK, MICHELLE

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV118/2013YUEN OI YEE LISA v. NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER
  • CACV96/2013魏岳鵬及另一人 對 李善鈺
  • CAMP161/2018YUEN OI YEE LISA v. NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER
  • CAMP217/2019YUEN OI YEE LISA v. NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER
  • CAMP281/2019YUEN OI YEE LISA AND ANOTHER v. NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER
  • CAMP295/2019YUEN OI YEE LISA v. NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER
  • CAMP296/2019YUEN OI YEE LISA v. NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER
  • HCMP1128/2020YUEN OI YEE LISA v. NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER
  • HCMP2155/2018YUEN OI YEE LISA AND ANOTHER v. NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER
  • LDPD2002/2012NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER 對 LEE SYN YUK, MICHELLE

Files (2)

87136-EN-2013-05-10

NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER v. LEE SYN YUK, MICHELLE

HTML content

LDPD3030/2012

IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

APPLICATION NO. LDPD 3030 OF 2012

________________

BETWEEN

 Ngai Ngok Pang1st Applicant
 Ngai Yu Ling Mony2nd Applicant
 and
 Lee Syn Yuk, MichelleRespondent

________________

 

Before: His Honour Judge KO, Presiding Officer of the Lands Tribunal
Date of Decision: 10 May 2013

____________________

DECISION ON REVIEW

____________________

 

1.  By an interlocutory application dated 27 March 2013, the respondent applied:

(a)  to “counterclaim the damages for distress, inconvenience and loss of enjoyment of the premises against the plaintiffs same as my husband’s counterclaims lodged in DCCJ 563/2010”; and

(b)  for “leave to withhold payment of rent to the plaintiffs from 1st May, 2013 unless the plaintiffs will complete all necessary work in those repairs and maintenance being informed to them by my written notice since 19th January 2013”.

2.  On 12 April 2013, I dismissed her application (see my decision handed down on that date).

3.  This is the respondent’s application to review my above decision.  The grounds of review set out in an affirmation of the respondent’s mother (Yuen Oi Yee Lisa) filed on 2 May 2013 (“Ms Yuen’s 3rd affirmation”) are:

“In DCCJ 563/2010, the plaintiff claimed the rental in arrear from my husband. My husband decided for his counterclaims. If the plaintiff claimed her rental in arrear in the Lands Tribunal but not District Court, should my husband make his counterclaims in the Lands Tribunal or District Court despite the plaintiff lodged her claim in the Lands Tribunal as a start?

If my claims for the repairs and maintenance is out of jurisdiction in Lands Tribunal, can the plaintiffs’ claim be passed to the District Court by Lands Tribunal since I will have my counterclaims related to and concerned with the rental in arrear?

I strongly believe my claims for the repairs and maintenance should be within the jurisdiction of Lands Tribunal since the plaintiffs are now claiming their rental in arrear or even mense profits while their application for leave to appeal in HCMP 451/2013 is still pending in the Court of Appeal.

It will be irrational for the Lands Tribunal to trial the plaintiffs’ claim without the defendant’s counterclaims to be made when the counterclaims for repairs are under clauses 14 and 21 of the tenancy agreement.”

4.  The applicants have not filed any submission in response to the review application in accordance with the President’s Direction dated 21 May 2009 [LTPD: Review No 1/2009]. 

Decision on the review application

5.  Previously when I dealt with the respondent’s interlocutory application dated 27 March 2013, I was under the impression that it was supported by the affirmation of Ms Yuen attached to the application (“Ms Yuen’s 1st affirmation”) only.  

6.  In dealing with this review application, I have the opportunity to revisit the documents filed by the parties and it came to light that I had overlooked the affirmation of Ms Yuen filed on 2 April 2013 (“Ms Yuen’s 2nd affirmation”) which was expressed to be: “這誓章支持我在2013年3月27日的申請,尤其我方把應付租金$13,800交法庭指示。”

7.  Since I omitted one of the two supporting affirmations in coming to my previous decision, I decide to review myself in all fairness to the respondent by setting aside my previous order.

8.  Section 11A of the Lands Tribunal Ordinance (Cap 17) provides that:

“The Tribunal may, in any review, hear and receive any evidence it thinks fit for the purpose of determining the issue between the parties.”

9.  So, I shall reconsider the interlocutory application afresh taking into account all 3 affirmations.

Decision on the interlocutory application dated 27 March 2013

10.  What I said in paragraphs 3 to 9 of my previous decision in terms of background is still valid.

11.  I have recounted the gist of Ms Yuen’s 1st affirmation in paragraph 2 of my previous decision.

12.  Ms Yuen’s 2nd affirmation consists of 2 parts. 

(a)  The second part (entitled “Exhibit 2” by Ms Yuen) comprises a draft summons and some correspondences in HCMP 2829/2012. 

(b)  In the first part, Ms Yuen exhibited the original of a cheque drawn by the respondent to the 1st applicant in the sum of $13,800 and deposed that:

“Exhibit 1 – After digesting the contents of letter issued to my daughter, husband and myself by [the 1st applicant] representing the plaintiffs for this proceedings dated 29th August, 2011 with the heading of “Unauthorized and unlawful repair” (our tenancy was only commenced on 1st July, 2011) and the following abnormality and craziness of [the 1st applicant] contained in my below letters addressed to the Clerk to Madam Queeny Au Yeung (written in English) and [the 1st applicant] (written in Chinese) dated 25th March, 2013 (please refer to point 3 and 4 below), I strongly believe that [the 1st applicant] will not do the repairs and maintenance before 30th June, 2013 which had been informed to him by my written notice since 19th January, 2013. Therefore, instead of withholding the rental payment from 1st May to 30th June, 2013 (expiry date in the tenancy agreement) which is purely our rental deposit for two months only, we decide to deposit the cheque for rental from 1st April to 30th April, 2013 of HK$13,800 to your court until the hearing/trial of this proceedings to be held one day perhaps after we may move out by 30th June, 31st July or August 2013 when we may pay the mense profits only after 30th June, 2013, if to be ordered and if any suitable to be paid. Please refer to “Exhibit 1” for the cheque of HK$13,800.00 issued by my daughter when I decide to let your court to withhold it. Please note that this cheque is still valid for 12 months from 1st April, 2013 to 31st March, 2014.

…

In view of all above, please keep the cheque as per “Exhibit 1” until the hearing/trial for this proceedings and my counterclaims for distress, inconvenience and loss of enjoyment of the premises against the plaintiffs will be held one day, perhaps after we will move out by end of June, July or August 2013 or so on…”

13.  In my view, Ms Yuen’s 2nd affirmation is irrelevant.  The proceedings in HCMP 2829/2012 will be dealt with by the Court of First Instance.  If the respondent wants to make payment to the applicants in the meantime, she should do so directly.  If she wants to make a sanctioned payment or sanctioned offer, she should follow the procedure set out in Order 22 of the Rules of the High Court, Cap 4A.  No purpose is served by asking the court to keep the cheque for her until trial.

14.  I remain of the view that the respondent’s interlocutory application should be dismissed for the reasons set out in paragraph 11 of my previous decision.  The respondent is seeking to introduce into this case part of the counterclaim filed by Ms Yuen’s husband in DCCJ 563/2010.  But each case is different, and the respondent may not simply adopt the counterclaim in DCCJ 563/2010 when the parties, the suit premises, the issues and the evidence there are all different. 

15.  The Lands Tribunal may only, in an application for possession or ejectment, make an order for the payment of damages in respect of breach of a condition of the tenancy (see section 8(8) of the Lands Tribunal Ordinance, Cap 17).  A counterclaim is generally treated as an independent action (see Hong Kong Civil Procedure 2013, paragraph 15/2/4).  Since the respondent is not also counterclaiming for possession or ejection, the Lands Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to entertain her claim for damages.

16.  In Ms Yuen’s 3rd affirmation, the respondent seems to suggest that she is presently counterclaiming for “repairs and maintenance”.  That is not correct.  She had previously tried to introduce such a counterclaim into this case by her interlocutory applications dated 30 January 2013 (see paragraph 2 thereof), 7 February 2013 (see paragraph 3 thereof) and 14 February 2013 (see paragraph 2 thereof), but those applications have been dismissed for want of prosecution (see paragraphs 7 and 8 of my previous decision).  The respondent’s present application is in respect of “damages for distress, inconvenience and loss of enjoyment of the premises”.

17.  The respondent also suggests in the last paragraph of Ms Yuen’s 3rd affirmation that “it would be irrational for the Lands Tribunal to [try] the plaintiffs’ claim without the defendant’s counterclaims”.  But that is exactly what happened in the authority cited by the respondent (ie DCCJ 563/2010).  In that case, the landlord claimed against Ms Yuen’s husband as tenant for possession of the suit premises, arrears of rent and mesne profits, and Ms Yuen’s husband filed a counterclaim for unliquidated damages arising out of the undulated floor at the suit premises including damages for inconvenience and loss of enjoyment.  The Master granted summary judgment in favour of the landlord whilst the counterclaim was still pending.  The subsequent appeal of Ms Yuen’s husband against that decision was dismissed, as the Judge found that the counterclaim could not amount to any legal or equitable set-off (see paragraphs 19 to 36 of the judgment dated 25 June 2010).  The counterclaim was eventually tried some 2 years later wherein the court found in favour of Ms Yuen’s husband and awarded him damages including $40,000 for distress, inconvenience and loss of enjoyment of the suit premises (see the judgment dated 10 October 2012).  Thus, the claim and the counterclaim in DCCJ 563/2010 were not tried at the same time.

18.  For the above reasons, I dismiss the respondent’s interlocutory application dated 27 March 2013 with no order as to costs. 

19.  I reiterate my comment in paragraph 12 of my previous decision.  The parties should really focus on the application to the Court of Appeal for leave to appeal against the decisions in LDPD 2002/2012 at this stage.  Unless and until the applicants have elected to proceed with this case, there is no point for anyone to file any submission, evidence or further interlocutory application (such as any application to add a counterclaim).  I therefore substitute paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 5 of my directions dated 27 February 2013 by the following orders:

(1)  The applicants do inform the Tribunal of the result of their application to the Court of Appeal for leave to appeal against the decisions in LDPD 2002/2012 within 14 days of the result becoming available, and the Tribunal will give further direction in Chambers in writing;

(2)  In the meantime, all proceedings herein be stayed and no party may file any submission, evidence or interlocutory application without leave; and

(3)  All applications for leave to uplift the stay or to file any submission, evidence or interlocutory application be made ex parte in writing to me or, in the event of my unavailability, any President Officer and such applications will be dealt with on the papers unless otherwise directed.

20.  This review is disposed of on the papers. Although I have decided to review myself, the result is still not favourable to the respondent.  The applicants have not filed any response. In those circumstances, I make no order as to costs of the review application.

(Justin Ko)
Presiding Officer
Lands Tribunal
86577-EN-2013-04-12

NGAI NGOK PANG AND ANOTHER v. LEE SYN YUK, MICHELLE

HTML content

LDPD3030/2012

IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

APPLICATION NO. LDPD 3030 OF 2012

________________

BETWEEN

 Ngai Ngok Pang1st Applicant
 Ngai Yu Ling Mony2nd Applicant
 and
 Lee Syn Yuk, MichelleRespondent

________________

Before: His Honour Judge KO, Presiding Officer of the Lands Tribunal
Date of Hearing: 10 April 2013
Date of Handing Down Decision: 12 April 2013

_______________

DECISION

_______________

 

1.  By an interlocutory application dated 27 March 2013, the respondent applies:

(a)   “to counterclaim the damages for distress, inconvenience and loss of enjoyment of the premises against the plaintiffs same as my husband’s counterclaims lodged in DCCJ 563/2010”; and

(b)  for “leave to withhold payment of rent to the plaintiffs from 1st May, 2013 unless the plaintiffs will complete all necessary work in those repairs and maintenance being informed to them by my written notice since 19th January 2013”.

2.  The application is supported by an affirmation of the respondent’s mother (Yuen Oi Yee Lisa) in which Ms Yuen drew attention to 2 letters of the applicants and 2 judgments in DCCJ 563/2010.  She complained about the “mentality and craziness” of the applicants and said: “After you have digested and understood the mental sickness of [the 1st applicant], what could I do in order to urge him to do the repairs and maintenance leading to our damages, inconvenience and loss of enjoyment of the Premises?”

Background

3.  The applicants are the owners of the premises known as Flat LC, 47/F, Tower 1, Le Prestige, Lohas Park, 1 Lohas Park Road, Tseung Kwan O, New Territories, and the respondent is their tenant.

4.  This is not the first time the parties are embroiled in legal battle concerning the lease premises.  Previously in LDPD 2002/2012, the applicants applied to recover vacant possession of the premises from the respondent.  That application was dismissed by the Temporary Member after trial (see the judgment dated 15 November 2012).  The applicants’ subsequent applications for review and for leave to appeal were dismissed by the Temporary Member (see the judgments dated 21 January 2013 and 22 February 2013).  The applicants are, as I was told, applying to the Court of Appeal for leave to appeal.

5.  In the meantime, the applicants commenced this application on 14 December 2012 to seek vacant possession from the respondent again.  The application is also opposed.  The new case is said to build upon the findings of LDPD 2002/2012.

6.  The respondent was absent at the first call-over hearing of this case held on 21 January 2013. I adjourned the hearing to 27 February 2013 for the parties to consider whether to appeal against the judgment in LDPD 2002/2012 as the two cases are obviously intertwined.  In view of the fact that the Tribunal had been bombarded with unnecessary paperwork prematurely, I forbade parties to submit further on this case during the adjournment and directed that any interlocutory application should be formally made.

7.  During the adjournment, the respondent took out 3 interlocutory applications trying essentially to introduce a counterclaim into this case.

8.  The respondent was again absent on 27 February 2013, and her 3 applications were dismissed for want of prosecution.  The applicants confirmed at that hearing that they would appeal and that, depending on their success, they may not need to proceed with this case.  I therefore adjourned this case sine die with liberty to restore and directed the applicants to notify the Tribunal of the result of their leave application to the Court of Appeal so that further directions can be given on paper.  I again forbade parties to submit unnecessarily in the meantime and directed all interlocutory applications to be made formally.

9.  It is in those circumstances that the present application was made.

Disposition

10.  The applicants are absent at today’s hearing, but have written in to voice their objection (see their letter dated 5 April 2013, which was copied to the respondent). They said that the present application was made in breach of the Tribunal’s directions and accused the respondent of being unreasonable in making repeating applications both to the Lands Tribunal and in the High Court (e.g. HCMP 2829/2012) which led to the imposition of a restricted application order.

11.  In my view, the respondent’s application must be dismissed.  The Lands Tribunal has only such jurisdiction as has been conferred upon it by legislation.  Unlike the District Court (which adjudicated on DCCJ 563/2010 relied on by the respondent), the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to entertain any counterclaim for damages for distress, inconvenience and loss of enjoyment.  Also, this Tribunal may not rewrite a tenancy agreement to suspend the payment of rent by a tenant for failure of his landlord to effect proper repair and maintenance.

12.  It appears from the papers that both parties have been trying to out-maneuver each other by unnecessary actions in the Lands Tribunal or otherwise.  In my view, these tactical maneuvering are unhelpful and would only serve to complicate matters.  The parties should instead focus on the matter at hand, namely, the intended appeal.

13.  The respondent’s application is therefore dismissed.  No one has applied for costs and I make no order on the costs of the application.  I reiterate my directions dated 27 February 2013 (see the sealed order of that date). 

(Justin Ko)
Presiding Officer
Lands Tribunal

The 1st applicant, absent

The 2nd applicant, absent

The respondent, represented by Ms. YUEN Oi Yee Lisa appeared in person