HK CourtDB
HomeDirectoryMCP
Hong Kong CourtDB
Back to directory
Civil Action2022

YINGGAO RESOURCES LTD AND OTHERS v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD

Related cases with same parties

  • CACV117/2014GURDAS S CHOITHRAMANI v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • CACV213/2017LAU YU also known as JAFFE LAU v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • CACV466/2021POOSAALA RAM PRASAD v. THE HONG KONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • CACV74/2015CHOITHRAMANI GURDAS SABHAGCHAND v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • CACV77/2007LOKE MEI YUK, MIMI v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • CACV84/2015LI CHUNG YAN HILDA v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • CACV86/2015MANN KEVIN PATRICK v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • CACV86/2021GURDAS SABHAGCHAND CHOITHRAMANI v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • CAMP103/2025POOSAALA RAM PRASAD v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • CAMP296/2022YINGGAO RESOURCES LTD AND OTHERS v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • CAMP81/2018THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD v. SY SHUN WU AND OTHERS
  • CAMP94/2023YINGGAO RESOURCES LTD AND ANOTHER v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • DCCJ1251/2003THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD 訴 TONG CHI CHEONG
  • DCMP1349/2006THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD 訴 張偉乾
  • DCMP1555/2024HIP LIK PACKAGING PRODUCTS FACTORY LTD v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • DCMP1591/2023CHEN BEI v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • DCMP2460/2000THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD v. HUI LAI KAI AND OTHERS
  • HCA1020/2015PA SAM NANG AND OTHERS v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • HCA1218/2018COLVIN MORTON BROWN v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD
  • HCA1924/2016FRANK LEE AND ANOTHER v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD

Files (2)

[2022] HKCFI 2335-EN-2022-07-28

YINGGAO RESOURCES LTD AND OTHERS v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD

HTML content

HCA 128/2022

[2022] HKCFI 2335

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO 128 OF 2022

____________

BETWEEN

 YINGGAO RESOURCES LIMITED1st Plaintiff
 WINBEST RESOURCES LIMITED2nd Plaintiff
 WINKO FOUNDATION LIMITED3rd Plaintiff

and

 THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LIMITEDDefendant

____________

Before: Hon Au-Yeung J in Chambers

Closing Date for Written Submission: 21 July 2022

Date of Decision: 28 July 2022

______________

D E C I S I O N

______________


Introduction

1.  On 6 June 2022, this Court upheld the Master’s decision granting extension of time for the Defendant to file its defence after determination of the appeal in HCA 329/2015 (“Decision”). This is the Plaintiffs’ application for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal against the Decision.

Legal principles for leave to appeal

2.  The court must be satisfied that the appeal has a reasonable prospect of success or there is some other reason in the interests of justice why the appeal should be heard before granting leave. Reasonable prospect of success involves the notion that the prospects of succeeding must be ‘reasonable’ and therefore more than ‘fanciful’, without having to be ‘probable’: SMSE v KL [2009] 4 HKLRD 125 at §17.

3.  An appeal against the case management decision of the court below is a type of an appeal against exercise of discretion: Hong Kong Civil Procedure 2022, §59/0/55. The appellant faces a very high hurdle and has to show that the judge had gone clearly wrong and made orders which clearly involved an injustice to an inability for the trial court to carry out its task or had erred in principle or that his/her order was irrational: Hong Kong Civil Procedure 2022, at §59/0/55.

Analyses of the 4 intended grounds of appeal

4.  It has to be borne in mind that the Plaintiffs have not made any submission at the hearing on 6 June 2022 (“Hearing”) except to apply for an adjournment. The Hearing concerned extension of time for filing a defence, which was a fresh exercise of discretion by the judge on appeal. The Plaintiffs have not shown how this Court has clearly gone wrong. The application for leave to appeal is thus totally unjustified. In any case, the Grounds of Appeal do not bear scrutiny.

Ground 1

5.  The Plaintiffs seek to appeal against this Court’s refusal to grant them an adjournment of the Hearing. The Decision has taken into account the Plaintiffs’ prior application for adjournment by letter which was rejected and the lack of complication in the matter (Decision, §5).

6.  In the submission in reply, the Plaintiffs assert that this Court had held a double standard in giving a chance for the Defendant to object to the Plaintiffs’ application by letter but failed to provide a chance for the Plaintiffs to reply to it. That assertion was never raised at the Hearing.

7.  Refusal to adjourn was effectively a case management decision. The Plaintiffs have not shown how this Court fell within the principle in paragraph 3 above. Ground 1 is not arguable.

Grounds 2-4

8.  These grounds effectively re-run the views of the Plaintiffs’ solicitors that the reference notes in Form 14 amounted to an unless order, which the Defendant had failed to comply with and failed to apply for relief from sanctions.

9.  Not only had the Decision held those views to be erroneous, but 2 other Courts have come to the same holding: Young Crystal Limited & Orsv Hang Seng Bank Limited[2022] HKCFI 1589 at §§17 to 20, Cheng J; Guangdong Yinggao Shipping Limited v Secretary for Justice[2022] HKCFI 305, DHCJ Le Pichon, §§12 to 17.

10.  Further, Ground 4 refers to Order 42, rule 4(1) and (2) which were irrelevant and not advanced at the Hearing.

11.  Grounds 2-4 do not disclose arguable grounds of law.

Conclusion and costs

12.  As none of the Grounds have any reasonable prospect of success, I dismiss the application for leave to appeal.

13.  The Plaintiffs’ arguments have been considered in the cases of Young Crystal and Guangdong Yinggao Shipping. The Plaintiffs have been made aware of the latter at the hearing before the Master whose decision was appealed against at the Hearing. The Plaintiffs’ solicitors were solicitors acting for the Plaintiff in Young Crystal and the Plaintiffs’ solicitors should have been aware of their erroneous views of the law.

14.  As the present application is wholly unmeritorious, I make an order nisi for the Plaintiffs to bear costs on indemnity basis, summarily assessed at $47,201.80.

 (Queeny Au-Yeung)
 Judge of the Court of First Instance
 High Court

Written Submission by KH Mak & Co, for the 1st to 3rd Plaintiffs

Written Submission by Messrs Mayer Brown, for the Defendant

[2022] HKCFI 1704-EN-2022-06-06

YINGGAO RESOURCES LTD AND OTHERS v. THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LTD

HTML content

HCA 128/2022

[2022] HKCFI 1704

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO 128 OF 2022

____________

BETWEEN  
 YINGGAO RESOURCES LIMITED1st Plaintiff
 WINBEST RESOURCES LIMITED2nd Plaintiff
 WINKO FOUNDATION LIMITED3rd Plaintiff
 and 
 THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LIMITEDDefendant

____________

Before:  Hon Au-Yeung J in Chambers

Dates of Hearing:  6 June 2022

Date of Decision:  6 June 2022

______________

D E C I S I O N

______________

1.  This is the Plaintiffs’ appeal against a Master’s decision giving extension of time for the Defendant to file and serve its defence.

2.  By way of background, the 1st and 2nd Plaintiffs in this action are the Plaintiffs in HCA 329/2015 and the Defendant here is the Defendant in that action as well. The Plaintiffs in HCA 329/2015 got leave to re-amend their statement of claim (“amendment order”). The Defendant appeals against that amendment order, which would be heard on 28 July 2022 (“the Defendant’s Appeal”).

3.  On 4 May 2022, upon the Defendant’s application in the present action, Master Kent Yee gave leave to the Defendant to file and serve its defence after determination of the Defendant’s Appeal. This is the Plaintiffs’ appeal against Master Kent Yee’s order.

4.  Today, the Plaintiffs appear by counsel. Their solicitors only came on record on 2 June 2022 (Thursday), just before the long weekend, and the Defendant’s solicitors were informed late in that afternoon.

5.  The Plaintiffs have not lodged any written submission. Ms Cheung, counsel for the Plaintiffs, informs the Court that she does not have instructions to substantively proceed with arguing the appeal and sought an adjournment of 21 days. I refuse because a prior application by letter to adjourn today’s hearing has been declined on 30 May 2022; and there is no complication at all in this appeal.

6.  Upon being notified that the adjournment is refused, Ms Cheung asks the Court to permit the Plaintiffs to address the Court as her instructing solicitors’ instructions are limited to today’s application. I refuse that application also. The Plaintiffs’ solicitors are on record. It is up to the Plaintiffs to give their solicitors the proper instructions to proceed with the appeal. The Defendant’s solicitors had, on 1 June already served a bundle of documents and skeleton submission on the Plaintiffs’ former solicitors, K H Mak & Co. I am informed by Mr Chan, solicitor for the Defendant, that he has offered to pass a spare bundle of documents to the Plaintiffs’ current lawyers this morning but that was not accepted. The Plaintiffs have not made the best out of the circumstances to pursue their application.

7.  I therefore dismiss the appeal.

8.  In any case, the appeal has no merits. As disclosed in the affirmation filed by the Plaintiffs before Master Kent Yee, the Plaintiffs considered that the reference notes in Form 14 (the acknowledgement of service), which set out the time limit for a defendant to file its defence within 28 days from expiry of the time for filing its acknowledgement of service, had the effect of an “unless order”. They suggested that the Defendant should seek relief from sanction within 14 days after non-compliance. The Plaintiffs were then legally represented by K H Mak & Co.

9.  The Plaintiffs were plainly mistaken in their interpretation of the reference notes in Form 14. There was in fact no order with an “unless” provision that specified the consequence of non-compliance. The Master had power to extend time for filing a defence pursuant to Order 3, rule 5 of the Rules of the High Court.

10.  Further, the statement of claim in the present case largely overlaps that in HCA 329/2015. If a defence is filed now, it may have to be substantially amended if the Defendant’s Appeal is successful. There will be not much prejudice to the Plaintiffs to defer the filing of the defence in the present action since the Defendant has been given time to file its amended defence in HCA 329/2015 to 28 days after determination of the Defendant’s Appeal.

11.  For the reasons given, I dismiss the appeal as being wholly unmeritorious.

12.  Costs should be to the Defendant, which should include the costs of preparing the hearing bundles. The arguments are practically a re-run of those before the Master. I order the Plaintiffs to pay costs of $35,000 to the Defendant.

(Queeny Au-Yeung)
Judge of the Court of First Instance
High Court

Ms Michelle Cheung, instructed by C K Mok & Co, for the 1st to 3rd Plaintiffs

Mr Chan Ngai Hung, of Messrs Mayer Brown, for the Defendant